View Poll Results: BMW 550/650 or Lexus GS350
Voters: 26. You may not vote on this poll
Bmw 550/650i Vs Lexus Gs350
#1
Lexus Champion
Thread Starter
Bmw 550/650i Vs Lexus Gs350
I've currently been asking many opinions on what car to get. I know it's going to come down to what I want, but I would like to get as much opinions as possible. I will e keeping this car for maybe 2-3 years so I want to make best of the time So I have narrowed it down to BMW or Lexus. (MAYBE an Infiniti M45)
I test drove a 550, and a 650i and I fell in love with the power the V8 produces. It urges me to push it more. I feel the interior more "modern" though I find it rough than the GS. I will be able to buy no problem but if it's going to cost an arm and a leg to mantain, I can't do it. I am currently saving for a house, and also starting college. BTW, I am talking about the E60 5 series.
I know the GS350 has a powerful V6 as well, and I know it's super reliable. I was also considering the LS430, but now that I drove one, I feel it's more more of an old man's car. I'm 23, so I feel the need for spirited driving at times I have not test driven this car, only got the chance to sit in it since it was late. I was not blown away with the interior, as the 2 tone dash almost reminded me of my GS3. It does feel VERY comfortable and plush though.
I guess what I'm looking for is for input on people who have owned any of the cars I've mentioned. Also, I know many opinions will be biased since this is a Lexus forums. If you could do it again, what car would YOU get? For the spirited drivers, does the GS350 keep you happy?
I test drove a 550, and a 650i and I fell in love with the power the V8 produces. It urges me to push it more. I feel the interior more "modern" though I find it rough than the GS. I will be able to buy no problem but if it's going to cost an arm and a leg to mantain, I can't do it. I am currently saving for a house, and also starting college. BTW, I am talking about the E60 5 series.
I know the GS350 has a powerful V6 as well, and I know it's super reliable. I was also considering the LS430, but now that I drove one, I feel it's more more of an old man's car. I'm 23, so I feel the need for spirited driving at times I have not test driven this car, only got the chance to sit in it since it was late. I was not blown away with the interior, as the 2 tone dash almost reminded me of my GS3. It does feel VERY comfortable and plush though.
I guess what I'm looking for is for input on people who have owned any of the cars I've mentioned. Also, I know many opinions will be biased since this is a Lexus forums. If you could do it again, what car would YOU get? For the spirited drivers, does the GS350 keep you happy?
Last edited by EN_VY; 03-14-11 at 09:57 PM.
#2
Pole Position
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Chicago
Posts: 272
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I looked at getting a 545, m45 and the gs430, simply wanted a nice styled car with enough power to keep me entertained for atleast 4 years. The general agreement is beemers will be costly to maintain, especially a higher mileage 550i, that's a lot more money you're gonna pay up front, they are more mod friendly, though. M45 styling is becoming outdated, the new m57 is sick, even a m37.
The 6 series is a touring coupe in a different category, if I was going to buy a coupe it wouldn't be a huge *** 6series.
You lean more towards a luxury car then a sports car, the GS is a good mix of both. Quality is there, power is there. If I could do it again, I'd go for the GS450hyrid simply for the gas I would save. mid twenties for mid teens is a big different in yearly gas.
The 6 series is a touring coupe in a different category, if I was going to buy a coupe it wouldn't be a huge *** 6series.
You lean more towards a luxury car then a sports car, the GS is a good mix of both. Quality is there, power is there. If I could do it again, I'd go for the GS450hyrid simply for the gas I would save. mid twenties for mid teens is a big different in yearly gas.
#3
I owned a 545i e60 And I traded it in for my GS350. I don't regret my decision at alll. I had a lot of problems with my e60. The car handled great and was faster but I couldn't drive the car in any snow even with blizztech tires. if the e60 doesn't have a cpo warranty then don't get it. You will be killing yourself in Maintence and repair cost.
#5
I will agree with rominl and I'll add one more thing...
Although the Lexus will be (based on the overall history of both brands) more reliable, I'm getting evidence that the parts for the Lexus may actually be more expensive then those for the BMW. This is just my initial opinion, I've owned BMWs for about 8 years and my 1st Lexus for only a couple months but I'm shocked at a few items that I've gotten prices on for the Lexus. I thought some BMW parts were on the high side but Lexus redefines High prices in terms of parts. They may not break often but when they do... oh my ($450 for a replacement fog light, $400+ for a side mirror... ouch
Although the Lexus will be (based on the overall history of both brands) more reliable, I'm getting evidence that the parts for the Lexus may actually be more expensive then those for the BMW. This is just my initial opinion, I've owned BMWs for about 8 years and my 1st Lexus for only a couple months but I'm shocked at a few items that I've gotten prices on for the Lexus. I thought some BMW parts were on the high side but Lexus redefines High prices in terms of parts. They may not break often but when they do... oh my ($450 for a replacement fog light, $400+ for a side mirror... ouch
#7
Driver
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: ohio
Posts: 165
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I've been driving BMW's for over 20 yrs, including a couple V12's & an E46 M3.
My last one(and I do mean last), was an 04 645 vert. Sounds, power, & looks are wonderful. I-drive & reliability were bad. I couldn't wait to get rid of it. We have pretty much replaced all BMW's with Audi's except this '07 GS350 that my wife drives. It's a wonderful combination of looks, room, power & economy. It's out of warranty this month; hopefully I will be just as happy in the future.
My last one(and I do mean last), was an 04 645 vert. Sounds, power, & looks are wonderful. I-drive & reliability were bad. I couldn't wait to get rid of it. We have pretty much replaced all BMW's with Audi's except this '07 GS350 that my wife drives. It's a wonderful combination of looks, room, power & economy. It's out of warranty this month; hopefully I will be just as happy in the future.
Trending Topics
#9
Lexus Champion
Thread Starter
I looked at getting a 545, m45 and the gs430, simply wanted a nice styled car with enough power to keep me entertained for atleast 4 years. The general agreement is beemers will be costly to maintain, especially a higher mileage 550i, that's a lot more money you're gonna pay up front, they are more mod friendly, though. M45 styling is becoming outdated, the new m57 is sick, even a m37.
The 6 series is a touring coupe in a different category, if I was going to buy a coupe it wouldn't be a huge *** 6series.
You lean more towards a luxury car then a sports car, the GS is a good mix of both. Quality is there, power is there. If I could do it again, I'd go for the GS450hyrid simply for the gas I would save. mid twenties for mid teens is a big different in yearly gas.
The 6 series is a touring coupe in a different category, if I was going to buy a coupe it wouldn't be a huge *** 6series.
You lean more towards a luxury car then a sports car, the GS is a good mix of both. Quality is there, power is there. If I could do it again, I'd go for the GS450hyrid simply for the gas I would save. mid twenties for mid teens is a big different in yearly gas.
I owned a 545i e60 And I traded it in for my GS350. I don't regret my decision at alll. I had a lot of problems with my e60. The car handled great and was faster but I couldn't drive the car in any snow even with blizztech tires. if the e60 doesn't have a cpo warranty then don't get it. You will be killing yourself in Maintence and repair cost.
I will agree with rominl and I'll add one more thing...
Although the Lexus will be (based on the overall history of both brands) more reliable, I'm getting evidence that the parts for the Lexus may actually be more expensive then those for the BMW. This is just my initial opinion, I've owned BMWs for about 8 years and my 1st Lexus for only a couple months but I'm shocked at a few items that I've gotten prices on for the Lexus. I thought some BMW parts were on the high side but Lexus redefines High prices in terms of parts. They may not break often but when they do... oh my ($450 for a replacement fog light, $400+ for a side mirror... ouch
Although the Lexus will be (based on the overall history of both brands) more reliable, I'm getting evidence that the parts for the Lexus may actually be more expensive then those for the BMW. This is just my initial opinion, I've owned BMWs for about 8 years and my 1st Lexus for only a couple months but I'm shocked at a few items that I've gotten prices on for the Lexus. I thought some BMW parts were on the high side but Lexus redefines High prices in terms of parts. They may not break often but when they do... oh my ($450 for a replacement fog light, $400+ for a side mirror... ouch
I've been driving BMW's for over 20 yrs, including a couple V12's & an E46 M3.
My last one(and I do mean last), was an 04 645 vert. Sounds, power, & looks are wonderful. I-drive & reliability were bad. I couldn't wait to get rid of it. We have pretty much replaced all BMW's with Audi's except this '07 GS350 that my wife drives. It's a wonderful combination of looks, room, power & economy. It's out of warranty this month; hopefully I will be just as happy in the future.
My last one(and I do mean last), was an 04 645 vert. Sounds, power, & looks are wonderful. I-drive & reliability were bad. I couldn't wait to get rid of it. We have pretty much replaced all BMW's with Audi's except this '07 GS350 that my wife drives. It's a wonderful combination of looks, room, power & economy. It's out of warranty this month; hopefully I will be just as happy in the future.
It's not THAT bad
#11
exclusive matchup
iTrader: (4)
Lol, I love the 6 series styling. It's a coupe, yet it's a big body
Ok, this is what I always wonder. I hear everyone talk about maitenace on the BMW, but what goes out/wrong? Parts that make the car undriveable?
I guess I love to drive. Sometimes I go out to "cruise" with no destination, just to clear my mind. Why does this decision have t be so hard?! Lol
That was my exact thoughts, because I went to the dealer a few times to try and buy replacements I had broken. I guess the difference is that the Lexus doesn't break often
Exactly what was going wrong? If you don't mind me asking. I LOVE the way the 6ser looks. I can live with i-drive, no biggie. I just don't want to be shelling out 1G every 2 months( a figure I approximate) to have it!
It's not THAT bad
Ok, this is what I always wonder. I hear everyone talk about maitenace on the BMW, but what goes out/wrong? Parts that make the car undriveable?
I guess I love to drive. Sometimes I go out to "cruise" with no destination, just to clear my mind. Why does this decision have t be so hard?! Lol
That was my exact thoughts, because I went to the dealer a few times to try and buy replacements I had broken. I guess the difference is that the Lexus doesn't break often
Exactly what was going wrong? If you don't mind me asking. I LOVE the way the 6ser looks. I can live with i-drive, no biggie. I just don't want to be shelling out 1G every 2 months( a figure I approximate) to have it!
It's not THAT bad
i don't think it's anymore the case to say it's cheaper to maintain (not fix) lexus, maintenance cost is just about the same at dealerships. but over time, parts probably tend to have problem more likely on bmw.
gs450h is better, but only if it has apsss.
#12
the initial idrive was designed by a bunch of engineers who have never driven a car beyond a gremlin.
it was slow, clunky and unresponsive.
now they are at least bearable. not great but not near as terrible.
it was slow, clunky and unresponsive.
now they are at least bearable. not great but not near as terrible.
#13
Rookie
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Illinois
Posts: 87
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I've currently been asking many opinions on what car to get. I know it's going to come down to what I want, but I would like to get as much opinions as possible. I will e keeping this car for maybe 2-3 years so I want to make best of the time So I have narrowed it down to BMW or Lexus. (MAYBE an Infiniti M45)
I test drove a 550, and a 650i and I fell in love with the power the V8 produces. It urges me to push it more. I feel the interior more "modern" though I find it rough than the GS. I will be able to buy no problem but if it's going to cost an arm and a leg to mantain, I can't do it. I am currently saving for a house, and also starting college. BTW, I am talking about the E60 5 series.
I know the GS350 has a powerful V6 as well, and I know it's super reliable. I was also considering the LS430, but now that I drove one, I feel it's more more of an old man's car. I'm 23, so I feel the need for spirited driving at times I have not test driven this car, only got the chance to sit in it since it was late. I was not blown away with the interior, as the 2 tone dash almost reminded me of my GS3. It does feel VERY comfortable and plush though.
I guess what I'm looking for is for input on people who have owned any of the cars I've mentioned. Also, I know many opinions will be biased since this is a Lexus forums. If you could do it again, what car would YOU get? For the spirited drivers, does the GS350 keep you happy?
I test drove a 550, and a 650i and I fell in love with the power the V8 produces. It urges me to push it more. I feel the interior more "modern" though I find it rough than the GS. I will be able to buy no problem but if it's going to cost an arm and a leg to mantain, I can't do it. I am currently saving for a house, and also starting college. BTW, I am talking about the E60 5 series.
I know the GS350 has a powerful V6 as well, and I know it's super reliable. I was also considering the LS430, but now that I drove one, I feel it's more more of an old man's car. I'm 23, so I feel the need for spirited driving at times I have not test driven this car, only got the chance to sit in it since it was late. I was not blown away with the interior, as the 2 tone dash almost reminded me of my GS3. It does feel VERY comfortable and plush though.
I guess what I'm looking for is for input on people who have owned any of the cars I've mentioned. Also, I know many opinions will be biased since this is a Lexus forums. If you could do it again, what car would YOU get? For the spirited drivers, does the GS350 keep you happy?
#14
Some the problems I had was the I drive would be real slow. Then I had problems with the electrical problems with the car and it took BMW NA over a month to find the problem. Then I had a trans gasket and oil pan gasket leak. Then the radiator had a leak. I also had random trans slamms.
#15
It depends on the age of the car. I prefer a BMW V8 over a Lexus V6, no question, but if its an older car with no warranty forget about it. It will cost you too much to own.