Car Chat General discussion about Lexus, other auto manufacturers and automotive news.

Infiniti more dangerous than Lexus says BMW

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 01-19-07, 12:39 PM
  #91  
RON430
Lexus Fanatic
 
RON430's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: California
Posts: 6,084
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by mmarshall
EXACTLY.

In fact, Mike, I wish that more Lexuses WERE like sofas. Although the new LS460 is still quite comfortable, most of the rest of the Lexus pasenger-car-line, especially the new ES350, have been noticiably stiffened in an effort to compete with BMW ( The IS, of course, was always a little on the stiff side ) . And, for sports enthusiasts, of course, that is not a bad thing. And I agree that Lexus SHOULD have a comfort branch for people who like easy-riders AND a sporting branch for those who like to carve up the twisties. But, lately, like with some other manufactuerers, sport suspensions, tires, and dynamics seem to be proliferating everywhere.....and almost completely taking over even what SHOULD be left in the "comfort" column.
You know, this is a great point. Reducing lap times on that billiard table of a track, the Nurburgring, by stiffening up spring rates, bushings, bars, and using stiffer sidewall tires is something that any moron, high school student, or aftermarket tuner could do. Getting balance between ride and handling is something that takes some intelligence if not a bank of supercomputers. And this is precisely what Lexus should be doing. I do not want a race car for the street. But that awful "freeway float" that has defined a few generations of Lexus, is also not what I want. And Lexus is not alone in stiffening up suspensions. Most all of the brands we regularly talk about have done that including BMW. Some of it may be simply the side effect of the great rush for those cool looking and hard riding low profile tires. The silky balance that BMW once had between ride and handling is long gone. I won't rant again about run flats but I had that just demonstrated by a friend when he entirely changed the dynamic of his 7 by replacing the run flats - so much for this generation of run flats giving a better ride.

Then again, it is sure easier for BMW (or MB or Audi) to get a better lap time on the ring than build a long term reliable car with minimal maintenance requirement. But in the recent comparos on Toyotas, some very unToyota like squeaks and rattles are becoming more prominent. I think it was the C&D review that placed the Camry well down in a recent comparo that noticed build quality issues and raised the point that if Toyota loses their build quality, what have they got? As for whether Infiniti is worrying BMW on purpose or accident, we will find out in the next few models from Infiniti.
RON430 is offline  
Old 01-24-07, 12:33 AM
  #92  
S8B
Lead Lap
 
S8B's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: California
Posts: 428
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by 1SICKLEX


This is what I am saying. Those that just think Lexus are sofas, need to wake up. BOTH make sporty cars. Infiniti I will give the sporty edge as the G35/M35/45 AND FX 35/45 are all built off the 350Z platform. They BETTER be more sporty! :
Correction:

The G35/M35/M45/FX35/FX45 are all built off the FM Platform.

There's no such thing as a "350Z Platform"

(I know what you intended to say though; They share the same platform, as the 350z is also in the FM Platform)

.
S8B is offline  
Old 01-24-07, 01:13 AM
  #93  
mavericck
Lexus Test Driver
 
mavericck's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: WA
Posts: 1,230
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by RON430
You know, this is a great point. Reducing lap times on that billiard table of a track, the Nurburgring, by stiffening up spring rates, bushings, bars, and using stiffer sidewall tires is something that any moron, high school student, or aftermarket tuner could do. Getting balance between ride and handling is something that takes some intelligence if not a bank of supercomputers. And this is precisely what Lexus should be doing. I do not want a race car for the street. But that awful "freeway float" that has defined a few generations of Lexus, is also not what I want. And Lexus is not alone in stiffening up suspensions. Most all of the brands we regularly talk about have done that including BMW. Some of it may be simply the side effect of the great rush for those cool looking and hard riding low profile tires. The silky balance that BMW once had between ride and handling is long gone. I won't rant again about run flats but I had that just demonstrated by a friend when he entirely changed the dynamic of his 7 by replacing the run flats - so much for this generation of run flats giving a better ride.

Then again, it is sure easier for BMW (or MB or Audi) to get a better lap time on the ring than build a long term reliable car with minimal maintenance requirement. But in the recent comparos on Toyotas, some very unToyota like squeaks and rattles are becoming more prominent. I think it was the C&D review that placed the Camry well down in a recent comparo that noticed build quality issues and raised the point that if Toyota loses their build quality, what have they got? As for whether Infiniti is worrying BMW on purpose or accident, we will find out in the next few models from Infiniti.
I agree it's about being able to find the perfect combination of sportiness and comfort. This is something air suspensions and magnetic shock absorbers are very good at helping a suspension engineer achieve. I also agree with your opinion of run-flat tires....horrible idea. I'm so thankful Audi and Porsche decided against using them. I'm also thankful they're not on my LS as well.

I however disagree with your statements about the Nurburgring. You see a car MUST be dependable to be able to survive development and testing on the Nurburgring. This is what makes their cars so solid and reliable (mechanically and as far as I am concerned, in every other aspect as well), because they must be able to endure the torture testing that takes place on the Nurburgring which is far more demanding than just being designed for a normal jaunt to the grocery store. Why do you think Lexus and most of the major car manufacturers take their cars here to test them to the breaking point? And "billiard table of track"...are you mocking this phenomenal track? It is regarded by nearly every car enthusiast as the greatest and most demanding race track in the world and for you to mock it is just plain ridiculous.

You need to take a look at this video: http://video.google.com/videoplay?do...30111&hl=en-GB
mavericck is offline  
Related Topics
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Old Oiler
Car Chat
45
11-11-07 09:21 AM
GS3rdwow
IS - 2nd Gen (2006-2013)
16
01-01-06 11:24 AM
XenonES3
Car Chat
13
11-10-03 07:14 PM



Quick Reply: Infiniti more dangerous than Lexus says BMW



All times are GMT -7. The time now is 01:31 AM.