I could have sworn sewell had it listed around $400 with the cl discount. Could be wrong though

You were right actually, discounted it was around $450 a wheel.
Regular price I think it was around 700-800, cannot remember.

So I decided to give the guy asking $85 a shot, and it turned out pretty good. Unfortunately I did not get the wheel/tire road hazard option from the dealer. I did however go back to where the pothole was and it had been filled in. Do you think I can still make a claim to get the city to pay for the damage?

Here are shots of the wheel before and after being fixed: