Does this Lexus Dealership theory sound logical???
#1
Pit Crew
Thread Starter
Does this Lexus Dealership theory sound logical???
I took my 92 SC400 to the Lexus dealership for a diagnostic since "literally" overnight my car took a toll for the worse. Symptoms were misfires, complete loss of power, turned off at stop lights, hesitations, ackward exhaust sound, and that hot metal cooling off sound that usually is heard when you turn off your car (its that ping ping ding ding sound... i know... that was a stupid description ). Once again... this was literally overnight. Because the day prior I had gone out to dinner, came home and parked, went to sleep, woke up, I was going to take my son out to breakfast, turned on the car, attempted to drive... and bam... the symptoms mentioned came up.
So anyways, after some thought process , I figured it to be an exhaust situation like clogged up cats or something. But since it happend overnight I couldnt imagine that to just pop up and be a problem.
Well according to my local Lexus dealership, they are saying it is related to water in the spark plug areas possibly due to washing the engine. Well yes... I have washed the engine twice in the last month, but the last time I washed the engine was at least 2 weeks ago. Since then I have driven the car up and down with no related problems showing. All of a sudden, overnight this happens.
Would have the water not dried up in there by this time already if that was to be the problem as they state? Is it possible for negative engine washing results to take place this far out even after a good 100 miles have been driven since?
I dont know... it just doesnt make sense to me. Worse yet, Lexus states that the resolution will be to change out the spark plugs and wires to solve this problem. They are quoting me $580 for such . $10 per plug, $140 wires, and $300 labor.
Do you guys feel this diagnostic is legit? Thanks.
So anyways, after some thought process , I figured it to be an exhaust situation like clogged up cats or something. But since it happend overnight I couldnt imagine that to just pop up and be a problem.
Well according to my local Lexus dealership, they are saying it is related to water in the spark plug areas possibly due to washing the engine. Well yes... I have washed the engine twice in the last month, but the last time I washed the engine was at least 2 weeks ago. Since then I have driven the car up and down with no related problems showing. All of a sudden, overnight this happens.
Would have the water not dried up in there by this time already if that was to be the problem as they state? Is it possible for negative engine washing results to take place this far out even after a good 100 miles have been driven since?
I dont know... it just doesnt make sense to me. Worse yet, Lexus states that the resolution will be to change out the spark plugs and wires to solve this problem. They are quoting me $580 for such . $10 per plug, $140 wires, and $300 labor.
Do you guys feel this diagnostic is legit? Thanks.
#3
Pit Crew
Thread Starter
Out of curiosity... where are the two coils? I did some search on the forum and found that one is right up front by the inlet hose above the pulleys . But I havent been able to find out where the other one is located, and/or if it looks the same so that I can identify it visually.
Oh and Lexus sells the coils at $111 each. Anyone NOT recommend going non OEM? Thanks.
Oh and Lexus sells the coils at $111 each. Anyone NOT recommend going non OEM? Thanks.
#4
Zombie Slayer
Out of curiosity... where are the two coils? I did some search on the forum and found that one is right up front by the inlet hose above the pulleys . But I havent been able to find out where the other one is located, and/or if it looks the same so that I can identify it visually.
Oh and Lexus sells the coils at $111 each. Anyone NOT recommend going non OEM? Thanks.
Oh and Lexus sells the coils at $111 each. Anyone NOT recommend going non OEM? Thanks.
Trending Topics
#9
Pit Crew
Thread Starter
Looking at the engine in front of you: Right hand side, below the front of the valve cover. Gray in color. To see if a coil is bad. Unplug one and start car. Plug back in. Unplug other and start. If the car does not start on one or the other, then it's a bad coil. If one coil goes, one "bank" of cylinders will not fire. Causes, misfiring, bad noises, etc. Basically everything you described. If both go, then the car no starty. Sooooo, if the car doesn't start with only one plugged in, that one is bad.
MKORSU... Your idea sounds interesting. Not too sure I follow though.
I unplug one of the ignition coils and then start the car or attempt to start the car? Plug it back in... is this assuming the car does not start, or if it does start? Not too sure on the conclusion if the car "does not start on one or the other, then its a bad coil". Forgive my stupidy , but how do I identify the "bad ignition coil"?
Should the car be able to start with only one ignition coil plugged in? Or should the car only turn the engine but not start completely? Doesnt one ignition coil juice up 4 of the spark plugs? Is it possible to turn the engine and start it with only 4 valves running?
Once again, sorry for the idiotic question since I just dont get it.... But I wanna give it a shot.
Thanks again MKORSU
Oh... and as far as the ping ping noise of the cats/exhaust cooling off... I dont think I had ever heard it on my car before. Ive heard it on many others, and I know that to be normal on them, but since my Lex never did that, I figured it to be an issue. Not to mention burning smoke and smell coming from underneath (cats and/or exhaust). Sorry to put a scare on a few of you guys.
#10
Lexus Test Driver
MKORSU... Your idea sounds interesting. Not too sure I follow though.
I unplug one of the ignition coils and then start the car or attempt to start the car? Plug it back in... is this assuming the car does not start, or if it does start? Not too sure on the conclusion if the car "does not start on one or the other, then its a bad coil". Forgive my stupidy , but how do I identify the "bad ignition coil"?
Should the car be able to start with only one ignition coil plugged in? Or should the car only turn the engine but not start completely? Doesnt one ignition coil juice up 4 of the spark plugs? Is it possible to turn the engine and start it with only 4 valves running?
Once again, sorry for the idiotic question since I just dont get it.... But I wanna give it a shot.
Thanks again MKORSU
Oh... and as far as the ping ping noise of the cats/exhaust cooling off... I dont think I had ever heard it on my car before. Ive heard it on many others, and I know that to be normal on them, but since my Lex never did that, I figured it to be an issue. Not to mention burning smoke and smell coming from underneath (cats and/or exhaust). Sorry to put a scare on a few of you guys.
I unplug one of the ignition coils and then start the car or attempt to start the car? Plug it back in... is this assuming the car does not start, or if it does start? Not too sure on the conclusion if the car "does not start on one or the other, then its a bad coil". Forgive my stupidy , but how do I identify the "bad ignition coil"?
Should the car be able to start with only one ignition coil plugged in? Or should the car only turn the engine but not start completely? Doesnt one ignition coil juice up 4 of the spark plugs? Is it possible to turn the engine and start it with only 4 valves running?
Once again, sorry for the idiotic question since I just dont get it.... But I wanna give it a shot.
Thanks again MKORSU
Oh... and as far as the ping ping noise of the cats/exhaust cooling off... I dont think I had ever heard it on my car before. Ive heard it on many others, and I know that to be normal on them, but since my Lex never did that, I figured it to be an issue. Not to mention burning smoke and smell coming from underneath (cats and/or exhaust). Sorry to put a scare on a few of you guys.
The car will start when you unplug one of the coils. It means that only the 4 cylinders on the side you left plugged in will fire.
#11
Maintenance Moderator
iTrader: (2)
water may indeed be the cause here... Their prices don't seem too out of line except labor - good god $300?
My book calls for 1hour labor for plugs and 1 hour labor for wires - if you do both, I knock .5 off, so, 1.5 hours and we charge $79 / hour... $118.50 plus plugs and wires at a reasonable shop...
I would, as suggested above, check the coils as well... it's quite easy to do yourself - get the car running, and pull the coil wire off each coil (please wear rubber gloves), one at a time, and listen / look for a spark to jump the gap... also, clearly the engines performance should change when you do this - if it doesn't change, you most likely have a bad coil... if it dies immediately, the opposite coil is most likely bad.... if it idles still, but worse than before, then most likely both are good, and wires/cap/rotor/plugs are the culprit...
My book calls for 1hour labor for plugs and 1 hour labor for wires - if you do both, I knock .5 off, so, 1.5 hours and we charge $79 / hour... $118.50 plus plugs and wires at a reasonable shop...
I would, as suggested above, check the coils as well... it's quite easy to do yourself - get the car running, and pull the coil wire off each coil (please wear rubber gloves), one at a time, and listen / look for a spark to jump the gap... also, clearly the engines performance should change when you do this - if it doesn't change, you most likely have a bad coil... if it dies immediately, the opposite coil is most likely bad.... if it idles still, but worse than before, then most likely both are good, and wires/cap/rotor/plugs are the culprit...
#12
Pit Crew
Thread Starter
Thanks for the clearing up NYLEXSC!!!
Just one final question... wouldnt an ignition coil problem of this kind or even water in the spark plugs trigger the check engine light?
Thanks!!!
Just one final question... wouldnt an ignition coil problem of this kind or even water in the spark plugs trigger the check engine light?
Thanks!!!
#13
Pit Crew
Thread Starter
I just went outside to my car, did the ignition coil tests you guys told me about, and here are the results:
Ignition Coil #1: I disconnected ignition coil #1 (leaving only ignition coil #2 connected), turned the key, and just got a turn, turn, turn sound then a quick vrooom, but the engine did not stay on (continue running) despite keeping my foot a bit on the gas pedal during the process. It always sounded like it almost wanted to, but hesistated itself off.
Ignition Coil #2: After connecting ignition coil #1 back in place and disconnecting ignition coil #2, all I got was the engine turning, but no vrooom sound.
Does that mean that both coils are bad? Wouldnt it be abnormal for both to go bad at the same time as opposed to just one or the other? If so, then with that thought in mind, could I weed out the possibility of the ignition coils being the problem? As a reminding side note, this literally happend overnight.
Also, I forgot to mention that with the symptoms of the situation, I also get a faint paint-like smell coming from the bottom of the car and/or exhaust.
Sorry for the stupid sound effects (vroom-vroom), but not sure how to describe.
Thanks in advance and thanks again to all for your continued assistance with all this...!!!
Ignition Coil #1: I disconnected ignition coil #1 (leaving only ignition coil #2 connected), turned the key, and just got a turn, turn, turn sound then a quick vrooom, but the engine did not stay on (continue running) despite keeping my foot a bit on the gas pedal during the process. It always sounded like it almost wanted to, but hesistated itself off.
Ignition Coil #2: After connecting ignition coil #1 back in place and disconnecting ignition coil #2, all I got was the engine turning, but no vrooom sound.
Does that mean that both coils are bad? Wouldnt it be abnormal for both to go bad at the same time as opposed to just one or the other? If so, then with that thought in mind, could I weed out the possibility of the ignition coils being the problem? As a reminding side note, this literally happend overnight.
Also, I forgot to mention that with the symptoms of the situation, I also get a faint paint-like smell coming from the bottom of the car and/or exhaust.
Sorry for the stupid sound effects (vroom-vroom), but not sure how to describe.
Thanks in advance and thanks again to all for your continued assistance with all this...!!!
#14
Zombie Slayer
#15
Zombie Slayer
I just went outside to my car, did the ignition coil tests you guys told me about, and here are the results:
Ignition Coil #1: I disconnected ignition coil #1 (leaving only ignition coil #2 connected), turned the key, and just got a turn, turn, turn sound then a quick vrooom, but the engine did not stay on (continue running) despite keeping my foot a bit on the gas pedal during the process. It always sounded like it almost wanted to, but hesistated itself off.
Ignition Coil #2: After connecting ignition coil #1 back in place and disconnecting ignition coil #2, all I got was the engine turning, but no vrooom sound.
Does that mean that both coils are bad? Wouldnt it be abnormal for both to go bad at the same time as opposed to just one or the other? If so, then with that thought in mind, could I weed out the possibility of the ignition coils being the problem? As a reminding side note, this literally happend overnight.
Also, I forgot to mention that with the symptoms of the situation, I also get a faint paint-like smell coming from the bottom of the car and/or exhaust.
Sorry for the stupid sound effects (vroom-vroom), but not sure how to describe.
Thanks in advance and thanks again to all for your continued assistance with all this...!!!
Ignition Coil #1: I disconnected ignition coil #1 (leaving only ignition coil #2 connected), turned the key, and just got a turn, turn, turn sound then a quick vrooom, but the engine did not stay on (continue running) despite keeping my foot a bit on the gas pedal during the process. It always sounded like it almost wanted to, but hesistated itself off.
Ignition Coil #2: After connecting ignition coil #1 back in place and disconnecting ignition coil #2, all I got was the engine turning, but no vrooom sound.
Does that mean that both coils are bad? Wouldnt it be abnormal for both to go bad at the same time as opposed to just one or the other? If so, then with that thought in mind, could I weed out the possibility of the ignition coils being the problem? As a reminding side note, this literally happend overnight.
Also, I forgot to mention that with the symptoms of the situation, I also get a faint paint-like smell coming from the bottom of the car and/or exhaust.
Sorry for the stupid sound effects (vroom-vroom), but not sure how to describe.
Thanks in advance and thanks again to all for your continued assistance with all this...!!!
Ultimately, I would say do the work the dealer mentioned, but do it yourself. Platinum plugs can be purchased for roughly $5-$6 ea. (they are more than adequate on a stock motor), new OEM wires for roughly $90, 2 distributer caps and 2 rotors for $30-$40. All said and done, that's about $180 out the door!