i would choose the S3 anyday over the IS.

 

Seems to me if you are looking at an S3 and an IS (assuming 350), then a BMW 340i xDrive should be in the mix too.

 

Thanks again everyone. See the comment on how expensive maintenance could be worries me plus I feel the reliability is a no brainer with the Lexus. Maybe instead of the IS, I'll check out the GS too or even the RC. I definitely don't want to spend a lot on maintenance which is why I'm not even considering a BMW.

 

Leasing Audi
Buying Lexus

 

But how long do you intend to keep the car? BMW covers everything including a good number of the wear and tear items for 4 years 50,000 miles...

 

not always, the s3 is a new car lease deals wont be as aggressive since there is a demand for it

 

I meant longer than 4 year ownership where Lexus is a better choice maintenance wise.

 

Haven't sampled the new S3, but, with the latest A3 I did a full-review on, not too long ago, it was a nice, well-built small car that was pleasant to drive. The S3, obviously, will have a lot more power, a more sport-oriented interior, and probably a stiffer ride.


According to Consumer Reports, which IMO is the best reliability-data currently available, Audi, as a brand, ranks #3 among all U.S.-market makes now in reliability......a remarkable improvement in the last several years. Audis, not long ago, were considered money-pits.

 

Maintenance on the S3 will consist of $120 oil changes every 10K miles....or less if you pay for the maintenance up front like you do on BMW. Other than air and cabin filters that's about it. oh, Spark Plugs every 35-40K miles...very easy to do yourself.

If you're talking about reliability - Audi has been great lately.


http://www.audiusa.com/content/dam/a...-Year-2015.pdf

 

I'm in the Audi forums as well since I have an S5, and it seems all the S3 owners love them. I've also seen the car in the flesh and it is quite attractive and sporty.

 

Maintenance is more costly than Lexus, but it's not considerable. If you purchase Audi Care, or negotiate into your deal, then most of your maintenance is covered.

The A3 and the IS are both nice cars, you can't go wrong with either one.

 

BMW is the least to maintain since they are one of few offer free maint. for first 4 years or 40k miles. I didn't spend a cent for my 750i for the 2 and half years of ownership.

 

S3 would be my pic. Speed, efficiency, and improved reliability all make the package attractive. Also a very handsome body too. Right now L.A. dealers are offering S3's well below invoice, so opportunity is there.
About the only thing you give up with the Audi is a luxurious interior. It is a bit plain inside. But then again I feel the latest IS is also lacking in luxury, with it's more sporting dash and console. Really depends on what your priorities are.

 

on paper, yes, but aren't these extremely difficult to come by, as well as priced by stealerships well above msrp?

 

Then you shouldn't be considering an Audi either. Not sure of Audi's program, but BMW includes all maintenance for 4 years.