Change tranny fluid or not?
#1
Change tranny fluid or not?
So my 2001 GS430 is pushing near 70K, and I wanted to change the tranny fluid on it, however the local dealership advised me that I should never change the fluid unless the car was driven in harsh conditions and the fluid is dirty. They said I should just add fluid if level is low. I also looked throught Lexus maintenance manual, it has no mentioning of chaning tranny fluid.
I bought the car with 63K, no idea if/when the previous owners ever changed the fluid. What do you guys think?
I bought the car with 63K, no idea if/when the previous owners ever changed the fluid. What do you guys think?
#2
dubsonlexus
iTrader: (9)
Originally Posted by Och
So my 2001 GS430 is pushing near 70K, and I wanted to change the tranny fluid on it, however the local dealership advised me that I should never change the fluid unless the car was driven in harsh conditions and the fluid is dirty. They said I should just add fluid if level is low. I also looked throught Lexus maintenance manual, it has no mentioning of chaning tranny fluid.
I bought the car with 63K, no idea if/when the previous owners ever changed the fluid. What do you guys think?
I bought the car with 63K, no idea if/when the previous owners ever changed the fluid. What do you guys think?
#4
Rookie
iTrader: (15)
Originally Posted by Och
however the local dealership advised me that I should never change the fluid unless the car was driven in harsh conditions and the fluid is dirty.
Changing transmission fluid is never a bad thing. Those problems about people having trouble after changing fluid is a myth. If something is wrong after changing fluid, then the problem lies somewhere else, not the tranny fluid. Changing the tranny fluid only if you drive in harsh condition makes as much sense as only changing the engine oil when you drive it hard. Doesn't make sense.
I know people who change their tranny fluid every 3k miles. Yes, 3000 miles. Overkill? Yes, but the shift is like butter (acura legend; they're known for hard 1st to 2nd shifts).
#5
Lexus Fanatic
Originally Posted by Och
wanted to change the tranny fluid on it, however the local dealership advised me that I should never change the fluid unless the car was driven in harsh conditions and the fluid is dirty.
btw-use only Toyota fluid.
Trending Topics
#9
Lexus Champion
iTrader: (4)
Originally Posted by 3dog
If you do this you are only diluting the dirty fluid that still remains.
A complete flush is the only way to get rid of all the old fluid
Ivan
3dog
A complete flush is the only way to get rid of all the old fluid
Ivan
3dog
#11
Moderator
Make sure folks who offer warranty stand behind it.
Pressure flush [not always but] can be detremental. You want all the metal filings etc remain near the magnets and not get back into the fluid flow channels.
Trnasmission fluid is stressed but unlike engine oil no contaminents get in to it.
So a drain and fill is the most unobstrusive way. You want to take it a step further, remove the pan and clean it and add fluid. Next step might be disconnecting the low pressure pipe and feeding fresh fluid while collecting the old [Tricky and potentially desasterous if you fail to provide same volume as being pumped out.[needs to be zeo net gain in the volume]. In this process you are using the pump of the transmission to flush the system.
Next step is to use external pump and cleaner fluid. This can be bad for the stated reasons above. Just make sure the warranty is genuine and you will not be short changes in case of trouble.
Drain and fill is simple, but be careful in reinstalling the drain plug and rember to put in a new crush washer and torque it to the right setting.
Salim
Pressure flush [not always but] can be detremental. You want all the metal filings etc remain near the magnets and not get back into the fluid flow channels.
Trnasmission fluid is stressed but unlike engine oil no contaminents get in to it.
So a drain and fill is the most unobstrusive way. You want to take it a step further, remove the pan and clean it and add fluid. Next step might be disconnecting the low pressure pipe and feeding fresh fluid while collecting the old [Tricky and potentially desasterous if you fail to provide same volume as being pumped out.[needs to be zeo net gain in the volume]. In this process you are using the pump of the transmission to flush the system.
Next step is to use external pump and cleaner fluid. This can be bad for the stated reasons above. Just make sure the warranty is genuine and you will not be short changes in case of trouble.
Drain and fill is simple, but be careful in reinstalling the drain plug and rember to put in a new crush washer and torque it to the right setting.
Salim
#12
dubsonlexus
iTrader: (9)
Originally Posted by salimshah
Make sure folks who offer warranty stand behind it.
Pressure flush [not always but] can be detremental. You want all the metal filings etc remain near the magnets and not get back into the fluid flow channels.
Trnasmission fluid is stressed but unlike engine oil no contaminents get in to it.
So a drain and fill is the most unobstrusive way. You want to take it a step further, remove the pan and clean it and add fluid. Next step might be disconnecting the low pressure pipe and feeding fresh fluid while collecting the old [Tricky and potentially desasterous if you fail to provide same volume as being pumped out.[needs to be zeo net gain in the volume]. In this process you are using the pump of the transmission to flush the system.
Next step is to use external pump and cleaner fluid. This can be bad for the stated reasons above. Just make sure the warranty is genuine and you will not be short changes in case of trouble.
Drain and fill is simple, but be careful in reinstalling the drain plug and rember to put in a new crush washer and torque it to the right setting.
Salim
Pressure flush [not always but] can be detremental. You want all the metal filings etc remain near the magnets and not get back into the fluid flow channels.
Trnasmission fluid is stressed but unlike engine oil no contaminents get in to it.
So a drain and fill is the most unobstrusive way. You want to take it a step further, remove the pan and clean it and add fluid. Next step might be disconnecting the low pressure pipe and feeding fresh fluid while collecting the old [Tricky and potentially desasterous if you fail to provide same volume as being pumped out.[needs to be zeo net gain in the volume]. In this process you are using the pump of the transmission to flush the system.
Next step is to use external pump and cleaner fluid. This can be bad for the stated reasons above. Just make sure the warranty is genuine and you will not be short changes in case of trouble.
Drain and fill is simple, but be careful in reinstalling the drain plug and rember to put in a new crush washer and torque it to the right setting.
Salim
#13
Moderator
Originally Posted by lexusondubs
do you think the dealer would offer something harmful to your car that would cost them costly repairs for a service they recomended ? yes it might be harmful but with the 10k warranty i think your in the clear
Service revenew is brought in by keeping the bays full and all workers working all of the time (preferrably only a few master techs and mostly the hired help). So dealership will be eager to sell you all sort of service(s). An honest one will keep this to minimum, customer request or prescribed maintainence.
Warranty is a cost borne by the manufacturer or the insurer. It does not cost the dealership any money, if they have to replace the transmission. They will simply forward the bill to the manuafcturere/insurance/owner.
Back to reality.
The service manual states the reccomended time to drain and fill. New transmissions may soon be available with synthetic ... sealed for life. Prior GS's are not.
Salim
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
AJT123
LS - 3rd Gen (2001-2006)
20
05-14-15 03:44 PM
SuperCoupe400
Performance & Maintenance
5
05-09-08 08:07 PM