I went with a Blue Dog due to it still lets you close the lid.
https://bluedogdesignwerks.com/produ...-holder-insert

 

If you want to get the tabs pulled back out, this is not very difficult. You can get the cup holder section out and usually fix it unless some part is actually broken. I had one tab get stuck, it moved but lost the spring pressure. Easily fixed once I got the cup holder out.