ECO mode is bogus (or faulty??)
#1
Driver
Thread Starter
ECO mode is bogus (or faulty??)
I have been working the ECO mode a bunch recently trying to get my MPG better (I have AWD RX350 2010, best yet is 21mpg after 5000 miles)
So I go into cruise control (which is goood for economy right ?- no herky jerky) ECO light is on, bargraph shows nothing (you can toggle to bargraph from the steering wheel while in cruise)- ie implies good economy. But I am doing 60 mph so clearly I must be using some gas - so why is the bar graph at zero?
Then when I step on gas while still in cruise, the ECO green light goes off - as you would expect. But the bar graph still is on zero??
And when I use the cruise lever to accelerate while in cruise (using the + function) the ECO light stays green - despite the fact that the acceleration is at least the same as my pedal acceleration above.
So what gives? Is the whole ECO indication bogus? Or do I need a service check?
Please let me know if you experience the same behaviour..
So I go into cruise control (which is goood for economy right ?- no herky jerky) ECO light is on, bargraph shows nothing (you can toggle to bargraph from the steering wheel while in cruise)- ie implies good economy. But I am doing 60 mph so clearly I must be using some gas - so why is the bar graph at zero?
Then when I step on gas while still in cruise, the ECO green light goes off - as you would expect. But the bar graph still is on zero??
And when I use the cruise lever to accelerate while in cruise (using the + function) the ECO light stays green - despite the fact that the acceleration is at least the same as my pedal acceleration above.
So what gives? Is the whole ECO indication bogus? Or do I need a service check?
Please let me know if you experience the same behaviour..
#2
Driver
Thread Starter
Wow 69 views and no responses.
Does no-one else have this problem or know they have this problem? Or is it too complicated for you to observe that there's a problem?
Very simply put for the inattentive: When you are in cruise control with the eco light green, does the light go off if the gears kick down as you go uphill. Mine doesn't.
Does no-one else have this problem or know they have this problem? Or is it too complicated for you to observe that there's a problem?
Very simply put for the inattentive: When you are in cruise control with the eco light green, does the light go off if the gears kick down as you go uphill. Mine doesn't.
#3
I turned the light off shortly after getting the car. Then a few weeks ago turned it on, and tried to drive in a manner that kept the light on. My MPG went up by about 2, and the fun factor went to ZIP, NADA. For the extra $100 a year I'd be saving, I drive it like I stole it, and couldn't care less about that light.
You're assuming that the ECO light programming and that graph programming are tied together, which they may not be. It does make sense that the light is programmed to stay on while cruise is on, to get you in the habit of using cruise, like Pavlov's dog. But I do think you're way over-thinking how sophisticated that light and graph are.
You're assuming that the ECO light programming and that graph programming are tied together, which they may not be. It does make sense that the light is programmed to stay on while cruise is on, to get you in the habit of using cruise, like Pavlov's dog. But I do think you're way over-thinking how sophisticated that light and graph are.
Last edited by jay_man2; 07-10-10 at 07:10 PM.
#4
I have a 450h so this is not a direct comparison.
When using my cruise control the ECO light does go out when the venicle is accelerating at a higher rate. It comes back on when it "settles in".
Where you have a tachometer I have a Hybrid System Indicator gauge. Anytime that this gauge moves out of the green and into the white "power" area, the ECO light goes off.
When using my cruise control the ECO light does go out when the venicle is accelerating at a higher rate. It comes back on when it "settles in".
Where you have a tachometer I have a Hybrid System Indicator gauge. Anytime that this gauge moves out of the green and into the white "power" area, the ECO light goes off.
#5
Moderator
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: San Francisco, CA
Posts: 12,055
Likes: 0
Received 74 Likes
on
45 Posts
the ECO bar graph does not represent how much gas you are using. It represents how efficient you are driving. Therefore, when you step on the gas a little, even though you are using more gas, the bar graph doesnt have to change because it just means you are acelerating economically.
#6
I have a 450h so this is not a direct comparison.
When using my cruise control the ECO light does go out when the venicle is accelerating at a higher rate. It comes back on when it "settles in".
Where you have a tachometer I have a Hybrid System Indicator gauge. Anytime that this gauge moves out of the green and into the white "power" area, the ECO light goes off.
When using my cruise control the ECO light does go out when the venicle is accelerating at a higher rate. It comes back on when it "settles in".
Where you have a tachometer I have a Hybrid System Indicator gauge. Anytime that this gauge moves out of the green and into the white "power" area, the ECO light goes off.
#7
I watched my "bar graph" closely this weekend. When using cruise at about 70 mph, the graph shows about 25 mpg. Using the cruise lever to slow down, the graph zooms up to 60 mpg.
I don't think yours works. Or at least not like mine.
I don't think yours works. Or at least not like mine.
Trending Topics
#8
Moderator
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: San Francisco, CA
Posts: 12,055
Likes: 0
Received 74 Likes
on
45 Posts
^^ there are two different bar graphs. One is instantaneous mpg and it is the bar graph with the 30, 60, 90 markers. The ECO bargraph doesnt have any markers.
1st one looks like this
I think we are talking about this one (2nd one)
1st one looks like this
I think we are talking about this one (2nd one)
#9
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: WA
Posts: 49
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I have been working the ECO mode a bunch recently trying to get my MPG better (I have AWD RX350 2010, best yet is 21mpg after 5000 miles)
So I go into cruise control (which is goood for economy right ?- no herky jerky) ECO light is on, bargraph shows nothing (you can toggle to bargraph from the steering wheel while in cruise)- ie implies good economy. But I am doing 60 mph so clearly I must be using some gas - so why is the bar graph at zero?
Then when I step on gas while still in cruise, the ECO green light goes off - as you would expect. But the bar graph still is on zero??
And when I use the cruise lever to accelerate while in cruise (using the + function) the ECO light stays green - despite the fact that the acceleration is at least the same as my pedal acceleration above.
So what gives? Is the whole ECO indication bogus? Or do I need a service check?
Please let me know if you experience the same behaviour..
So I go into cruise control (which is goood for economy right ?- no herky jerky) ECO light is on, bargraph shows nothing (you can toggle to bargraph from the steering wheel while in cruise)- ie implies good economy. But I am doing 60 mph so clearly I must be using some gas - so why is the bar graph at zero?
Then when I step on gas while still in cruise, the ECO green light goes off - as you would expect. But the bar graph still is on zero??
And when I use the cruise lever to accelerate while in cruise (using the + function) the ECO light stays green - despite the fact that the acceleration is at least the same as my pedal acceleration above.
So what gives? Is the whole ECO indication bogus? Or do I need a service check?
Please let me know if you experience the same behaviour..
#10
I have been working the ECO mode a bunch recently trying to get my MPG better (I have AWD RX350 2010, best yet is 21mpg after 5000 miles)
So I go into cruise control (which is goood for economy right ?- no herky jerky) ECO light is on, bargraph shows nothing (you can toggle to bargraph from the steering wheel while in cruise)- ie implies good economy. But I am doing 60 mph so clearly I must be using some gas - so why is the bar graph at zero?
Then when I step on gas while still in cruise, the ECO green light goes off - as you would expect. But the bar graph still is on zero??
And when I use the cruise lever to accelerate while in cruise (using the + function) the ECO light stays green - despite the fact that the acceleration is at least the same as my pedal acceleration above.
So what gives? Is the whole ECO indication bogus? Or do I need a service check?
Please let me know if you experience the same behaviour..
So I go into cruise control (which is goood for economy right ?- no herky jerky) ECO light is on, bargraph shows nothing (you can toggle to bargraph from the steering wheel while in cruise)- ie implies good economy. But I am doing 60 mph so clearly I must be using some gas - so why is the bar graph at zero?
Then when I step on gas while still in cruise, the ECO green light goes off - as you would expect. But the bar graph still is on zero??
And when I use the cruise lever to accelerate while in cruise (using the + function) the ECO light stays green - despite the fact that the acceleration is at least the same as my pedal acceleration above.
So what gives? Is the whole ECO indication bogus? Or do I need a service check?
Please let me know if you experience the same behaviour..
The purpose of these indicators is to get the driver to save gas while actually operating the gas pedal anyway.
#11
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: NY
Posts: 25
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Cough,
Something is wrong with your bar graph. I've noticed that there is a slight lag with the bar graph, but you should not see an empty bar during cruise control for more than a few seconds if you are not accelerating or driving up a sleep slope. Have it checked out during your next service.
Something is wrong with your bar graph. I've noticed that there is a slight lag with the bar graph, but you should not see an empty bar during cruise control for more than a few seconds if you are not accelerating or driving up a sleep slope. Have it checked out during your next service.
#12
Driver
Thread Starter
Cough,
Something is wrong with your bar graph. I've noticed that there is a slight lag with the bar graph, but you should not see an empty bar during cruise control for more than a few seconds if you are not accelerating or driving up a sleep slope. Have it checked out during your next service.
Something is wrong with your bar graph. I've noticed that there is a slight lag with the bar graph, but you should not see an empty bar during cruise control for more than a few seconds if you are not accelerating or driving up a sleep slope. Have it checked out during your next service.
#14
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: NY
Posts: 25
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I ignore the ECO bar anyway. The ECO bar/light are less relevant than the MPG data because one's driving is efficient or good "ecologically" insofar as it is yielding good gas mileage. In other words, the ECO indicator is a proxy for mpg.
#15
Pole Position
Ever since cruise control has been a part of the automobile, it was well known, documented and still is that "it" is more efficient and yields more MPGs than the unaided driver. Evidently, the Eco graph and light are there to help the driver achieve (teach) higher fuel economies, and not the cruise control system. So, displaying the cruise control's performance is completely redundant, to say the least...