What does everyone think?

Just my personal opinion, not a fan of how the end of the skirt ramps up about midway of the bottom of the rear door to the wheel well.
I can appreciate it's trying to mimic the ramp on the side of the front lip, but it still looks odd.
Having said that, I don't have an answer as to what would look better...just that I know it's not that.

Maybe have the end of the skirt mimic the end of the rocker above it? At least it would flow with the body lines.

Agreed with the other comment. I'm a fan of the 1st 80% of it but it just looks odd once it starts going triangular near the rear wheel.

Too straight. Looks like that small flat lego piece that you always lose.

I actually like them🙈🙈

Cosmetic surgeon once told me that if a patient comes who is 8-9/10 in appearance, they discourage them from trying to perfect their looks, it rarely creates that significant of an improvement. I think a lot of the "appearance" mods on our cars add little to no value, or decrease their curb appeal. A good example is ugly/ricer wheels or wheels that look almost identical to OEM that cost hundreds.

These skirts are in that categry.

The exact thought I had before i read the comments was for the rear part where it meets the wheel. it doesn't flow. it's just an abrupt corner that angles differently.

Also what's the flat black part? is that rubber? bare plastic? gloss painted? would need to see up close photos.

Sort of thinking less is more here. Why does this car need a side skirt? I don't really see that this skirt here is addressing any defecit of the original design. If you are able to complment, it should be done well.

The skirt here just doesn't flow well. I think it needs more subtlety. Side view perhaps?

Lip kits add significant stance and aggression to a car in a subtle way and these are all reversible modifications. Although, I can't agree with NIA's prices, their lip kits look really good.

Your statement doesn't hold up, simple fact that we're talking about cars not people-- proof being that a lot of manufacturers are starting (if not already put) lip kits on their cars such as BMW, Honda, and others.

I think the black part is just a natural shadow created by the gap between the rocker and the skirt...I don't think there is anything in the space...if you look at the first photo closely, and stare at the gap you are basically looking under the vehicle.

I think that's sort of their signature. Fairly common for a few brands.

Really well stated.

Stock side skirt looks better IMO. I agree with Sasnuke's observations and opinions though.

looks horrible and cheap.

I think it's the original piece on the side

Loving the fitment and design of the skirts. However, I feel that the skirts are not matching well with the front lip.