Throttle too aggressive
I did a surface search on the threads but couldn't find these topics, so here goes;
1) The throttle is VERY aggressive! The slightest pedal movement from a standing stop may chirp the tires on a warm street and if its raining, the risk of spinning the tires from a stop is always there. It feels like there is a gap between the pedal and the engine. I know its a drive by wire system, so visualize a dead spot in the pedal switch resistor.
2) Couple that with the transmission shifting 1-2-3 gear as the car crosses an intersection, then back to 2nd gear as it accelerates. I cant help but think there's a connection between the two issues. It shifts way to early in my opinion, I think it should hold the gears a bit longer.
As a comparison, my son has a 2020 ES-350 (same engine, probably the same trans too) and its flawless. My former 2016 ES-350 didn't exhibit this problem either.
The dealer drove it and couldn't recommend anything since there are no faults stored in the computer and no active TSB's. I have sort of lost confidence in their willingness to resolve these issues. I'm not in a position to toss them a blank check to experiment with parts swapping or experimental programming.
These issues are not deal breakers and only a bit frustrating. We have driven the car another 30,000 miles since then.
I did a surface search on the threads but couldn't find these topics, so here goes;
1) The throttle is VERY aggressive! The slightest pedal movement from a standing stop may chirp the tires on a warm street and if its raining, the risk of spinning the tires from a stop is always there. It feels like there is a gap between the pedal and the engine. I know its a drive by wire system, so visualize a dead spot in the pedal switch resistor.
2) Couple that with the transmission shifting 1-2-3 gear as the car crosses an intersection, then back to 2nd gear as it accelerates. I cant help but think there's a connection between the two issues. It shifts way to early in my opinion, I think it should hold the gears a bit longer.
As a comparison, my son has a 2020 ES-350 (same engine, probably the same trans too) and its flawless. My former 2016 ES-350 didn't exhibit this problem either.
The dealer drove it and couldn't recommend anything since there are no faults stored in the computer and no active TSB's. I have sort of lost confidence in their willingness to resolve these issues. I'm not in a position to toss them a blank check to experiment with parts swapping or experimental programming.
These issues are not deal breakers and only a bit frustrating. We have driven the car another 30,000 miles since then.
You never mentioned if the throttle problem was there when you first bought the car. Sensors can be very touchy and there are two working together here. You have the gas pedal sensor and the sensor connected to the throttle servo motor. It could also be the mass air flow sensor, vacuum leak, gas pedal adjustment, or 20 other things. There should be a fault stored. Take it to a Toyota dealer and see what they say. Since this seems to be a rare problem, dealerships don't want to use a lot of time trying to figure it out. It costs them money.
Last edited by jcg0324; Jan 28, 2025 at 01:16 PM.
There are no codes stored, either pending, live, or historic. One person asked if it was like an old car with a bad accelerator pump. Its more like 90% of performance in the first 5% of throttle movement, very aggressive.
Like I said, its not a deal breaker, just a slight annoyance. My wife is the primary driver and she says she has gotten used to it. Also, the local Toyota dealer wont look at the car except for customer pay service(!) even though its practically the same as the Highlander.
There are no codes stored, either pending, live, or historic. One person asked if it was like an old car with a bad accelerator pump. Its more like 90% of performance in the first 5% of throttle movement, very aggressive.
Like I said, its not a deal breaker, just a slight annoyance. My wife is the primary driver and she says she has gotten used to it. Also, the local Toyota dealer wont look at the car except for customer pay service(!) even though its practically the same as the Highlander.
Trending Topics
Celebrating Lexus & Toyota from Around the Globe
Its hard to quantify how much movement of the pedal I press but I assure you that it is minimal.
As an engineer with considerable automotive experience, albeit with no access to the inner workings of the PCM, its puzzling. To get one more step technical, if any of these readers are familiar with an electrical POT, visualize a dead spot in the coil where the arm moves from one section to the other. Or a resistor that is connected to a lever, where the lever arm requires minimal movement to actuate the resistor.
Its hard to quantify how much movement of the pedal I press but I assure you that it is minimal.
As an engineer with considerable automotive experience, albeit with no access to the inner workings of the PCM, its puzzling. To get one more step technical, if any of these readers are familiar with an electrical POT, visualize a dead spot in the coil where the arm moves from one section to the other. Or a resistor that is connected to a lever, where the lever arm requires minimal movement to actuate the resistor.
The Accelerator Pedal Position Sensor and the Throttle Position Sensor (integrated to the throttle motor) has a potentiometer. These sensors are the one that sends the signal to the PCM to know how much throttle is being demanded. You would need to confirm if the resistor inside is working properly. You can easily do that with a generic scan tool by looking at live data and slowly depressing the accelerator pedal. On the other hand, do you have anything connected to the Accelerator Pedal Position Sensor, such as a throttle commander? This modifies the signal telling the PCM the throttle demand is higher than normal.
Looks like we've got a few Engineers on this board.
The Accelerator Pedal Position Sensor and the Throttle Position Sensor (integrated to the throttle motor) has a potentiometer. These sensors are the one that sends the signal to the PCM to know how much throttle is being demanded. You would need to confirm if the resistor inside is working properly. You can easily do that with a generic scan tool by looking at live data and slowly depressing the accelerator pedal. On the other hand, do you have anything connected to the Accelerator Pedal Position Sensor, such as a throttle commander? This modifies the signal telling the PCM the throttle demand is higher than normal.
Looks like we've got a few Engineers on this board.
Before the days of scantools, my seat of the pants feeling would be a defective throttle actuator at the pedal and possibly the TPS sensor at the throttlebody. Since there are no codes, the dealer is reluctant to chase the rabbit unless I open my wallet, and I'm too tight to open that door!
My son as a throttle commander on his Raptor and it totally changed the trucks driving attitude, and would almost exactly replicate what I am experiencing here, and no, I dont have one installed.
I have access to a scan tool and might dig into it to look at the commanded voltage and throttle opening ratio in degrees of rotation per second. It will have to wait for a couple of weeks before I can do this.
Welcoming all thoughts and suggestions, thanks!










