jrmckinley

My mom is looking to replace her 2002 Toyota Highlander which she bought brand new and has driven 175k trouble-free miles. Her main requirements are a quiet ride (extremely important), back up camera, blind spot monitoring, a good warranty, high reliability, good visibility, safe, and needs to be comparable to size of her generation of Highlander. New Highlander feels too big for her. She will most likely buy brand new and will opt for the higher-end option package to get leather and all of the goodies. She most likely would buy a foreign car over domestic. Here's what I have suggested she go look at and test drive - please let me know what models I'm missing or if anyone has any input to add to things I have listed below:

- Kia Sorento
- Subaru Forrester- she just looked at 2019 model earlier this week. She liked it but thought the engine was a bit loud during acceleration.
- Hyundai Santa Fe
- Mazda CX-5 (I think the CX-9 would be way too big, but not sure if the CX-5 is too small - don't think Mazda makes an in-between?) I love the interior and exterior styling of these.
- Rav 4 ?? Will this offer a quiet and comfortable ride? I had an Uber in a new Rav4 this week and think the size is perfect. Just not sure how ride quality would be on this as a daily driver.

Appreciate the input.

Toys4RJill

corradoMR2

For long-term ownership (i.e. 10-15 years), only one way to go. Toyota/Lexus with their bullet-proof proven powertrains and electronics.

- 1st pick: 2019 Rav4 is here this month and what I'd buy overall as I like the styling, interior efficiency, and relatively short packaging (180" long). Ride should be nice as per the reviews of cars like the Camry and Avalon on the new new TNGA-K platform though it's still with a 4cyl which will be heard a bit under heavier acceleration.
- 2nd pick: a low-mileage 2015 RX 350 (not the F Sport), sized at 187" (5" shorter than the current RX) or about 3" longer than the '02 Highlander. You'll enjoy the V6 power and a smooth quiet ride.

In your situation, I'd avoid any and all Turbo 4 cyl-equipped CUVs which sadly eliminates many. They will highly likely give you costly trouble between 50k-100k miles or soon after warranty will end. That includes Subaru, Honda (i.e. new CR-V), Kia, Mazda, etc. I wouldn't even recommend the NX 200t/300. It's not a matter of "if" but "when".

Htony

I'd pick Subaru Outback with H6 engine.

jrmckinley

Interesting about the 2019 Rav4 - wasn't aware of the updated styling, etc. but I just took a look and I like it. Also, the 2015 RX might be an excellent recommendation since she could search for a CPO. She doesn't care for the new RX design but the '15 is a look that she probably would like and it gives her the upgraded ride and feel of a Lexus. Thanks for info on the turbo 4cyl.

jrmckinley

I haven't told her to look at that one because I think she needs something where the height of the vehicle is a bit higher than the Outback. Makes it easier for her to get in & out and is something she is very picky about when shopping around.

Hoovey689

iTrader: (16)

Last generation RDX with the 3.5L V6

ArmyofOne

Honestly, there is alot on the market in this segment today, but for the money, nothing beats a CX-5.

mmarshall

I'm going to review the new RAV-4 myself very shortly, as soon as it is available here in the D.C. area....in the meantime, there are a number of good reviews available on-line and on YouTube...I especially recommend Alex Dykes and his reviews. The Forester is mostly a good suggestion (superb AWD system and good outward visibility), but may be iffy with the engine reliability. Sorento's a good solid choice..well-screwed together, and the versions with the higher-profile tires are smooth and quiet. I agree with Josh on the CX-5 from a driver-enthusiast standpoint, but I don't think it is quite what your mom would be looking for, and its lack of an engine-temperature gauge (only red/blue warning-lights) to me is annoying. Lexus RX and Buick Enclave would probably have the quietest rides, but both may be too large for her tastes, and the Enclave has not been reliable.

jrmckinley

Thanks for the input so far. I watched Alex's review on the CX-5 and the brand new Santa Fe - both of which are very impressive. In addition to those two, I'm going to recommend she look at the Rav4, RDX (one I hadn't thought of), and a 2015 RX. Keep the feedback coming.

bitkahuna

iTrader: (20)

So many choices, endless videos on them. She'll know as soon as she drives the right one.

About turbos, I think we're well beyond the worries about long term reliability these days. Check out Ford's videos on extreme testing they do for example.

Johnhav430

Judging purely by looks, I saw a new Santa Fe on the road and it looked nice. Again, having never owned a Hyundai, but rented many of them, I would consider them.

mmarshall

For the most part, yes. Turbos or not, these are not sports cars. The conservative way that most owners are likely to drive them, combined with advances in turbo durability, and, of course, today's full-synthetic oils, has eliminated many (but not all) of the reliability concerns. Even my non-turbo Lacrosse now uses 5W-30 full-synthetic.

bitkahuna

iTrader: (20)

so what modern turbos do you consider unreliable?

mmarshall

In general, those that are abused, not maintained properly, or don't have the proper type oil in them (for example, people trying to save a buck). But more specifically, at least from some sources I've read, some of the Ford/Lincoln turbos have had premature issues even if properly cared for.