In a conundrum repair or part out a '97
#1
Driver School Candidate
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: TX
Posts: 37
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
In a conundrum repair or part out a '97
Vehicle in question is my wife's '97 LS400 with 167k on the clock. I logged on to search for answers as to why her heater doesn't work any longer. After following advise found in several helpful threads I got to the root of the problem which is blown head gaskets. I'v got all the parts coming including TB & WP as well as dist. caps, rotors, well the whole nine yards.
On my way to work I spotted another LS400 in a park-n-sell lot locally. In talking to the owner I got her version of it's history which I have no real reason to doubt. It's a '99 w/140k. It's white over silver (not pearl like my wife's is) with immaculate interior, new tires, receipts for new WP, TB, PSP & drive belt, battery and service which was (by a stroke of luck) done at a buddy's shop so it was easy to verify. She's asking $5500. The thing that concerns me is that it was wrecked two years ago. The owner's daughter was turning into a local grocery store and was rear ended. The right rear quarter panel, bumper & trunk lid was replaced in lieu of being straightned/repaired.
This is where I find myself on the fence. I've read several posts about folks that have parted their cars out. I'm seeking opinions/advise on what folks would do in my situation. I have all the replacement parts either in hand or in transit totaling roughly $600ish and a car mechanic buddy lined up to hold my hand during the repair process.
This is what I find myself weighing:
Pros:
1) Wife's car has never been wrecked and we know the history beyond any doubt.
2) Have all the parts here or coming and an excellent mechanic to assist
3) Will be like new again with many trouble free miles ahead when completed
Cons:
1) That's a HELLAVA LOT OF WORK!
2) The car will be down until it's completed. She'll be driving my truck and I'll be riding my motorcycle during the brunt of winter here. (Feb & 1st part of March)
3) I'm a Harley mechanic not a Lexus mech though as mentioned I do have a buddy who'll be on site while I'm doing the job lending a guiding hand. I just would feel awful if after completing the job I hit the key and find I've wankered something somewhere deep inside and have to go back in.
Last stanza of this marathon post. How much of the $5500 purchase price of the '99 could I expect to recoup by parting out the '97 and is the market strong enough that I wouldn't have a problem flipping the parts?
Thanks
On my way to work I spotted another LS400 in a park-n-sell lot locally. In talking to the owner I got her version of it's history which I have no real reason to doubt. It's a '99 w/140k. It's white over silver (not pearl like my wife's is) with immaculate interior, new tires, receipts for new WP, TB, PSP & drive belt, battery and service which was (by a stroke of luck) done at a buddy's shop so it was easy to verify. She's asking $5500. The thing that concerns me is that it was wrecked two years ago. The owner's daughter was turning into a local grocery store and was rear ended. The right rear quarter panel, bumper & trunk lid was replaced in lieu of being straightned/repaired.
This is where I find myself on the fence. I've read several posts about folks that have parted their cars out. I'm seeking opinions/advise on what folks would do in my situation. I have all the replacement parts either in hand or in transit totaling roughly $600ish and a car mechanic buddy lined up to hold my hand during the repair process.
This is what I find myself weighing:
Pros:
1) Wife's car has never been wrecked and we know the history beyond any doubt.
2) Have all the parts here or coming and an excellent mechanic to assist
3) Will be like new again with many trouble free miles ahead when completed
Cons:
1) That's a HELLAVA LOT OF WORK!
2) The car will be down until it's completed. She'll be driving my truck and I'll be riding my motorcycle during the brunt of winter here. (Feb & 1st part of March)
3) I'm a Harley mechanic not a Lexus mech though as mentioned I do have a buddy who'll be on site while I'm doing the job lending a guiding hand. I just would feel awful if after completing the job I hit the key and find I've wankered something somewhere deep inside and have to go back in.
Last stanza of this marathon post. How much of the $5500 purchase price of the '99 could I expect to recoup by parting out the '97 and is the market strong enough that I wouldn't have a problem flipping the parts?
Thanks
#2
It is alot of work but if your having a mechanic do the work it shouldnt take longer than a few days so you will be off the bike pretty quick.
but if you choose not to fix it, 5500 sounds pretty good for the 99 and you should be able to get some of that back with a part out.
The market is not that strong due to the rarity of the car but you should be able to get close to 1000 depending on the condition.
Brakes will sell first for about 100
interior will sell if the leathers good. For about 400, more if you take the time to sell all the leather pieces.
various engine and electronic will sell but more slowly totaling a few hundred.
you can return or sell the new parts you bought.
Then finally you can scrap the remainder for a few hundred.
but if you choose not to fix it, 5500 sounds pretty good for the 99 and you should be able to get some of that back with a part out.
The market is not that strong due to the rarity of the car but you should be able to get close to 1000 depending on the condition.
Brakes will sell first for about 100
interior will sell if the leathers good. For about 400, more if you take the time to sell all the leather pieces.
various engine and electronic will sell but more slowly totaling a few hundred.
you can return or sell the new parts you bought.
Then finally you can scrap the remainder for a few hundred.
#3
Driver School Candidate
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: TX
Posts: 37
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It is alot of work but if your having a mechanic do the work it shouldnt take longer than a few days so you will be off the bike pretty quick.
but if you choose not to fix it, 5500 sounds pretty good for the 99 and you should be able to get some of that back with a part out.
The market is not that strong due to the rarity of the car but you should be able to get close to 1000 depending on the condition.
Brakes will sell first for about 100
interior will sell if the leathers good. For about 400, more if you take the time to sell all the leather pieces.
various engine and electronic will sell but more slowly totaling a few hundred.
you can return or sell the new parts you bought.
Then finally you can scrap the remainder for a few hundred.
but if you choose not to fix it, 5500 sounds pretty good for the 99 and you should be able to get some of that back with a part out.
The market is not that strong due to the rarity of the car but you should be able to get close to 1000 depending on the condition.
Brakes will sell first for about 100
interior will sell if the leathers good. For about 400, more if you take the time to sell all the leather pieces.
various engine and electronic will sell but more slowly totaling a few hundred.
you can return or sell the new parts you bought.
Then finally you can scrap the remainder for a few hundred.
#4
Part out probably will bring in more as I just listed a few things that would sell quickly.
It all depends on how long you want to have a semi parted out car in your driveway and how many different places you try and sell the parts
It all depends on how long you want to have a semi parted out car in your driveway and how many different places you try and sell the parts
#6
Lexus Champion
I cannot recommend ever buying a previously wrecked car, it doesn't matter how it was fixed, even if no expense was spared, the reliability, which is the reason you buy a Lexus in the first place, is forever gone after a hard impact, even the reliability of systems on the opposite end of the car - sit tight and wait on a deal on a never wrecked 98-00
PS - I agree with Yotarip - a head gasket should never fail on a 97, unless someone did something really dumb and grossly overheated it by running it with no water etc. there are LS400's all over the place with 300K miles on their original head gasket, I have never heard of one failing in this model of Toyota!
PS - I agree with Yotarip - a head gasket should never fail on a 97, unless someone did something really dumb and grossly overheated it by running it with no water etc. there are LS400's all over the place with 300K miles on their original head gasket, I have never heard of one failing in this model of Toyota!
Last edited by LScowboyLS; 01-22-13 at 10:54 AM.
#7
Driver School Candidate
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: TX
Posts: 37
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I followed a thread and then started one about no heat and one thing lead to another. I still think I'm going to have the heater issue to deal with after this. Then driver and passenger seats, then paintless dent repair. A whole big laundry list.
Trending Topics
#8
BahHumBug
iTrader: (10)
I would just swap the motor out for a salvaged one and call it a day, will be significantly cheaper than rebuilding the motor in the car and (in my opinion) more reliable than just slapping new headgaskets on the old motor.
Something else to consider is that you wouldn't be allowed to part your vehicle out on this forum as you don't come close to meeting the requirements to do so. Parting out a relatively niche vehicle like an LS is a long-term prospect, i've seen guys part out complete S13s in DAYS because demand from the (far larger) 240sx community is ridiculous, but for the LS you should probably budget months...
Something else to consider is that you wouldn't be allowed to part your vehicle out on this forum as you don't come close to meeting the requirements to do so. Parting out a relatively niche vehicle like an LS is a long-term prospect, i've seen guys part out complete S13s in DAYS because demand from the (far larger) 240sx community is ridiculous, but for the LS you should probably budget months...
#9
PD beat me to it.
I've swapped 1uz's into two of my cars.The motor and complete electrical harness can be pulled in one complete unit without cutting anything. It would be much easier to get a good used motor with correct harness and drop it in.
Plus, if you put significant miles on the the car with a bhg, you could have caused damage to the bearings. You may be successful with the headgasket repair, only to result in rod knock a few weeks later. Coolant + oil is not a good thing.
I've swapped 1uz's into two of my cars.The motor and complete electrical harness can be pulled in one complete unit without cutting anything. It would be much easier to get a good used motor with correct harness and drop it in.
Plus, if you put significant miles on the the car with a bhg, you could have caused damage to the bearings. You may be successful with the headgasket repair, only to result in rod knock a few weeks later. Coolant + oil is not a good thing.
#10
Driver School Candidate
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: TX
Posts: 37
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I would just swap the motor out for a salvaged one and call it a day, will be significantly cheaper than rebuilding the motor in the car and (in my opinion) more reliable than just slapping new headgaskets on the old motor.
Something else to consider is that you wouldn't be allowed to part your vehicle out on this forum as you don't come close to meeting the requirements to do so. Parting out a relatively niche vehicle like an LS is a long-term prospect, i've seen guys part out complete S13s in DAYS because demand from the (far larger) 240sx community is ridiculous, but for the LS you should probably budget months...
Something else to consider is that you wouldn't be allowed to part your vehicle out on this forum as you don't come close to meeting the requirements to do so. Parting out a relatively niche vehicle like an LS is a long-term prospect, i've seen guys part out complete S13s in DAYS because demand from the (far larger) 240sx community is ridiculous, but for the LS you should probably budget months...
PD beat me to it.
I've swapped 1uz's into two of my cars.The motor and complete electrical harness can be pulled in one complete unit without cutting anything. It would be much easier to get a good used motor with correct harness and drop it in.
Plus, if you put significant miles on the the car with a bhg, you could have caused damage to the bearings. You may be successful with the headgasket repair, only to result in rod knock a few weeks later. Coolant + oil is not a good thing.
I've swapped 1uz's into two of my cars.The motor and complete electrical harness can be pulled in one complete unit without cutting anything. It would be much easier to get a good used motor with correct harness and drop it in.
Plus, if you put significant miles on the the car with a bhg, you could have caused damage to the bearings. You may be successful with the headgasket repair, only to result in rod knock a few weeks later. Coolant + oil is not a good thing.
Thanks for the replies and this fantastic forum.
#11
Lexus Champion
Oil is crystal clear as is the underside of the filler cap. It just drips and steams from the exhaust.
coolant in the exhaust is not automatically a blown head gasket, and I am having my doubts, since this just isn't a failure area on LS400
please do a compression check on all 8 cylinders, and also examine all 8 plugs, a real blown head gasket situation will typically have "steam cleaned" one of the plugs and it will look very different from the others
Last edited by LScowboyLS; 01-22-13 at 02:23 PM.
#12
Driver School Candidate
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: TX
Posts: 37
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
are you certain you don't have an intake gasket leak, or throttle body leak, idle air control valve coolant leak, etc.?
coolant in the exhaust is not automatically a blown head gasket, and I am having my doubts, since this just isn't a failure area on LS400
please do a compression check on all 8 cylinders, and also examine all 8 plugs, a real blown head gasket situation will typically have "steam cleaned" one of the plugs and it will look very different from the others
coolant in the exhaust is not automatically a blown head gasket, and I am having my doubts, since this just isn't a failure area on LS400
please do a compression check on all 8 cylinders, and also examine all 8 plugs, a real blown head gasket situation will typically have "steam cleaned" one of the plugs and it will look very different from the others
You mention a "steam cleaned plug". Wouldn't that also mean water in the oil since it's in the combustion chamber?
I do absolutely want to nail down exactly what the problem is before is start scattering an engine "***** nilly" for sure.
#13
Lexus Champion
You mention a "steam cleaned plug". Wouldn't that also mean water in the oil since it's in the combustion chamber?
a small amount of coolant can be getting into the oil and you wouldn't know it, because it is boiled out over time at engine crankcase operating temperatures, through the PCV valve.
#14
Driver School Candidate
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: TX
Posts: 37
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
almost always not, the oil control rings do a good job and all of the steam tends to exit out the exhaust valves (they get cleaned too!)
a small amount of coolant can be getting into the oil and you wouldn't know it, because it is boiled out over time at engine crankcase operating temperatures, through the PCV valve.
a small amount of coolant can be getting into the oil and you wouldn't know it, because it is boiled out over time at engine crankcase operating temperatures, through the PCV valve.
Also thanks to PD and Yotarip for the engine exchange suggestion. I found this place where I can get an engine for $780 guaranteed to have 50k or less miles with a 6 month warranty. If this thing does end up having blown HGs that will certainly be the route I go. That's less than $200 more than the rebuild parts cost! That's insane!
#15
BahHumBug
iTrader: (10)
https://www.clublexus.com/forums/whe...-for-sale.html
Car Part Outs
There are two authorized vendors that can part out cars (Aliga and RJ Distrib). Other than the vendors, only established CL members with more than 500 posts and greater than one year of membership are allowed to part out a car, and only under certain circumstances as defined below. Part outs should be posted in the appropriate model classified forum, not vehicles classifieds.
There are two authorized vendors that can part out cars (Aliga and RJ Distrib). Other than the vendors, only established CL members with more than 500 posts and greater than one year of membership are allowed to part out a car, and only under certain circumstances as defined below. Part outs should be posted in the appropriate model classified forum, not vehicles classifieds.
a) Multiple vehicle part-outs are not allowed.... it's a one time event meant for a Lexus that is disabled due to accident or one you've bought to use major pieces on your own car and are selling the rest. Buying a car specifically to part it out here is reserved for the two vendors above.
b) All individual part sales and prices should be posted on the forum so we know no one is getting ripped off by sales of the same item to other members and there is no auction activity.
c) No price gouging
d) Unknown / lightly known member partouts: Due to several scams run on members, these are no longer allowed. Recent joiners, don't even try. If you've had problems following classified forum rules in the past your partout may also be closed.
e) Planning on buying a parts car and taking future orders to sell parts of it? Absolutely not allowed. If you can't support the purchase of the parts car for without the forum support, don't buy it or plan on pre-selling parts here.
b) All individual part sales and prices should be posted on the forum so we know no one is getting ripped off by sales of the same item to other members and there is no auction activity.
c) No price gouging
d) Unknown / lightly known member partouts: Due to several scams run on members, these are no longer allowed. Recent joiners, don't even try. If you've had problems following classified forum rules in the past your partout may also be closed.
e) Planning on buying a parts car and taking future orders to sell parts of it? Absolutely not allowed. If you can't support the purchase of the parts car for without the forum support, don't buy it or plan on pre-selling parts here.