Battle of the Big 3! GS series vs 5 series vs E class
#17
Originally Posted by 1SICKLEX
2. No rebates. Rebates destroys a cars resale and image. You won't see these 3 cars with ads saying "get 8k off MSRP". It just won't happen, instead of rebates, the companies will add perks, lower financing rate specials or simply add more features and freshen the cars up.
#18
I really think the Infinit M 35/45 will shock the industry. I know about the heritage of the others but many sedan owners are ready for something fresh and affordable. I have owned 2 G-35s and greatly appreciated their balance of performance and value. I'm in the air right now between the previous 540ia, M 35 and GS 300. Price will probably be a large deciding factor.
#19
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally Posted by SpoonSport
I really think the Infinit M 35/45 will shock the industry. I know about the heritage of the others but many sedan owners are ready for something fresh and affordable. I have owned 2 G-35s and greatly appreciated their balance of performance and value. I'm in the air right now between the previous 540ia, M 35 and GS 300. Price will probably be a large deciding factor.
The car is outstanding competiton and will give buyers finally another Japanese alternative.
#20
1SICK-Lex: I've seen so mnay people concerned about the price of the car. They equate price with prestige and quality. I don't think that's the case. Until the GS, I felt my '02 Maxima ws one of my best overall cars. It had power, space and a well appointed interior. I chose to drive it instead of the G-35. I haven't seen the interior of the M-series and I can't until May. I get out of the desert then. I've missed a whole year of car shows ad test drives. I base a lot of my assessment from you guys. I'm glad pix are starting to pop up.
Spoon
Spoon
#21
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally Posted by SpoonSport
1SICK-Lex: I've seen so mnay people concerned about the price of the car. They equate price with prestige and quality. I don't think that's the case. Until the GS, I felt my '02 Maxima ws one of my best overall cars. It had power, space and a well appointed interior. I chose to drive it instead of the G-35. I haven't seen the interior of the M-series and I can't until May. I get out of the desert then. I've missed a whole year of car shows ad test drives. I base a lot of my assessment from you guys. I'm glad pix are starting to pop up.
Spoon
Spoon
If u mean the desert like "the desert" ,dude, if I can e-mail you anything about these cars (anything real specific) or maybe send a brochure (I think it may take a month or 2 to reach, correct?)let me know. seloc1@gmail.com
In all honestly, for Nissan fans, I can now finally see progressive steps, up to the M35/45 for those that don't want to leave the company.
#22
I had a great experience with the dealership in Hawaii from Infiniti. That's where I bought the two G 35s. My sedan was shipped to Bama and traded for the GS. I'm really liking the new GS and my short list is down to M-35 Sport, '06 GS 300, E-39 540i or '04 LS 430. The market is tough these days. The new GS and M raised the bar enven higher. I also dabble at freshalloy for Infiniti info. It looks like its gonna come down to a coin toss. My wife is test driving for me but I want to lean on the sport end of the sport-sedan market.
Mail isn't slow like it was during Desert Storm. The military realizes how important mail really is to us. This time around isn't bad at all. I have a Dubs GS430, IS 300 and R-34 Skyline on my desk right now. I went off topic.....
Spoon
Mail isn't slow like it was during Desert Storm. The military realizes how important mail really is to us. This time around isn't bad at all. I have a Dubs GS430, IS 300 and R-34 Skyline on my desk right now. I went off topic.....
Spoon
#23
Guest
Posts: n/a
All right, now its too early to tell but here is what we can say
1. The first full month of battle, the E took the biggest hit in sales.
2. The 5 seems to be untouched so far.
3. The GS is 3rd in sales after the E and 5 and Lexus has fully hit its target with the GS.
In comparisons, the GS has beat the 5 and E every time, based on price and in the new Automobile, based on engine size (V-8). There have been no GS 300 vs E/5 comparison tests yet but its gonna be tough, both the E and 5 will have updated V-6s when this battle rolls around.
1. The first full month of battle, the E took the biggest hit in sales.
2. The 5 seems to be untouched so far.
3. The GS is 3rd in sales after the E and 5 and Lexus has fully hit its target with the GS.
In comparisons, the GS has beat the 5 and E every time, based on price and in the new Automobile, based on engine size (V-8). There have been no GS 300 vs E/5 comparison tests yet but its gonna be tough, both the E and 5 will have updated V-6s when this battle rolls around.
#24
The Kelley Blue Book thing with BMW is disingenous, because it is based on 'projected value' of which only in the most recent year has BMW come out slightly ahead. So, no, on the contrary I don't think Lexus doesn't want the customers (you) to read the Kelley Blue Book at all.
#26
Originally Posted by 1SICKLEX
I am not sure of shock the industry, the car hasn't made a cover yet on any auto magazine.. It will sell well for Infiiniti and finally give them luxury car success. Credit the low price, which is attaniable by sharing so many important parts. They want to sell 20k a year, which is very modest. At its debut in 1998, 30k GSs were sold and just last year, over 50k 5 series and E classes were sold (though they have so many varients with engine choices, wagons, etc, that is what helps).
The car is outstanding competiton and will give buyers finally another Japanese alternative.
The car is outstanding competiton and will give buyers finally another Japanese alternative.
#27
There is a misconception on the resale value.
It really depends on which model of BMW vs Lexus you are talking about. The 5 series actually hold value very well as compared to the GS. While the E46/E65 (due to 2002 disaster roll out of the I-drive and electronic issues) tends to depreciates faster.
Mercedes resale value has gone down quiet a bit and is actually worse than BMW and in some cases Audi.
BMW M models depreciates very slowly even when new one comes out.
As far as dealer service goes. The lexus and mercedes are both quiet good. BMW on the other hand needs professional help.
As far as price goes, if you owned the car over 4 year period, the BMW price is not that bad. Since the maint program also covers brakes and host of others. I did a comparison a while back between my wife's TL and my 530i. My TL actually costed me more to own than the 530i.
Lexus service is not that cheap. You are looking at 5k service for around $100 (in bay area), 15k at around $300, and 30k at $600.
Plus you will probably spend close to $1k on the brakes in 4 years.
Adding up service through out 50k miles 5k, 10k, 20k, 25k, 35k, 40k, 50k=$700 15k/45k=$600
30k $600= $1900 in expense. In addition add another $1k for brakes and other wear items.
You are adding about $3k to the price of GS.
The initial price difference is high, but figuring overall cost through out 4 year period you will find that the price difference is not really that bad. Also, it will also depends on the insurance cost.
I haven't had a lexus since 01. So I won't comment on that. But wife's TL an my sienna costed me more to insure than my E500 (per Wanwanesa).
So pricing issues needs to be carefully reviewed.
In addition, although BMW does not publish incentives. They are currently blowing the E60 (old engine) and E46 out of the door right now. I know that E46 currently has $6,000 incentive (i.e. you can get one for about $5k off invoice on stock cars). I think E60 has $4k incentive.
You just need to take time to find better deal. I also believe that mercedes is also offering around $6k incentives on 05 W211 as well. A loaded E500 can be bought for around $59k easily right now.
It really depends on which model of BMW vs Lexus you are talking about. The 5 series actually hold value very well as compared to the GS. While the E46/E65 (due to 2002 disaster roll out of the I-drive and electronic issues) tends to depreciates faster.
Mercedes resale value has gone down quiet a bit and is actually worse than BMW and in some cases Audi.
BMW M models depreciates very slowly even when new one comes out.
As far as dealer service goes. The lexus and mercedes are both quiet good. BMW on the other hand needs professional help.
As far as price goes, if you owned the car over 4 year period, the BMW price is not that bad. Since the maint program also covers brakes and host of others. I did a comparison a while back between my wife's TL and my 530i. My TL actually costed me more to own than the 530i.
Lexus service is not that cheap. You are looking at 5k service for around $100 (in bay area), 15k at around $300, and 30k at $600.
Plus you will probably spend close to $1k on the brakes in 4 years.
Adding up service through out 50k miles 5k, 10k, 20k, 25k, 35k, 40k, 50k=$700 15k/45k=$600
30k $600= $1900 in expense. In addition add another $1k for brakes and other wear items.
You are adding about $3k to the price of GS.
The initial price difference is high, but figuring overall cost through out 4 year period you will find that the price difference is not really that bad. Also, it will also depends on the insurance cost.
I haven't had a lexus since 01. So I won't comment on that. But wife's TL an my sienna costed me more to insure than my E500 (per Wanwanesa).
So pricing issues needs to be carefully reviewed.
In addition, although BMW does not publish incentives. They are currently blowing the E60 (old engine) and E46 out of the door right now. I know that E46 currently has $6,000 incentive (i.e. you can get one for about $5k off invoice on stock cars). I think E60 has $4k incentive.
You just need to take time to find better deal. I also believe that mercedes is also offering around $6k incentives on 05 W211 as well. A loaded E500 can be bought for around $59k easily right now.
#28
Lexus Connoisseur
Originally Posted by chiawei
Lexus service is not that cheap. You are looking at 5k service for around $100 (in bay area), 15k at around $300, and 30k at $600.
Plus you will probably spend close to $1k on the brakes in 4 years.
Adding up service through out 50k miles 5k, 10k, 20k, 25k, 35k, 40k, 50k=$700 15k/45k=$600
30k $600= $1900 in expense. In addition add another $1k for brakes and other wear items.
You are adding about $3k to the price of GS.
#29
SpoonSport,
Don't let yourself fall too much in love with the M, based on reading, before you get a chance to see it in person. A lot of people (myself included) don't find the styling very attractive. About the only part I can stomach is the side profile. The rest of the car (from a styling perspective) doesn't do it for me at all. Of course, everyone sees things differently, so you might see it and fall in love.
Don't let yourself fall too much in love with the M, based on reading, before you get a chance to see it in person. A lot of people (myself included) don't find the styling very attractive. About the only part I can stomach is the side profile. The rest of the car (from a styling perspective) doesn't do it for me at all. Of course, everyone sees things differently, so you might see it and fall in love.
#30
Originally Posted by flipside909
$1k on brakes in 4 years? That's overinflated as well as the service costs you just listed. Granted you take your vehicle for service outside the dealership and plan to keep it more than 4 years or put a lot of mileage like myself, servicing/maintaining a Lexus isn't as expensive as most people perceive it to be.
You wish this is inflated. But this is how much dealers in silicon valley charges.
I am simply comparing things on equal footing. The BMW are serviced at dealers for free of charge. In order to compare on same footing, you have to compare what Lexus charges to service their vehicles. Everyone can change their own oil, replace their own brakes. But that's not the same as having dealers working on it.
BMW's free maint program is very good for people that keeps their car less than 4 years. I never keep my cars that long, hence the initial price difference is not really there.
However if you are going to put a lot of miles or keep the car past the 4 year period, the lexus becomes cheaper to own. German service are expansive. Oil change alone is already over $100.
BTW, if you have problem with the service cost, then go complain to lexus dealers in the bay area. I did not make up the cost. The cost is simply what it is.