Interesting comment in the "Worst to First" Edmunds review
#1
Lead Lap
Thread Starter
Interesting comment in the "Worst to First" Edmunds review
In the "4GS Reviews" thread there is a writeup by one of the Edmunds guys saying how the new GS is his favorite in the class because of the driving experience. One of the posted replies to his article (not sure if this was a CL member) mentions that, unlike Audi and BMW, Lexus has both the ES and GS, so instead of trying to be all things to all people with one model they have the freedom to make the ES the "luxury cruiser" and the GS the "sport sedan". Audi and BMW only have the A6 and 5 Series and can only offer equipment packages to reach either segment. I thought this was an interesting and very poignant observation.
We frequently complain about the ES cannabilizing GS sales, but maybe the existence of the ES has actually given us GS owners the kind of car we have wanted for so long!
We frequently complain about the ES cannabilizing GS sales, but maybe the existence of the ES has actually given us GS owners the kind of car we have wanted for so long!
#2
Lexus Champion
iTrader: (1)
We frequently complain about the ES cannabilizing GS sales, but maybe the existence of the ES has actually given us GS owners the kind of car we have wanted for so long!
I agree with this 100%!!! That way you do not compromise too much. The 2011 BMW 5 I had was compromising too much and it felt like a GS with a bit of ES which I hated. The GS feels so alive and engaging.
I agree with this 100%!!! That way you do not compromise too much. The 2011 BMW 5 I had was compromising too much and it felt like a GS with a bit of ES which I hated. The GS feels so alive and engaging.
#3
Pole Position
I've said this before : The sales/profits of the ES( majority) finances the existence of the GS (minority), allowing the driving enthusiasts to enjoy the GS off the volume generated by the non-enthusiast buyers of the ES.
However it is a 2 way street. The GS acts like a loss-leader. The presence of the GS attracts people who read the favorable reviews it garners. When they get to the showroom, they see the ES sitting next to the GS, same size, larger interior volume, better gas mileage, cheaper by thousands. They do their calculations and being non-driving enthusiasts, 8 times of of 10, they will opt for the cheaper car. The presence and proximity of the more expensive GS also accentuates for them the impression that they got a good deal in getting the ES.
It is interesting that ES-GS sales breakdown in a 80%-20% ratio and that combined ES-GS monthly sales are roughly equivalent to total monthly 5 series/E-class sales.
However it is a 2 way street. The GS acts like a loss-leader. The presence of the GS attracts people who read the favorable reviews it garners. When they get to the showroom, they see the ES sitting next to the GS, same size, larger interior volume, better gas mileage, cheaper by thousands. They do their calculations and being non-driving enthusiasts, 8 times of of 10, they will opt for the cheaper car. The presence and proximity of the more expensive GS also accentuates for them the impression that they got a good deal in getting the ES.
It is interesting that ES-GS sales breakdown in a 80%-20% ratio and that combined ES-GS monthly sales are roughly equivalent to total monthly 5 series/E-class sales.
#4
I tend to think of the LS as the Luxury Cruiser and the GS as the sports sedan. However, I'm interested in the new ES300h for my wife as it has the same look and feel of the GS (not the F-Sport). So, for me, the ES does indeed take away interest from the base GS as its roughly the same size and a bit more cheaper with most of the same functionality.
#5
in other words... you can't go wrong with the 2013 GS. i concur. i want my car to be a sleeper once everything is done. i've seen 4 2013 ES vehicles in one day (they are selling like hotcakes) as opposed to the 2013 GS which i might see once a month, if that.
#6
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Sep 2012
Location: Michigan
Posts: 41
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I had a somewhat odd experience with the Lexus salesman on my test drive. I drove the F-Sport AWD and loved it, but he kept on trying to get me to drive the GS350 luxury model. (they had only a couple of F-Sport's, but MANY GS350 AWD Luxury models on the lot). I said, no thanks, I love the looks and espec the handling of the F-Sport. He then said that the handling of the Luxury models is the SAME as F-Sport models when they're driven in the Sport+ mode. I asked "Really? Are you sure? Are the suspension and steering in fact the same on the Luxury as the F-Sport when driven in the Sport+ mode?" He said YES, "the major differences are only cosmetic--plus different wheels/tires-- in the AWD models".
I knew this to be false, but said, no thanks, and even if so, "I love the looks and the F-Sport's cabernet interior, so I would choose the F-Sport anyway".
So it seems to me that maybe the GS350 Luxury models are falling through the cracks--people either choose the GS350 F-Sport, or the ES instead, and perhaps FEW choose the GS LUXURY....so that maybe the Lexus saleman have pressure on them to sell the GS Luxury models?....
(So I think that this is a shady saleman....but it does leave me with a question: Does the F-sport package impove the handling and suspension of the AWD model similarly to the RWD model? The reason I ask this is due to my research on the BMW 5-series recently. The M-Sport package on the RWD 535i does indeed tighten the suspension, but the M-Sport package on the AWD 535xi DOES NOT--it's only cosmetic--i.e., seats, steering wheel, fenders, etc... Thus my question: Is the F-Sport package on GS350 AWD different than the package on the GS350 RWD?? Is it only cosmetic in the AWD version, like the 5-Series? Did the salesman in fact tell me the truth?)
I knew this to be false, but said, no thanks, and even if so, "I love the looks and the F-Sport's cabernet interior, so I would choose the F-Sport anyway".
So it seems to me that maybe the GS350 Luxury models are falling through the cracks--people either choose the GS350 F-Sport, or the ES instead, and perhaps FEW choose the GS LUXURY....so that maybe the Lexus saleman have pressure on them to sell the GS Luxury models?....
(So I think that this is a shady saleman....but it does leave me with a question: Does the F-sport package impove the handling and suspension of the AWD model similarly to the RWD model? The reason I ask this is due to my research on the BMW 5-series recently. The M-Sport package on the RWD 535i does indeed tighten the suspension, but the M-Sport package on the AWD 535xi DOES NOT--it's only cosmetic--i.e., seats, steering wheel, fenders, etc... Thus my question: Is the F-Sport package on GS350 AWD different than the package on the GS350 RWD?? Is it only cosmetic in the AWD version, like the 5-Series? Did the salesman in fact tell me the truth?)
Last edited by Hockyguy4u; 10-19-12 at 10:38 AM.
#7
I had a somewhat odd experience with the Lexus salesman on my test drive. I drove the F-Sport AWD and loved it, but he kept on trying to get me to drive the GS350 luxury model. (they had only a couple of F-Sport's, but many GS350 AWD Luxury models). I said, no thanks, I love the looks and espec the handling of the F-Sport. He then said that the handling of the Luxury models is the SAME AS F-Sport models when they're driven in the Sport+ mode. I asked "Really? Are you sure? Are the suspension and steering in fact the same on the Luxury as the F-Sport when driven in the Sport+ mode?" He said YES, "the major differences are cosmetic, and the wheels/tires".
I knew this to be false, but said, no thanks, and even if so, "I love the looks and the F-Sport's cabernet interior, so I would choose the F-Sport anyway".
So it seems to me that maybe the GS350 Luxury models are falling through the cracks--people either choose the GS350 F-Sport, or the ES instead, and perhaps FEW choose the GS LUXURY....so that maybe the Lexus saleman have pressure on them to sell the GS Luxury models?....
(So I think that this is a shady saleman....but it does leave me with a question: Does the F-sport package impove the handling and suspension of the AWD model similarly to the RWD model? The reason I ask this is due to my research on the BMW 5-series recently. The M-Sport package on the RWD 535i does indeed tighten the suspension, but the M-Sport package on the AWD 535xi DOES NOT--it's only cosmetic--i.e., seats, steering wheel, fenders, etc... Thus my question: Is the F-Sport package on GS350 AWD different than the package on the GS350 RWD?? Is it only cosmetic in the AWD version, like the 5-Series? Did the salesman in fact tell me the truth?)
I knew this to be false, but said, no thanks, and even if so, "I love the looks and the F-Sport's cabernet interior, so I would choose the F-Sport anyway".
So it seems to me that maybe the GS350 Luxury models are falling through the cracks--people either choose the GS350 F-Sport, or the ES instead, and perhaps FEW choose the GS LUXURY....so that maybe the Lexus saleman have pressure on them to sell the GS Luxury models?....
(So I think that this is a shady saleman....but it does leave me with a question: Does the F-sport package impove the handling and suspension of the AWD model similarly to the RWD model? The reason I ask this is due to my research on the BMW 5-series recently. The M-Sport package on the RWD 535i does indeed tighten the suspension, but the M-Sport package on the AWD 535xi DOES NOT--it's only cosmetic--i.e., seats, steering wheel, fenders, etc... Thus my question: Is the F-Sport package on GS350 AWD different than the package on the GS350 RWD?? Is it only cosmetic in the AWD version, like the 5-Series? Did the salesman in fact tell me the truth?)
Trending Topics
#8
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Sep 2012
Location: Michigan
Posts: 41
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My question still remains:
Other than the wider tires, is there any handling difference between the Luxury and F-Sport-AWD-equipped models when driven in Sport+ mode?
My thinking is YES-- the F-sport package does indeed improve the steering and suspension in the AWD model as well as the RWD model.....is this correct? Any dealer guy on here that can answer?
Other than the wider tires, is there any handling difference between the Luxury and F-Sport-AWD-equipped models when driven in Sport+ mode?
My thinking is YES-- the F-sport package does indeed improve the steering and suspension in the AWD model as well as the RWD model.....is this correct? Any dealer guy on here that can answer?
#9
I had a somewhat odd experience with the Lexus salesman on my test drive. I drove the F-Sport AWD and loved it, but he kept on trying to get me to drive the GS350 luxury model. (they had only a couple of F-Sport's, but MANY GS350 AWD Luxury models on the lot). I said, no thanks, I love the looks and espec the handling of the F-Sport. He then said that the handling of the Luxury models is the SAME as F-Sport models when they're driven in the Sport+ mode. I asked "Really? Are you sure? Are the suspension and steering in fact the same on the Luxury as the F-Sport when driven in the Sport+ mode?" He said YES, "the major differences are only cosmetic--plus different wheels/tires-- in the AWD models".
I knew this to be false, but said, no thanks, and even if so, "I love the looks and the F-Sport's cabernet interior, so I would choose the F-Sport anyway".
So it seems to me that maybe the GS350 Luxury models are falling through the cracks--people either choose the GS350 F-Sport, or the ES instead, and perhaps FEW choose the GS LUXURY....so that maybe the Lexus saleman have pressure on them to sell the GS Luxury models?....
(So I think that this is a shady saleman....but it does leave me with a question: Does the F-sport package impove the handling and suspension of the AWD model similarly to the RWD model? The reason I ask this is due to my research on the BMW 5-series recently. The M-Sport package on the RWD 535i does indeed tighten the suspension, but the M-Sport package on the AWD 535xi DOES NOT--it's only cosmetic--i.e., seats, steering wheel, fenders, etc... Thus my question: Is the F-Sport package on GS350 AWD different than the package on the GS350 RWD?? Is it only cosmetic in the AWD version, like the 5-Series? Did the salesman in fact tell me the truth?)
I knew this to be false, but said, no thanks, and even if so, "I love the looks and the F-Sport's cabernet interior, so I would choose the F-Sport anyway".
So it seems to me that maybe the GS350 Luxury models are falling through the cracks--people either choose the GS350 F-Sport, or the ES instead, and perhaps FEW choose the GS LUXURY....so that maybe the Lexus saleman have pressure on them to sell the GS Luxury models?....
(So I think that this is a shady saleman....but it does leave me with a question: Does the F-sport package impove the handling and suspension of the AWD model similarly to the RWD model? The reason I ask this is due to my research on the BMW 5-series recently. The M-Sport package on the RWD 535i does indeed tighten the suspension, but the M-Sport package on the AWD 535xi DOES NOT--it's only cosmetic--i.e., seats, steering wheel, fenders, etc... Thus my question: Is the F-Sport package on GS350 AWD different than the package on the GS350 RWD?? Is it only cosmetic in the AWD version, like the 5-Series? Did the salesman in fact tell me the truth?)
If there are a lot of Luxury models on the dealer lots, that's due to the fact that they sell well. Dealerships have no interest in stocking models which won't sell.
#10
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Sep 2012
Location: Michigan
Posts: 41
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Outrage--
I saw the interiors of all the models. The cabernet interior of the F-sport is stunning--almost a work of art. It's much more to my taste than the interior with wood trim. I also like the F-sport bumper and grill better. The only part of the F-sport package I don't like are the wheels, and they're going to go...
Also, it's possible that they had few F-Sports because they were selling them quickly, but couldn't move the Luxury models.....so I'm not sure about your statement
I saw the interiors of all the models. The cabernet interior of the F-sport is stunning--almost a work of art. It's much more to my taste than the interior with wood trim. I also like the F-sport bumper and grill better. The only part of the F-sport package I don't like are the wheels, and they're going to go...
Also, it's possible that they had few F-Sports because they were selling them quickly, but couldn't move the Luxury models.....so I'm not sure about your statement
#11
hockeyguy: I agree with the others comments, the differences are quite minimal and although you may feel the salesperson was dishonest, they probably didn't know any better.
Had it not been for stock availability, the Luxury is a better "value". You pay almost the same price as the F-Sport but get numerous more useful features.
THAT being said, I am very particular about my cars and I did notice a difference between the BASE AWD, F-Sport AWD, and Luxury AWD. I attribute it to the Base not having the AVS and the F-Sport having larger wheels. Aside from that those cars are mechnically quite close. The RWD is a slightly different story.
In short though, you can't go wrong. Great car and you'll love it. I'm personally happy the Luxury had a 3-month wait and I chose the F-Sport (two day wait) instead. The aggressive and cab interior have grown on me, and half the luxury features in the rear won't be used (carseats don't care about seat heaters).
Had it not been for stock availability, the Luxury is a better "value". You pay almost the same price as the F-Sport but get numerous more useful features.
THAT being said, I am very particular about my cars and I did notice a difference between the BASE AWD, F-Sport AWD, and Luxury AWD. I attribute it to the Base not having the AVS and the F-Sport having larger wheels. Aside from that those cars are mechnically quite close. The RWD is a slightly different story.
In short though, you can't go wrong. Great car and you'll love it. I'm personally happy the Luxury had a 3-month wait and I chose the F-Sport (two day wait) instead. The aggressive and cab interior have grown on me, and half the luxury features in the rear won't be used (carseats don't care about seat heaters).
#12
Pole Position
I had a somewhat odd experience with the Lexus salesman on my test drive. I drove the F-Sport AWD and loved it, but he kept on trying to get me to drive the GS350 luxury model. (they had only a couple of F-Sport's, but MANY GS350 AWD Luxury models on the lot). I said, no thanks, I love the looks and espec the handling of the F-Sport. He then said that the handling of the Luxury models is the SAME as F-Sport models when they're driven in the Sport+ mode. I asked "Really? Are you sure? Are the suspension and steering in fact the same on the Luxury as the F-Sport when driven in the Sport+ mode?" He said YES, "the major differences are only cosmetic--plus different wheels/tires-- in the AWD models".
I knew this to be false, but said, no thanks, and even if so, "I love the looks and the F-Sport's cabernet interior, so I would choose the F-Sport anyway".
So it seems to me that maybe the GS350 Luxury models are falling through the cracks--people either choose the GS350 F-Sport, or the ES instead, and perhaps FEW choose the GS LUXURY....so that maybe the Lexus saleman have pressure on them to sell the GS Luxury models?....
(So I think that this is a shady saleman....but it does leave me with a question: Does the F-sport package impove the handling and suspension of the AWD model similarly to the RWD model? The reason I ask this is due to my research on the BMW 5-series recently. The M-Sport package on the RWD 535i does indeed tighten the suspension, but the M-Sport package on the AWD 535xi DOES NOT--it's only cosmetic--i.e., seats, steering wheel, fenders, etc... Thus my question: Is the F-Sport package on GS350 AWD different than the package on the GS350 RWD?? Is it only cosmetic in the AWD version, like the 5-Series? Did the salesman in fact tell me the truth?)
I knew this to be false, but said, no thanks, and even if so, "I love the looks and the F-Sport's cabernet interior, so I would choose the F-Sport anyway".
So it seems to me that maybe the GS350 Luxury models are falling through the cracks--people either choose the GS350 F-Sport, or the ES instead, and perhaps FEW choose the GS LUXURY....so that maybe the Lexus saleman have pressure on them to sell the GS Luxury models?....
(So I think that this is a shady saleman....but it does leave me with a question: Does the F-sport package impove the handling and suspension of the AWD model similarly to the RWD model? The reason I ask this is due to my research on the BMW 5-series recently. The M-Sport package on the RWD 535i does indeed tighten the suspension, but the M-Sport package on the AWD 535xi DOES NOT--it's only cosmetic--i.e., seats, steering wheel, fenders, etc... Thus my question: Is the F-Sport package on GS350 AWD different than the package on the GS350 RWD?? Is it only cosmetic in the AWD version, like the 5-Series? Did the salesman in fact tell me the truth?)
All the mechanical performance advantages that F-Sport has over Luxury - Larger Front Rotors, VGRS, DRS (Rear Steering), staggered broader rear tires - are found only in the RWD models.
That said, the base structure of the 4GS is already very capable. Added to that, the AVS takes the ride-handling balance of the 4GS to the next level.
If I were to judge the contributions of each component to the total handling of a RWD F-Sport with DRS, they would be :
1) Basic suspension and chassis of the 4GS : 50%
2) AVS (Adaptive Variable Suspension) : 25%
3) Staggered 19" wheels of the RWD F-Sport : 10%
4) Larger Front Brakes (RWD only) : 5%
5) DRS (Rear Wheel Steering) : 10%
EDIT : I forgot about VGRS but it doesn't technically add to handling but sure adds to steering feel.
Last edited by natnut; 10-20-12 at 06:32 AM.
#13
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Sep 2012
Location: Michigan
Posts: 41
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The salesman is essentially telling the truth : For AWD models, there is not much difference dynamically between the Luxury and F-Sport package. Perhaps the software tuning for the AVS and VDIM is more sporty in the F-Sport.
All the mechanical performance advantages that F-Sport has over Luxury - Larger Front Rotors, VGRS, DRS (Rear Steering), staggered broader rear tires - are found only in the RWD models.
That said, the base structure of the 4GS is already very capable. Added to that, the AVS takes the ride-handling balance of the 4GS to the next level.
If I were to judge the contributions of each component to the total handling of a RWD F-Sport with DRS, they would be :
1) Basic suspension and chassis of the 4GS : 50%
2) AVS (Adaptive Variable Suspension) : 25%
3) Staggered 19" wheels of the RWD F-Sport : 10%
4) Larger Front Brakes (RWD only) : 5%
5) DRS (Rear Wheel Steering) : 10%
All the mechanical performance advantages that F-Sport has over Luxury - Larger Front Rotors, VGRS, DRS (Rear Steering), staggered broader rear tires - are found only in the RWD models.
That said, the base structure of the 4GS is already very capable. Added to that, the AVS takes the ride-handling balance of the 4GS to the next level.
If I were to judge the contributions of each component to the total handling of a RWD F-Sport with DRS, they would be :
1) Basic suspension and chassis of the 4GS : 50%
2) AVS (Adaptive Variable Suspension) : 25%
3) Staggered 19" wheels of the RWD F-Sport : 10%
4) Larger Front Brakes (RWD only) : 5%
5) DRS (Rear Wheel Steering) : 10%
#14
My question still remains:
Other than the wider tires, is there any handling difference between the Luxury and F-Sport-AWD-equipped models when driven in Sport+ mode?
My thinking is YES-- the F-sport package does indeed improve the steering and suspension in the AWD model as well as the RWD model.....is this correct? Any dealer guy on here that can answer?
Other than the wider tires, is there any handling difference between the Luxury and F-Sport-AWD-equipped models when driven in Sport+ mode?
My thinking is YES-- the F-sport package does indeed improve the steering and suspension in the AWD model as well as the RWD model.....is this correct? Any dealer guy on here that can answer?
#15
Lead Lap
Thread Starter
Why didn't you test drive both when you were given the opportunity? I test drove a standard model, an F Sport model, and I purchased a Luxury model. All of these models were AWD. I wasn't able to discern any meaningful differences in handling prowess between the F Sport and Luxury models. For roughly the same price as the F Sport model I was able to get a nicer interior and more useful features (IMO). All I had to sacrifice was a different front bumper, larger wheels, a spoiler, and the "F" badge on the front fender. All of those items are purely cosmetic.
If there are a lot of Luxury models on the dealer lots, that's due to the fact that they sell well. Dealerships have no interest in stocking models which won't sell.
If there are a lot of Luxury models on the dealer lots, that's due to the fact that they sell well. Dealerships have no interest in stocking models which won't sell.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post