My 2003 LS430 was backed into recently and the front left fender/quarter panel was damaged beyond repair. I have looked and looked for a non-OEM fender because I want to be sure the replacement fits well without modification. I haven't had any luck finding one anywhere and would prefer it be the Metalic Mercury Silver color my car is so I won't have to get it painted to match the car. I would be more than thankful for some help finding one for an acceptable price.

 

There are no non-oem. Check www.car-parts.com

 

Check your local wreck yards, check online wrecking yards too.

If they have a silver car, they'd be willing to take off the fender for you.

As for replicas, there are non OEM fenders, but all of them are aftermarket styles. And you'd end up needing to buy 2. So your best bet is to check local listings for wreckage yards. Silver is not rare as you think, you'll find one I'm sure.