Transmission fluid change (merged threads)
Originally Posted by mj1pate;[url=tel:11900551
11900551[/url]]The “lifetime fluid” debate has been a topic for almost 2 decades in all the forums I participate in.
Fluid degrades with heat and condensation, which is physics, not automotive technology or marketing.
If we anticipate owning our Lexus for 100k miles or less, that’s likely within Lexus corporate’s “lifetime” definition.
If we expect to own our Lexus for 12years/200k, then multiple fluid exchanges over that time are appropriate… many of us believe.
My Lexus dealer will not consider a flush of my Lexus 3yrs/36k, even though at this young age the fluid would be particle free… but will drain and fill ~3.5 quarts for $800.
Muliple drain/fills will exchange most of the old fluid, but not all. And will certainly do no damage…if done properly. But I’ve never settled for drain/fills in the past.
I have the tools, and the necessary competence, but I need to first resolve how many drain/fills equal a likely improved environment inside the transmission, so as to make the whole effort worthwhile. It seems like such a compromise.
… and maybe consider saving the entire costs of servicing and add that to the cost of a transmission replacement >100k down the road. So much cheaper to do a unit replacement than replacing the entire car.
Fluid degrades with heat and condensation, which is physics, not automotive technology or marketing.
If we anticipate owning our Lexus for 100k miles or less, that’s likely within Lexus corporate’s “lifetime” definition.
If we expect to own our Lexus for 12years/200k, then multiple fluid exchanges over that time are appropriate… many of us believe.
My Lexus dealer will not consider a flush of my Lexus 3yrs/36k, even though at this young age the fluid would be particle free… but will drain and fill ~3.5 quarts for $800.
Muliple drain/fills will exchange most of the old fluid, but not all. And will certainly do no damage…if done properly. But I’ve never settled for drain/fills in the past.
I have the tools, and the necessary competence, but I need to first resolve how many drain/fills equal a likely improved environment inside the transmission, so as to make the whole effort worthwhile. It seems like such a compromise.
… and maybe consider saving the entire costs of servicing and add that to the cost of a transmission replacement >100k down the road. So much cheaper to do a unit replacement than replacing the entire car.
Great thread. My daughter just purchased a used 2019 RX 350 F Sport. I drive a 2016 ES 350 and change the trans fluid regularly (drain and fill). Glad to see the information here that I need to do the drain/fill for hers. Thanks to all who contributed. I have several post in the ES forum about the importance of fluid and filter changes.
One point I would like to make about these transmissions (ES 350 and RX 350) is that they have a filter that has a paper filter element, not a screen. My 2015 4Runner has a screen, no need to change. The paper element filters do require changing for proper fluid flow. I have changed the filter on my ES with 100k twice now. I also cleaned the transmission pan and magnets thoroughly while it was dropped. The filters can last a very long time, but will eventually reduce the flow as they filter out clutch debris. Just something to think about. I plan to change her RX filter after a couple of drain and fills.
Again, thanks to all who contributed to this thread. Just what I needed !
One point I would like to make about these transmissions (ES 350 and RX 350) is that they have a filter that has a paper filter element, not a screen. My 2015 4Runner has a screen, no need to change. The paper element filters do require changing for proper fluid flow. I have changed the filter on my ES with 100k twice now. I also cleaned the transmission pan and magnets thoroughly while it was dropped. The filters can last a very long time, but will eventually reduce the flow as they filter out clutch debris. Just something to think about. I plan to change her RX filter after a couple of drain and fills.
Again, thanks to all who contributed to this thread. Just what I needed !
Last edited by rmak; Apr 24, 2025 at 01:28 AM.
Originally Posted by rmak;[url=tel:11901003
11901003[/url]]Great thread. My daughter just purchased a used 2019 RX 350 F Sport. I drive a 2016 ES 350 and change the trans fluid regularly. Glad to see the information here that I need to do the drain/fill for hers. Thanks to all who contributed. I have several post in the ES forum about the importance of fluid and filter changes.
One point I would like to make about these transmissions (ES 350 and RX 350) is that they have a filter that has a paper filter element, not a screen. My 2015 4Runner has a screen, no need to change. The paper element filters do require changing for proper fluid flow. I have changed the filter on my ES with 100k twice now. I also cleaned the transmission pan and magnets thoroughly while it was dropped. The filters can last a very long time, but will eventually reduce the flow as they filter out clutch debris. Just something to think about. I plan to change her RX filter after a couple of drain and fills.
Again, thanks to all who contributed to this thread. Just what I needed !
One point I would like to make about these transmissions (ES 350 and RX 350) is that they have a filter that has a paper filter element, not a screen. My 2015 4Runner has a screen, no need to change. The paper element filters do require changing for proper fluid flow. I have changed the filter on my ES with 100k twice now. I also cleaned the transmission pan and magnets thoroughly while it was dropped. The filters can last a very long time, but will eventually reduce the flow as they filter out clutch debris. Just something to think about. I plan to change her RX filter after a couple of drain and fills.
Again, thanks to all who contributed to this thread. Just what I needed !
Originally Posted by rmak;[url=tel:11901005
11901005[/url]]I also am researching that now. Is it true that they use a FIP (form in place) gasket?
See post #143 above in this thread. Many Toyota/Lexus techs (CCN and Viktor) recommend a single drain and fill (approx 3.5 quarts of WS ATF) around 60,000 miles. See their YouTube channels for the procedure. CCN does NOT recommend multiple drain and fills. My post above shows pics and outlines procedure....I have a printed procedure if you want it. BTW, $800 is robbery for this job. Fluid is maybe $75 and labor is one hour at the most. DIY if you feel comfortable doing the job or find a Toyota/Lexus dealer who will do it for less. Only use WS ATF and only follow the TIS procedure.
My warranty states it supports the drive train for 6yr/72,000mi. Is it safe to assume Toyota Highlanders use the same trans as the RX350? Therefore Toyota techs have the same experience?
Do we know the Toyota techs work on our cars is compliant with the Lexus warranty requirements? You might think so..
Interesting…. Thanks
My warranty states it supports the drive train for 6yr/72,000mi. Is it safe to assume Toyota Highlanders use the same trans as the RX350? Therefore Toyota techs have the same experience?
Do we know the Toyota techs work on our cars is compliant with the Lexus warranty requirements? You might think so..
My warranty states it supports the drive train for 6yr/72,000mi. Is it safe to assume Toyota Highlanders use the same trans as the RX350? Therefore Toyota techs have the same experience?
Do we know the Toyota techs work on our cars is compliant with the Lexus warranty requirements? You might think so..
Although the transmission is "sealed" (which is just a name), TIS has an official procedure and ATF service is listed as a maintenance item if you tow or carry heavy loads @ 60,000 miles. If a dealership said that they will not do the job, just tell them that you tow or carry heavy loads. The job is very straightforward and not difficult....slightly more involved than an oil change, but not much.
Warranty does not require that you go to Lexus for service. Service can be done by anyone "qualified" which does not mean certified. I would contend that I am more qualified to change oil and fluids than the kid hired last week.
Last edited by Quantum501; Apr 24, 2025 at 06:37 AM.
Originally Posted by mj1pate;[url=tel:11901099
11901099[/url]]Interesting…. Thanks
My warranty states it supports the drive train for 6yr/72,000mi. Is it safe to assume Toyota Highlanders use the same trans as the RX350? Therefore Toyota techs have the same experience?
Do we know the Toyota techs work on our cars is compliant with the Lexus warranty requirements? You might think so..
My warranty states it supports the drive train for 6yr/72,000mi. Is it safe to assume Toyota Highlanders use the same trans as the RX350? Therefore Toyota techs have the same experience?
Do we know the Toyota techs work on our cars is compliant with the Lexus warranty requirements? You might think so..
Drain and refill procedure will be the same. The difference will be the capacity, if any. Or unless it’s a hybrid or CVT.
As always, to each there own. Just one mans opinion.
Originally Posted by rmak;[url=tel:11901639
11901639[/url]]Good points. I have found that for me, doing a drain and fill early (30k) keeps the fluid newer and also gets some of the break-in particles/fluid out. I do this with every one of my vehicles because I keep them and run them forever. I also do this for the transfer case and differential as well on my trucks and 4Runner. It does not hurt anything to wait until 60k, but changing the fluids is the life of the equipment. I have had many neglected engines and transmissions on the floor of my shop that could have been prevented with proper care.
As always, to each there own. Just one mans opinion.
As always, to each there own. Just one mans opinion.
4th RX 350 and even the previous gens uses "sealed transmission" (no dip stick or fill tube) and requires no changing of filters or fluid. However, due to old practices and maintenance culture, some people continue to change transmission fluid and filters in the same way that some people continue to change engine oil every 3K miles despite using 10K/1yr full synthetic oils. Personally, I just leave the transmission alone.
I have done 3 full transmission flushes and the last one with a filter change. The Toyota dealer dropped the pan was amazed by the minimal debris. I have the filter to prove why ATF maintenance is important.
Venza ATF changes
Venza ATF changes
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
paul3991
GX - 1st Gen (2003-2009)
6
Sep 10, 2018 05:44 PM
mesostinky
RX - 1st Gen (1999-2003)
21
Aug 12, 2018 08:49 AM









