What Would You Replace Your LC With?
Thread Starter
Advanced
Joined: Jul 2017
Posts: 741
Likes: 330
From: FL
What Would You Replace Your LC With?
Hey guys, I made a video recently, discussing possible replacements to the LC. This doesn't necessarily mean I want to get rid of her right away, but lately I've been getting the itch to find a replacement - keep in mind I've had her for about 5 years now. Like I said in my video, a little difficult to find a true replacement. Frankly, if Lexus came out with a next gen LC or an LFA 2 (as rumoured), I'd definitely stick with Lexus. Curious to know if any of you have driven/owned some of the choices I mentioned (AMG GT-R, Aston Martin Vantage, Nissan GT-R, Nissan NSX)? I know that the majority of these are a little sportier, but they do tick most of the boxes.
I went to Aston to build an F1 Edition Vantage - they'd sell it to me at MSRP - approximately $187K. Went to 3 different Porsche dealers to SERIOUSLY order a GT4 RS - all allocations already taken - AND worst of all, each one told me that they would have a markup of anywhere between $50K - $150K (with exact pricing when the build would begin). IMO, I love that GT4 RS, but that markup is ludicrous.
Nevertheless, I still love my LC, and wanted to get some of your opinions. Thanks!
I went to Aston to build an F1 Edition Vantage - they'd sell it to me at MSRP - approximately $187K. Went to 3 different Porsche dealers to SERIOUSLY order a GT4 RS - all allocations already taken - AND worst of all, each one told me that they would have a markup of anywhere between $50K - $150K (with exact pricing when the build would begin). IMO, I love that GT4 RS, but that markup is ludicrous.
Nevertheless, I still love my LC, and wanted to get some of your opinions. Thanks!
Intermediate
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 263
Likes: 170
From: SG
Definitely consider a 911. That was the only other car I would consider when shopping for my car and even though the LC500 won, if it did not exist, the 911 would definitely be the one I would buy. It has the right image, the engine has some character, it drives really well, and with the right options, can be pretty luxurious on the inside as well
Aston Martins are simply way too outdated interior wise and they will almost certainly be unreliable. And I dont think they look that good, they most definitely do not age very well at all
Nissan GT-R likewise too outdated inside and out, and I think severely lacking in luxury
I like the AMG GT but it is a 2 seater. I skipped this car because i needed a 2 + 2 as I would just have one car and I need one that can do it all. If you need a (barely usable) back seat, maybe one of the new SL55s? The new SLs do look amazing and the US spec cars sound pretty good without the OPF but you must like open top motoring (or maybe wait for the hardtop which is coming at some point)
I still think the LC500 is an overall better car (all things considered) than all of those options above though, honestly. But thats just me. If I had to choose something else it would be a well specced base 911 or an SL55.
Aston Martins are simply way too outdated interior wise and they will almost certainly be unreliable. And I dont think they look that good, they most definitely do not age very well at all
Nissan GT-R likewise too outdated inside and out, and I think severely lacking in luxury
I like the AMG GT but it is a 2 seater. I skipped this car because i needed a 2 + 2 as I would just have one car and I need one that can do it all. If you need a (barely usable) back seat, maybe one of the new SL55s? The new SLs do look amazing and the US spec cars sound pretty good without the OPF but you must like open top motoring (or maybe wait for the hardtop which is coming at some point)
I still think the LC500 is an overall better car (all things considered) than all of those options above though, honestly. But thats just me. If I had to choose something else it would be a well specced base 911 or an SL55.
Last edited by breplica; Aug 9, 2022 at 06:02 AM.
Advanced
Joined: May 2021
Posts: 722
Likes: 315
From: Georgia
I am a Lexus fan thru & thru. I’ve never contemplated the idea of replacing my LC. For me she is a keeper. However, I may consider buying another vehicle, maybe the LFA2 if I can get in and out of it. Or maybe an all electric Lexus. All in all, I have no immediate plans on changing brands. We only ride Toyota round here! 
Instructor
Joined: Mar 2015
Posts: 1,189
Likes: 823
From: Vancouver BC
Move on to the next big thing man. All cars get boring after a while. Just buy what you like, although i do caution you that the AM Vantage has a horrible interior. The plastic buttons are a god damn joke for something of that caliber
i crossed shopped these ones below
Ferrari Roma - love the lines of the Roma the best. But they wanted a 2 year wait
Ferrari Portofino - wanted the vert, but not my first choice because of the Roma. Also 1-2 year wait
Maserati MC20 - 1-2 year wait and also that v6 TT is questionable
Bentley Continental GT convertible - wife's choice, but i wasnt too keen on it
AM Vantage convertible - i almost bought this, but the interior is garbage and the wait time is still 6months - 1 year
911 - the safe choice, but actually the least interesting for me. I dont track, i dont care about outright performance, and they are dime a dozen in vancouver
So i ended up with this LC as my "fun" car and its probably the most sensible purchase out of this list of GT's.
i crossed shopped these ones below
Ferrari Roma - love the lines of the Roma the best. But they wanted a 2 year wait
Ferrari Portofino - wanted the vert, but not my first choice because of the Roma. Also 1-2 year wait
Maserati MC20 - 1-2 year wait and also that v6 TT is questionable
Bentley Continental GT convertible - wife's choice, but i wasnt too keen on it
AM Vantage convertible - i almost bought this, but the interior is garbage and the wait time is still 6months - 1 year
911 - the safe choice, but actually the least interesting for me. I dont track, i dont care about outright performance, and they are dime a dozen in vancouver
So i ended up with this LC as my "fun" car and its probably the most sensible purchase out of this list of GT's.
Last edited by Badhobz; Aug 9, 2022 at 07:40 AM.
Driver School Candidate
Joined: Mar 2022
Posts: 23
Likes: 13
From: MD
So my personal car history since 2007 to the present is as follows. 2007 bought my first Corvette (new) C6. At the time I assumed it would be my forever car. I never found another car I would rather have and kept it 9 years. My only wish was that I should have bought the stick as opposed to the auto trans. Got the itch in 2016 for a C7 ordered it with the 7 speed. Loved the stick for the 1st year then the novelty wore off, somehow it was not the same as 4spds of the late 60 muscle cars. Honestly I liked my C6 better. 4 years later bought a Tundra (flawless truck) still have it today but got the itch for a new C8. Got on a wait list that lasted 15 months with still no allocation. The wife wanted a new RX 350 thats when I got up close and personal with the LC in the showroom. I saved my money for the C8, I was too close to retiring and did not want a car payment.The 2022 was about 20K above my budget. Our sales guy mentioned an L/ Certified LC.. Next thing you know they got a 2019 in and I bought it before it even hit the inventory.
Love this car, it is rare and does get an extreme amount of attention. Could be my forever car who knows. As of now nothing sparks my interest.
Love this car, it is rare and does get an extreme amount of attention. Could be my forever car who knows. As of now nothing sparks my interest.
Trending Topics
Instructor
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 934
Likes: 198
From: N. CA
So my personal car history since 2007 to the present is as follows. 2007 bought my first Corvette (new) C6. At the time I assumed it would be my forever car. I never found another car I would rather have and kept it 9 years. My only wish was that I should have bought the stick as opposed to the auto trans. Got the itch in 2016 for a C7 ordered it with the 7 speed. Loved the stick for the 1st year then the novelty wore off, somehow it was not the same as 4spds of the late 60 muscle cars. Honestly I liked my C6 better. 4 years later bought a Tundra (flawless truck) still have it today but got the itch for a new C8. Got on a wait list that lasted 15 months with still no allocation. The wife wanted a new RX 350 thats when I got up close and personal with the LC in the showroom. I saved my money for the C8, I was too close to retiring and did not want a car payment.The 2022 was about 20K above my budget. Our sales guy mentioned an L/ Certified LC.. Next thing you know they got a 2019 in and I bought it before it even hit the inventory.
Love this car, it is rare and does get an extreme amount of attention. Could be my forever car who knows. As of now nothing sparks my interest.
Love this car, it is rare and does get an extreme amount of attention. Could be my forever car who knows. As of now nothing sparks my interest.
ClubLexus Stories
Celebrating Lexus & Toyota from Around the Globe
8 Tips for Improving Your Hybrid or Plug-in Hybrid's Efficiency!
Michael S. Palmer
10 Best Lexus Models No One Remembers
Joe Kucinski
TRD Off-Road Premium: Best 2026 4Runner, Except This One Thing
Michael S. Palmer
Top 10 Lexus & Toyotas to Drive Before You Die!
Joe Kucinski
Top 10 Lexus/Toyotas With The LEAST 5-Year Depreciation
Joe Kucinski
Lexus LC500 Convertible Auction: A Preview of Rising Values?
Brett Foote
GX 550 vs TX 550: Best 3-Row Luxury Lexus Family Hauler
Michael S. Palmer
9 Best Lexus Models You Can Buy for Half Price (And 1 You Shouldn't!)
Joe Kucinski
2026 Lexus NX Buyer's Guide: Models, Features, Prices & More!
Brett Foote
Pit Crew
Joined: Dec 2018
Posts: 182
Likes: 43
From: EP
You have to consider the fact that the LC is a true daily use car. The Nissan GTR is not, as an example, as it got low clearance, very high maintenance cost for a Nissan l, and no where close to the comfy ride of the LC.
The LC is hard to replace in my opinion. Looks wise I think the new 911 is well designed especially if you will go with wide body models. MBZ GT looks amazing but I assume that a facelift/new generation is on the way soon.
after all, it all depends on your budget. Some of the new entry level Ferrari’s are made for daily use, but you will pay 200k+
The LC is hard to replace in my opinion. Looks wise I think the new 911 is well designed especially if you will go with wide body models. MBZ GT looks amazing but I assume that a facelift/new generation is on the way soon.
after all, it all depends on your budget. Some of the new entry level Ferrari’s are made for daily use, but you will pay 200k+
Driver School Candidate
Joined: Mar 2022
Posts: 23
Likes: 13
From: MD
My wife wanted a new RX as well, but I decided that the 2023 RX is coming and might as well wait for it. Hit the showroom with her and she actually liked the NX better, smaller than her RX and seats a little lower. We are waiting for a few more months and see what happens in the car market, all the dealers here in the SF Bay Area wants $2K markup on any Hybrid except one dealer, but they do tack on some BS accessories for $700.
Pit Crew
Joined: Dec 2020
Posts: 121
Likes: 97
From: CT
Replacing LC with 911 would be different driving experience.I own both and love them but LC is much more GT car.It is also more comfortable. The Porsche is AWD and handles like a go-cart. They are both great cars and can't go wrong with either.
