I’m looking to sell my 2010 LS460 Sport Package with 121K Miles (85% highway) on the clock, private party and or trade, and am looking for guidelines on what I should list for and or expect to receive?

The good:

Title is clean.
Garage Kept, Non-Smoker, No child household.
Dealer maintained and up to date with extensive list of service records on LexusDrivers.
New Tires.
New front brakes, rears at 60%.
Air shocks all replaced.
Nav Screen replaced OEM.
New interior parts from sticky dash/panels tsb, some parts on back order however.

The bad:
Repainted rear bumper with some light blending from parking lot hit and run.
Trunk close button rubber cover has deformed but still operable.
Right side headlamp washer gets stuck open intermittently, also still operable.

Mods:
Rear muffler delete with custom J pipes to eliminate drone.

 

I suppose I can see your point regarding the exhaust mod, it’s not obnoxiously loud when driving normally (Sound is quite tasteful actually) and I do have the stock mufflers in storage closet and was going to leave it to buyer if they wanted it back to stock or not.

I currently have offer from Vroom for $12,000 so wanted to get an idea of private market. I find it incredible just how bad the resale on this generation is considering previous generations appear to sell at similar mileage for not a ton of money less.

I may just end up trading in or selling to Vroom and eating the relatively small negative equity (I got an insanely great APR from PenFed at purchase!)

 

Check out KBB.com and NADA.com and also compare your vehicle with others that are selling..
Good luck, and I have the same exact Lexus...

 

I would not purchase a LS from someone that modified the exhaust.
Plenty of pristine examples that haven't been butchered.