Luxury: German vs Japanese
#31
exclusive matchup
iTrader: (4)
if i had to choose IS vs. 3 series, i'd get 3 series
if i had to choose GS vs. 5 series, i'd get 5 series (or an ES and save a bundle)
if i had to choose LS vs. 7 series, i'd get the LS
if i had to choose RX vs. X5, i'd get the RX (450h)
for benz, i'd get C class over IS, E over GS, S over LS, but i'd still get an RX over a ML/GLK.
if i had to choose GS vs. 5 series, i'd get 5 series (or an ES and save a bundle)
if i had to choose LS vs. 7 series, i'd get the LS
if i had to choose RX vs. X5, i'd get the RX (450h)
for benz, i'd get C class over IS, E over GS, S over LS, but i'd still get an RX over a ML/GLK.
#32
Moderator
Example; when one is a new owner of a cellphone that person configures the cellphone to their liking, ways, etc. So the new owners of the once upon a time British car companies take over they will eventually configure their newly acquired British company to their liking, ways, etc. Eventually the new owners will suggest their own engineering processes and procedures, philosophies, techniques, management, influence, etc. and so on.
Last edited by Trexus; 11-08-10 at 12:31 PM.
#33
I'm surprised that when considering luxury, BRITISH cars are not the first to be thought about.
Jaguar
Land Rover
Bentley
Rolls Royce
Aston Martin
Lotus
If we're talking about luxury and luxury alone, which include an excess of grandeur, opulence, and accommodation; British cars far surpass German and Japanese makes.
Jaguar
Land Rover
Bentley
Rolls Royce
Aston Martin
Lotus
If we're talking about luxury and luxury alone, which include an excess of grandeur, opulence, and accommodation; British cars far surpass German and Japanese makes.
Lotus doesn't really qualify as a luxury brand. They primarily make hard-core sports cars aimed at enthusiasts. Try taking an extended road trip in one, in comfort, with kids and luggage.
Aston's are quite luxurious. But across the whole line-up, are primarily GT cars, verging on exotic/supercar status and out of reach of the average luxury car buyer.
Bentley and Rolls Royce, while defining luxury and opulence, like Aston, again, are just too far out of reach for the average luxo shopper.
So that really only leaves Jaguar and Range Rover. And of those two, only Jag offers a full line-up of sedans that fit into the price-range of the typical American luxury car buyer.
For the original question? It really comes down to what a buyer wants in a luxo-car. For some, luxury is all about a plush, quiet ride, while tooling down the road, with no care for how the car corners when pushed hard, or how fast it can lap the 'Ring. I think that this is where the majority of Americans who buy luxury brands lie. But others are more than willing to sacrifice some of the amenities for performance bragging rights. This is generally the "enthusiast" crowd.
For me, where the car is made makes no real difference. German, Japanese, British, or even American luxury cars all need to stand on their own merits, in their class, against their competition.
I'm an enthusiast. So generally, for example, I'll take a 3-series over an IS. But the IS over the C-class. Sure, my buddy's new C300 is much nicer and more refined a car than my IS-300, but is nowhere near as rewarding to drive on a twisty back road. At track days, the MB and Lexus don't compare to the 3-Series for pure driving bliss, but if I was going to spend a week driving to Florida and back, give me the Mercedes.
So it all just comes down to what you want the car to do for you....
#34
Mercedes was the gold standard. What always impresses me is how the S class and the E class both drive smaller than they are. They're relatively nimble for their size and have a small turn radius. Also the highspeed freeway handling is phenomenal but I feel the suspension is too soft for me
BMWs are great in the twisties but have become too heavy and too gadgety for their own good. Look at the evolution of the M3 over time. The company also seems unresponsive to buyers over things like HPFP, bad water pumps, runflats.
Lexus excels in reliability and resale (hand in hand) b/c they are designed to last while the germans are designed to last for two ownership periods at most. Ever wonder why the resale plummets for a German car out of warranty? B/c the electronics, transmissions and suspension bits start to fall apart
Where a car is put together does matter. Not a brand thing but the actual reliability of that model (think early MLs and BMW X5s). If I'm paying a German price, I want German precision in the actual build of the unit. Same goes for Lexus
BMWs are great in the twisties but have become too heavy and too gadgety for their own good. Look at the evolution of the M3 over time. The company also seems unresponsive to buyers over things like HPFP, bad water pumps, runflats.
Lexus excels in reliability and resale (hand in hand) b/c they are designed to last while the germans are designed to last for two ownership periods at most. Ever wonder why the resale plummets for a German car out of warranty? B/c the electronics, transmissions and suspension bits start to fall apart
Where a car is put together does matter. Not a brand thing but the actual reliability of that model (think early MLs and BMW X5s). If I'm paying a German price, I want German precision in the actual build of the unit. Same goes for Lexus
#35
Lexus Champion
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: California
Posts: 1,832
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My personal preference is in the following order:
1. Lexus
2. BMW
3. Audi
4. Porsche
5. Mercedes-Benz
6. Infiniti
And I don't like Volvo, Saab, Acura, Jaguar, Cadillac, and Lincoln.
Then my favorite vehicles in each category are:
Luxury sedan: Lexus LS, Mercedes-Benz E-class sedan
Sports sedan: BMW 3-series sedan, Infiniti G sedan, Lexus IS sedan
Sports coupe: Audi RS5/S5/A5 coupe, BMW 3-series coupe
Luxury SUV: BMW X6
Crossover: Audi Q5, Lexus RX
Sports car: Porsche 911-series
Roadster: Porsche Boxster
I like Porsche's and BMW's and Audi's sportiness. I like Lexus' and Benz's luxury. I like Infiniti's improvement and I believe it would eventually catch up with those major players.
1. Lexus
2. BMW
3. Audi
4. Porsche
5. Mercedes-Benz
6. Infiniti
And I don't like Volvo, Saab, Acura, Jaguar, Cadillac, and Lincoln.
Then my favorite vehicles in each category are:
Luxury sedan: Lexus LS, Mercedes-Benz E-class sedan
Sports sedan: BMW 3-series sedan, Infiniti G sedan, Lexus IS sedan
Sports coupe: Audi RS5/S5/A5 coupe, BMW 3-series coupe
Luxury SUV: BMW X6
Crossover: Audi Q5, Lexus RX
Sports car: Porsche 911-series
Roadster: Porsche Boxster
I like Porsche's and BMW's and Audi's sportiness. I like Lexus' and Benz's luxury. I like Infiniti's improvement and I believe it would eventually catch up with those major players.
#37
Lexus Champion
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: CA
Posts: 2,439
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My personal preference is in the following order:
1. Lexus
2. BMW
3. Audi
4. Porsche
5. Mercedes-Benz
6. Infiniti
And I don't like Volvo, Saab, Acura, Jaguar, Cadillac, and Lincoln.
Then my favorite vehicles in each category are:
Luxury sedan: Lexus LS, Mercedes-Benz E-class sedan
Sports sedan: BMW 3-series sedan, Infiniti G sedan, Lexus IS sedan
Sports coupe: Audi RS5/S5/A5 coupe, BMW 3-series coupe
Luxury SUV: BMW X6
Crossover: Audi Q5, Lexus RX
Sports car: Porsche 911-series
Roadster: Porsche Boxster
I like Porsche's and BMW's and Audi's sportiness. I like Lexus' and Benz's luxury. I like Infiniti's improvement and I believe it would eventually catch up with those major players.
1. Lexus
2. BMW
3. Audi
4. Porsche
5. Mercedes-Benz
6. Infiniti
And I don't like Volvo, Saab, Acura, Jaguar, Cadillac, and Lincoln.
Then my favorite vehicles in each category are:
Luxury sedan: Lexus LS, Mercedes-Benz E-class sedan
Sports sedan: BMW 3-series sedan, Infiniti G sedan, Lexus IS sedan
Sports coupe: Audi RS5/S5/A5 coupe, BMW 3-series coupe
Luxury SUV: BMW X6
Crossover: Audi Q5, Lexus RX
Sports car: Porsche 911-series
Roadster: Porsche Boxster
I like Porsche's and BMW's and Audi's sportiness. I like Lexus' and Benz's luxury. I like Infiniti's improvement and I believe it would eventually catch up with those major players.
You're the first person to respond the question I asked in the original post, and for that, I commend you.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post