Poor experience with Valvoline MaxLife ATF
#1
Driver School Candidate
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: CA
Posts: 25
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Poor experience with Valvoline MaxLife ATF
About 2 years and 20,000 miles ago, I flushed out my Type-IV fluid with Valvoline's MaxLife synthetic ATF that they say meets the Type-IV spec. Did the flush through the cooler lines to get all the old fluid out. Noticed that within a few days of driving that the transmission had an occasional shudder on the 2-3 upshift and the car wouldn't accelerate for a second or two when starting from a stop going uphill (like from a stop sign). I lived with it for a while since I planned on flushing the fluid again after 6 months but got busy with work and never got around to it. Well I finally flushed the MaxLife out 2 weeks ago with Mobil 3309 (exactly the same as Type-IV) and a new filter. The transmission is totally back to normal now. Super smooth shifts, no hesitation when accelerating from a stop uphill.
I thought the synthetic ATF would be better for my car, it was way cheaper than the OEM fluid, and Valvoline claimed it met the Type-IV spec. I know many of you have used MaxLife without issue - but for my car, a 2002 ES300 with 144k miles, it performed very poorly. I noticed also that the viscosity is quite a bit thinner than Type-IV. In any case, just wanted to share so you all can make informed decisions.
I thought the synthetic ATF would be better for my car, it was way cheaper than the OEM fluid, and Valvoline claimed it met the Type-IV spec. I know many of you have used MaxLife without issue - but for my car, a 2002 ES300 with 144k miles, it performed very poorly. I noticed also that the viscosity is quite a bit thinner than Type-IV. In any case, just wanted to share so you all can make informed decisions.
#2
I have always said to stick with the OE recommended fluid.
No need to use this "superior" fluid because the old fluid works just fine. And has been around much longer.
"Don't fix what isn't broken."
No need to use this "superior" fluid because the old fluid works just fine. And has been around much longer.
"Don't fix what isn't broken."
#5
Lexus Fanatic
I find MaxLife too thin for the newer transmissions it seems fine in the A540E/A541E. I am not crazy about Royal Purple motor oil but their transmission fluid works excellent in the U140E and the others I mentioned.
#6
I've run Maxlife ATF in my sister's 98 Camry V6 and my mom's 99 Camry V6.
I've also done 2 changes with it on my dad's 2001 Odyssey.
I ran it for 100 miles in my 2000 ES before draining it and filling with Amsoil Signature ATF.
We had no shifting problems on any of those vehicles, but they're all older cars.
I'll probably continue running it on those cars in the future but for mine I will stick with the Amsoil as I noticed it is a thicker in viscosity.
I've also done 2 changes with it on my dad's 2001 Odyssey.
I ran it for 100 miles in my 2000 ES before draining it and filling with Amsoil Signature ATF.
We had no shifting problems on any of those vehicles, but they're all older cars.
I'll probably continue running it on those cars in the future but for mine I will stick with the Amsoil as I noticed it is a thicker in viscosity.
#7
I've run Maxlife ATF in my sister's 98 Camry V6 and my mom's 99 Camry V6.
I've also done 2 changes with it on my dad's 2001 Odyssey.
I ran it for 100 miles in my 2000 ES before draining it and filling with Amsoil Signature ATF.
We had no shifting problems on any of those vehicles, but they're all older cars.
I'll probably continue running it on those cars in the future but for mine I will stick with the Amsoil as I noticed it is a thicker in viscosity.
I've also done 2 changes with it on my dad's 2001 Odyssey.
I ran it for 100 miles in my 2000 ES before draining it and filling with Amsoil Signature ATF.
We had no shifting problems on any of those vehicles, but they're all older cars.
I'll probably continue running it on those cars in the future but for mine I will stick with the Amsoil as I noticed it is a thicker in viscosity.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
RX350LB
RX - 2nd Gen (2004-2009)
5
06-21-19 09:08 AM