Drove a new Mercedes S580 and S580e at legnth, thoughts compared to my S560
#16
Lexus Fanatic
Thread Starter
I still say keep yours, it's somehow more "S-classy" to me
Reading what you wrote it lines up with what I felt but I do find it very strange that Mercedes went stiffer and Audi went softer. Normally the spectrum doesn't really change between the German trio but I guess they are changing stuff since it's not just me who felt it
I'm not likely to step down to a G90 though, for one I want the V8, I would probably just keep my S560 vs getting a G90 unless it really blew me away.
also, doesn't your 560 have the 48v system also?
also did you check to see if the 580/580e were in any kind of 'valet' mode?
even if the 580 or 580e feel 'slower' off the line, perhaps that's due to the priority of smoothness over anything else, so it could be basically programming.
the 580e i think you said it the ttv6 + the bigger battery and electric motor(s)? that 60mi,. or range is pretty great since for daily commutes that means basically using no gas. and you still have the ability to drive long distances without waiting at some charging station.
glad you're coming around on the interior. yes, as you've mentioned, there's cost cutting corners, but obviously something has to give in a changing economy plus new features.
not sure if you were looking at models with the center 'slope' screen, or the crazy hyperscreen? not sure what's in the s580 (sorry, i don't have in that rarified air much! )
but i know from having driven the eqs suv that i loved the interior. i couldn't care less what's made of what as long as it looks and feels good in the frequent eye line and touch points.
not sure if you were looking at models with the center 'slope' screen, or the crazy hyperscreen? not sure what's in the s580 (sorry, i don't have in that rarified air much! )
but i know from having driven the eqs suv that i loved the interior. i couldn't care less what's made of what as long as it looks and feels good in the frequent eye line and touch points.
The S Class doesn't have the hyperscreen, yet. My guess is the mid cycle refresh in 25 will get the "megascreen" or whatever they call it the new E Class has. This is what the dash looks like:
One thing I don't like is the big swath of piano black plastic on the console where mine is controls and wood. There is an option to have a dot matrix trim there that the one I drove has that looks much better though:
anyway, you have such a horrible decision between an i7, an s580, or something else, you poor thing.
Last edited by SW17LS; 09-01-23 at 06:27 PM.
#17
Lead Lap
I kind of want you to get the i7 just to try something different. It’s not for me but would be kind of cool to be the first one here to have one. It’s got a lot of parlor tricks.
#18
Lexus Fanatic
Thread Starter
Trying something different for me is tough lol, look how long it took me to take the leap for the S Class...
My ONLY concern about the i7 is charging on trips...
My ONLY concern about the i7 is charging on trips...
#19
Lexus Test Driver
Nice review Sw17ls, enjoyed it.
What color combos did you look at?
Impressions?
What color combos did you look at?
Impressions?
#20
Lexus Fanatic
Thread Starter
The 580 I drove was matte white with a black interior. I wouldn’t do the matte white. The 580e was dark blue with a tan interior. I like the dark blue, they have a dark grey I also like, interior I always like black but also like that dark tan color I posted above. The 580e was a light tan that probably wouldn’t work for me.
#21
Lexus Fanatic
Thread Starter
I forgot to mention the rear wheel steering is an incredible feature.
#23
Super Moderator
It’s kinda crazy that it’s that way, since an I6 is inherently the most balanced engine layout (other than a V12). Must come down to decades of gradual perfection of their V8 platform, vs. a first attempt at a straight six since most of us have been alive.
#24
Lexus Champion
A V8 has the inherent advantage over an I6 of more firing events per rotation that makes it smoother. Same way a 12 has a 50% advantage over an 8, the power becomes nearly constant.
#25
Lexus Fanatic
Thread Starter
Yeah, I've always found that I6s while smoother than V6s don't feel like a V8.
#27
Lexus Test Driver
There are some quality differences, for instance my W222 has fully carpeted sills where there is no plastic, and the 223 has hard plastic sills which IMO cheapen the interior somewhat, but it is still an extremely nice place to be. The sides of the console in the W222 with napa leather (non exclusive napa) are also real leather, in the 223 they are synthetic, you have to go to exclusive napa to get that area in leather which makes the full door panels and dash leather too, gets the suede headliner...
Just thinking, if in a place that gets dirty maybe plastic is better and easier to maintain. Just ideas...
#28
Lexus Champion
These. Some high end cars have plastic there for no reason, like my Audis are just plastic. Same with the B pillar, usually high end cars have cloth/alcantara upper halves and leather lower halves or at least soft touch materials.
For some reason some cars have the lower half just hard plastic so the end result is the lower rim around the door is a metal sill with plastic everywhere else. I hate it, I had mine wrapped in alcantara to "fix" it but I guess I understand because it does prevent W220 like sill shredding. People tend to just slam their shoes into those areas so perhaps it's a measure to prevent damage
#29
Lexus Fanatic
Thread Starter
Here are the sills on my car. As you can see it’s all carpet, there’s no plastic, in the new S This carpeted area is all plastic. The new 7 is fully carpeted in these areas like my car is.
#30
Lexus Champion
The other thing that makes me think it's intentional are the door seals.....sometimes they are like Steve's car and soft all the way around, others stop when they get to the bottom.