Meineke just tried to sell me exhaust manifold w/ cat for $1350 !!! good deal ??
08-31-12, 08:07 PM
#1
Rookie
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: id
Posts: 78
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Meineke just tried to sell me exhaust manifold w/ cat for $1350 !!! good deal ??
'99 gs300 205k. ok so my check engine light ( CEL ) came on so i stopped at the nearest autozone and had them pull the engine code , it was "catalytic efficiency" , so i made an appointment at my local Meineke for a free evaluation. they used a heat/temp laser sensor to check the temps on my Catalytic converter , and they told me that i need a new one , then the guy tells me that the exhaust manifold and cat converter is all 1 unit and it will cost $1350 + 4hours of labor. and also that i should replace all 4 of my O2 sensors at about $500 for all 4 +labor , i came home and looked at rock auto and found that they have Bosal direct fit exhaust manifold/cat converter for $510 ,, and i can't find any other exhaust manifold on the net even close to $1350 , i found a magna flow for $690 , but that was the highest i could find. please give me any help on finding the right part at the right price. also would like you're input on if you think Meineke is try'n to rip me off. thanks
08-31-12, 08:32 PM
#5
Rookie
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: id
Posts: 78
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
i forgot to get the code## from the guy at auto zone , but the readout said " Catalytic Efficicy " so i figured that was code p0420 . yeah i have 2j engine. also the guy at Meineke didn't tell me about welding/swapping anything out ,, he just said " you need new catalytic converters , and those are attached to you're exhaust manifold so its all 1 unit and that unit is $1350." ,, do you think i should get a 2nd opinion at a different shop ?
08-31-12, 08:51 PM
#7
Rookie
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: id
Posts: 78
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
what other info do you need ? " Catalytic effenicey" ,, and i'm asking about the price on the parts the guy quoted me compared to other parts online that are 1/3 the price. , i need help , not smug remarks. thanks
Trending Topics
08-31-12, 09:01 PM
#10
This is what i would do..
Go to autozone or equivalent.. Get the Actual Engine Code. Do a quick search on the Forums.. See what pops up..
Take a few minutes to be your own Doctor..use the info to diagnose your car with peoples experience with the same code..I.E. Funny smells, Noises, the way car acts..etc...
Once you get a close enough educated guess what the problem might be then your either take it to a mechanic or DIY without getting ripped off.
the cats on the exh mani can be replaced a sa whole unit cheaper than what they quoted you. Im not sure if there is a third cat down stream, but if you do, you need to know which one is bad.
08-31-12, 09:18 PM
#11
Rookie
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: id
Posts: 78
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
No problem, i tend to be Blunt sometimes its my nature. Im my old age im Grumpy as hell.
This is what i would do..
Go to autozone or equivalent.. Get the Actual Engine Code. Do a quick search on the Forums.. See what pops up..
Take a few minutes to be your own Doctor..use the info to diagnose your car with peoples experience with the same code..I.E. Funny smells, Noises, the way car acts..etc...
Once you get a close enough educated guess what the problem might be then your either take it to a mechanic or DIY without getting ripped off.
the cats on the exh mani can be replaced a sa whole unit cheaper than what they quoted you. Im not sure if there is a third cat down stream, but if you do, you need to know which one is bad.
This is what i would do..
Go to autozone or equivalent.. Get the Actual Engine Code. Do a quick search on the Forums.. See what pops up..
Take a few minutes to be your own Doctor..use the info to diagnose your car with peoples experience with the same code..I.E. Funny smells, Noises, the way car acts..etc...
Once you get a close enough educated guess what the problem might be then your either take it to a mechanic or DIY without getting ripped off.
the cats on the exh mani can be replaced a sa whole unit cheaper than what they quoted you. Im not sure if there is a third cat down stream, but if you do, you need to know which one is bad.
08-31-12, 09:27 PM
#12
i doubt all four 02s took a dump all at once.... maybe be one, thats why is good to get the code or codes. a good shop will check each O2 and tell you which one if any is shot. all you need is a volt meter. Better yet a good shop will plug you right up to an Good O Snap On diagnostic comp and tell you. I just use my handy $20 voltmeter.
Now if your doing a complete exhaust overhaul then yes, new Exhaust mani, Y pipe, and new four 02s can begin to justify that cost.. But is that what you went in there for/ or is it what you need is the question. Everyone is looking to make a buck..
Now if your doing a complete exhaust overhaul then yes, new Exhaust mani, Y pipe, and new four 02s can begin to justify that cost.. But is that what you went in there for/ or is it what you need is the question. Everyone is looking to make a buck..
08-31-12, 09:46 PM
#13
Rookie
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: id
Posts: 78
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
i doubt all four 02s took a dump all at once.... maybe be one, thats why is good to get the code or codes. a good shop will check each O2 and tell you which one if any is shot. all you need is a volt meter. Better yet a good shop will plug you right up to an Good O Snap On diagnostic comp and tell you. I just use my handy $20 voltmeter.
Now if your doing a complete exhaust overhaul then yes, new Exhaust mani, Y pipe, and new four 02s can begin to justify that cost.. But is that what you went in there for/ or is it what you need is the question. Everyone is looking to make a buck..
Now if your doing a complete exhaust overhaul then yes, new Exhaust mani, Y pipe, and new four 02s can begin to justify that cost.. But is that what you went in there for/ or is it what you need is the question. Everyone is looking to make a buck..
08-31-12, 09:51 PM
#14
yes, shop around.. You may be able to get all the parts and have some one do it for you, even a CL member around your area willing to help you out and make a few bucks, beware, some shops will not do any work for you unless you buy the parts from them (Liability/warranty clause), so ask if they are willing to do just the Labor Vs. Labor and parts.
08-31-12, 10:03 PM
#15
Rookie
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: id
Posts: 78
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
yes, shop around.. You may be able to get all the parts and have some one do it for you, even a CL member around your area willing to help you out and make a few bucks, beware, some shops will not do any work for you unless you buy the parts from them (Liability/warranty clause), so ask if they are willing to do just the Labor Vs. Labor and parts.
yeah, thanks a lot for you're help. and yep .. you're right about that liability/warranty clause ,, meineke told me they cant warranty the exhaust mani +cat unless i buy and replace the o2 sensors at same time .