460 SWB vs 430 rear legroom
#61
Racer
Thread Starter
The LX570 may seem like a barge but it is only 199 inches long. 205 inches isn't that all that long although the LS460L I test drove in 2011 seemed seemed huge and bigger than it was. Some SUV's are much larger. The Chevy Suburban and Yukon XL are 225 inches long and friends and relatives that have them don't seem to have difficulty driving them and finding parking places.
If you want massive rear legroom, go back to the Sienna which which is slightly longer and wider than the LX570. When our Sienna Limited is in what I call "four passenger mode", both rear (adult) passengers can use the ottoman leg rests when the front seats are occupied. The only sedans I've seen that can do that are the Maybach 62 and Mercedes S-class Pullman. Here's a slightly altered photo showing my wife the first time she saw the Sienna when when I picked her up at the airport - I gave her a glass of her favorite Pinot Grigio wine and put one of favorite movies on the overhead video screen.
I considered buying "just one more LS" in early 2014 before I decided on the Sienna but only if I could get one in white with PCS and DRCC. I don't know how hard the Lexus dealer person really tried but he told me that he was unable to find a white SWB LS460 with PCS/DRCC although I think he found one in black. It took exactly four weeks to get a white Sienna with PCS and DRCC custom built to my specifications. After decades of driving Mercedes and Lexus sedans, it's unexpectedly refreshing to drive a high feature "stealth limo" that almost nobody pays attention to ... until they get inside it.
If you want massive rear legroom, go back to the Sienna which which is slightly longer and wider than the LX570. When our Sienna Limited is in what I call "four passenger mode", both rear (adult) passengers can use the ottoman leg rests when the front seats are occupied. The only sedans I've seen that can do that are the Maybach 62 and Mercedes S-class Pullman. Here's a slightly altered photo showing my wife the first time she saw the Sienna when when I picked her up at the airport - I gave her a glass of her favorite Pinot Grigio wine and put one of favorite movies on the overhead video screen.
I considered buying "just one more LS" in early 2014 before I decided on the Sienna but only if I could get one in white with PCS and DRCC. I don't know how hard the Lexus dealer person really tried but he told me that he was unable to find a white SWB LS460 with PCS/DRCC although I think he found one in black. It took exactly four weeks to get a white Sienna with PCS and DRCC custom built to my specifications. After decades of driving Mercedes and Lexus sedans, it's unexpectedly refreshing to drive a high feature "stealth limo" that almost nobody pays attention to ... until they get inside it.
#62
Lexus Fanatic
Insofar as minivans, the new Chrysler Pacifica is the nicest riding, quietest one. Driven all of them too lol
The issue with the LX is not length, it's just a huge heavy vehicle and feels heavy. Something like a Range Rover feels smaller than it is, the LX feels bigger than it is.
The issue with the LX is not length, it's just a huge heavy vehicle and feels heavy. Something like a Range Rover feels smaller than it is, the LX feels bigger than it is.
#63
Lead Lap
The best thing about the LX is the resale value is going to be off the charts. Especially if purchasing preowned, it is the type of vehicle that will hold its value.
While this time around, I really do prefer the Land Cruiser over the LX, it is simply one of those vehicles that you can reasonably expect to get 300,000 miles out of.
Unlike the RR, the LX retains a live rear axle so as to give at least the wherewithal to go off-road in some pretty crazy places. It is also perhaps the best vehicle on the market for driving in driving in serious amounts of snow owing to its ground clearance and AWD system.
Granted, most who spend what even an LX costs rarely will go off tarmac. While I do appreciate that thanks to all of the RR's trick electronics, it can hold its own, but the 200 Series is what you see being used in some of the most inhospitable terrain in the world and folks like the UN and so forth use the less gussied up version to this day.
There is no denying that it is an actual SUV with traditional body on frame construction. That said, it could not possibly be more different than an LS obviously. That said, I really do miss my LX470, but still happy with my decision and not getting 10 MPG is great.
While this time around, I really do prefer the Land Cruiser over the LX, it is simply one of those vehicles that you can reasonably expect to get 300,000 miles out of.
Unlike the RR, the LX retains a live rear axle so as to give at least the wherewithal to go off-road in some pretty crazy places. It is also perhaps the best vehicle on the market for driving in driving in serious amounts of snow owing to its ground clearance and AWD system.
Granted, most who spend what even an LX costs rarely will go off tarmac. While I do appreciate that thanks to all of the RR's trick electronics, it can hold its own, but the 200 Series is what you see being used in some of the most inhospitable terrain in the world and folks like the UN and so forth use the less gussied up version to this day.
There is no denying that it is an actual SUV with traditional body on frame construction. That said, it could not possibly be more different than an LS obviously. That said, I really do miss my LX470, but still happy with my decision and not getting 10 MPG is great.
#64
Lexus Test Driver
Close, but not quite. The Valiant was 195" long.
Still, pretty large for a mid-size car.
I know what you mean about no power steering...I've owned five cars with no power steering or brakes. Liked the brake feel, but the steering, when parking, could be unpleasant. Large steering wheels help, but to this day, I don't turn the steering wheel while stationary, out of habit. I mean, you could without PS, but it was a drag.
#65
Lexus Fanatic
Close, but not quite. The Valiant was 195" long.
Still, pretty large for a mid-size car.
I know what you mean about no power steering...I've owned five cars with no power steering or brakes. Liked the brake feel, but the steering, when parking, could be unpleasant. Large steering wheels help, but to this day, I don't turn the steering wheel while stationary, out of habit. I mean, you could without PS, but it was a drag.
Still, pretty large for a mid-size car.
I know what you mean about no power steering...I've owned five cars with no power steering or brakes. Liked the brake feel, but the steering, when parking, could be unpleasant. Large steering wheels help, but to this day, I don't turn the steering wheel while stationary, out of habit. I mean, you could without PS, but it was a drag.
The following users liked this post:
mckellyb (02-18-17)
#67
Racer
Thread Starter
Now the old Q7 is a different matter, the all new for 2017 Q7 is what I'm talking about, which had a lot of improvements over the previous Q7. I wasn't nearly as impressed with the old Q7 as I am the new Q7:
Spec'ed out exactly like I would want a Q7 Prestige new is $76k...which I expect to be ~ $20k less than an equally equipped LS500.
Spec'ed out exactly like I would want a Q7 Prestige new is $76k...which I expect to be ~ $20k less than an equally equipped LS500.
I just don't know where to take it to locally for maintenance and I don't have any clue how much it costs to maintain a Porsche. The Porsche forums are not as helpful as CL. I can't even find interior dimensions to compare against other vehicles.
#68
Lexus Fanatic
Neat vehicle, but nowhere near as comfort oriented as the LS.
#69
The Porsche Cayenne is extremely high maintenance like any Porsche. If you're considering purchasing one you could call a Porsche dealer service department or a independent shop that services Porsche and they could guide you. I had a neighbor who owned a Porsche and he said an oil changed cost almost $500 but he was surgeon.
#71
Racer
Thread Starter
The Porsche Cayenne is extremely high maintenance like any Porsche. If you're considering purchasing one you could call a Porsche dealer service department or a independent shop that services Porsche and they could guide you. I had a neighbor who owned a Porsche and he said an oil changed cost almost $500 but he was surgeon.
Yikes! Thanks for the warnings, dlbuckls and greg! I dug around a little more last night and found a reference to $200 oil changes but even that is almost $1,000 annually at the rate I drive. Geez, and I thought the LS air shock replacement was bad. I guess the Cayenne is relatively cheap to buy, but expensive to own.
#72
Lexus Fanatic
You can get quality oil filters for the Cayenne at about ten bucks apiece (Mahl or Mann). Use Mobil 1 0W40 Euro at Walmart, and your well under 75 bucks for an oil change.....or about the same price as an LS460 oil service.
#73
Racer
Thread Starter
EDIT: Coworker's husband will call me back later. Their 2016 was bought new and now has 10K miles. Dealership oil change was $400.
Last edited by FatherTo1; 02-14-17 at 10:20 AM.
#74
Lexus Test Driver
Chris brought up a good point here regarding what the cost of an oil change really "could" be...
Learning about the idiosyncrasies of this car and its upkeep cost may prove to be quite costly if using the dealership for all services.
But as many of us know, regarding the LS, if you find a reputable indy, that should cut down on the dollar tally a good bit, but how much who knows...
The LS (older model) has been fairly easy to work on via DIY but I wonder how that would translate over to the German-made Cayenne.
Can you just pop out an old battery and replace it like a traditional car, or does it require some sort of programming like the BMW?
Can you just change the filter, drain and fill the oil or is there something else to it that can or cant be done in your garage?
Brakes, radiator/coolant, alternator, starter, etc.
I think your on the right track doing as much homework and question asking as possible.
That, for me was what helped me seal the deal and pull the trigger on an LS, as there are really only a handful of issues that plagued the older models, and if your handy, the issues aren't really a big deal.
Looking forward to hear about the feedback you receive.
Learning about the idiosyncrasies of this car and its upkeep cost may prove to be quite costly if using the dealership for all services.
But as many of us know, regarding the LS, if you find a reputable indy, that should cut down on the dollar tally a good bit, but how much who knows...
The LS (older model) has been fairly easy to work on via DIY but I wonder how that would translate over to the German-made Cayenne.
Can you just pop out an old battery and replace it like a traditional car, or does it require some sort of programming like the BMW?
Can you just change the filter, drain and fill the oil or is there something else to it that can or cant be done in your garage?
Brakes, radiator/coolant, alternator, starter, etc.
I think your on the right track doing as much homework and question asking as possible.
That, for me was what helped me seal the deal and pull the trigger on an LS, as there are really only a handful of issues that plagued the older models, and if your handy, the issues aren't really a big deal.
Looking forward to hear about the feedback you receive.
#75
Racer
Thread Starter
Chris brought up a good point here regarding what the cost of an oil change really "could" be...
Learning about the idiosyncrasies of this car and its upkeep cost may prove to be quite costly if using the dealership for all services.
But as many of us know, regarding the LS, if you find a reputable indy, that should cut down on the dollar tally a good bit, but how much who knows...
The LS (older model) has been fairly easy to work on via DIY but I wonder how that would translate over to the German-made Cayenne.
Can you just pop out an old battery and replace it like a traditional car, or does it require some sort of programming like the BMW?
Can you just change the filter, drain and fill the oil or is there something else to it that can or cant be done in your garage?
Brakes, radiator/coolant, alternator, starter, etc.
I think your on the right track doing as much homework and question asking as possible.
That, for me was what helped me seal the deal and pull the trigger on an LS, as there are really only a handful of issues that plagued the older models, and if your handy, the issues aren't really a big deal.
Looking forward to hear about the feedback you receive.
Learning about the idiosyncrasies of this car and its upkeep cost may prove to be quite costly if using the dealership for all services.
But as many of us know, regarding the LS, if you find a reputable indy, that should cut down on the dollar tally a good bit, but how much who knows...
The LS (older model) has been fairly easy to work on via DIY but I wonder how that would translate over to the German-made Cayenne.
Can you just pop out an old battery and replace it like a traditional car, or does it require some sort of programming like the BMW?
Can you just change the filter, drain and fill the oil or is there something else to it that can or cant be done in your garage?
Brakes, radiator/coolant, alternator, starter, etc.
I think your on the right track doing as much homework and question asking as possible.
That, for me was what helped me seal the deal and pull the trigger on an LS, as there are really only a handful of issues that plagued the older models, and if your handy, the issues aren't really a big deal.
Looking forward to hear about the feedback you receive.
Surprisingly (to me at least), the Cayenne backseat is wider and roomier than our LS 430. Actually, the seat isn't as wide as the LS 430 but, because of how the doors are scallopped, the Cayenne affords more hip and shoulder space when sitting on either side of a Britax car seat placed in the middle. The Cayenne rode very stiff along the broken streets of downtown Sacramento. However, the ride greatly improved on the highway despite the 21-inch wheels. Of course I shouldn't expect a soft ride since that isn't what the Cayenne was designed for. Freeway on-ramps and clovers put an instant smile on my face as the Cayenne showed tenacious grip with nary any body roll or lean! This is a great SUV but I wouldn't consider it for a daily driver, more as a secondary weekend car (in which case I would probably just grab a Boxster S). The Cayenne V8 had great power once it got going. Strangely, even though they just had it inspected and tuned up at the same Porsche auto shop that I researched earlier, the engine felt lethargic and slow to respond on initial pedal tip-in. The brakes also seemed very grabby after the new pads and rotors. Overall, it was a fun SUV to drive but lacked smoothness. I am glad to have experienced the test drive as it reaffirms the LS is the right car for me. Everything I've test driven so far makes me want to go back to the LS. At least with the LS I already know who to take it to when maintenance is needed.
The following 3 users liked this post by FatherTo1: