Need new rotors, but from which company?
#1
Instructor
Thread Starter
Need new rotors, but from which company?
Okay, so the front rotors on my '97 are warped pretty bad and need to be replaced. The shop I always go to said the "cheap" rotors ($200/pair, including installation) should be avoided, especially with my 20"s. He believed the $315 option, from Wagner, would be my best bet through him (as he doesn't supply anything else). I still have EBC Red Stuff pads on the front, for whatever that's worth.
SO
I figured I'd just get some Brembo blanks since I can get them from Tire Rack, and have them installed, for about $40 less than the Wagner ones. Problem is, I read the reviews of the Brembo blanks on Tire Rack - it seems people are largely dissatisfied with them, saying they don't grip as well as factory, warp easily, and have a fairly short life expectancy.
Most of what I've read on here says to stay away from D/S rotors, for one reason or another, so I've been eliminating those from my searching. I've seen people suggest rotors from R1 Concepts on here, but didn't really see anything as far as how satisfied people were with them. They're in the same price range as the Brembo blanks.
I haven't seen anything from the likes of StopTech or Endless for our cars, but found plenty of EBC and Baer Decela D/S rotors...which, like I said, I'm trying to stay away from unless someone can convince me otherwise.
Your input is appreciated
SO
I figured I'd just get some Brembo blanks since I can get them from Tire Rack, and have them installed, for about $40 less than the Wagner ones. Problem is, I read the reviews of the Brembo blanks on Tire Rack - it seems people are largely dissatisfied with them, saying they don't grip as well as factory, warp easily, and have a fairly short life expectancy.
Most of what I've read on here says to stay away from D/S rotors, for one reason or another, so I've been eliminating those from my searching. I've seen people suggest rotors from R1 Concepts on here, but didn't really see anything as far as how satisfied people were with them. They're in the same price range as the Brembo blanks.
I haven't seen anything from the likes of StopTech or Endless for our cars, but found plenty of EBC and Baer Decela D/S rotors...which, like I said, I'm trying to stay away from unless someone can convince me otherwise.
Your input is appreciated
#2
Retired
iTrader: (32)
www.r1concepts.com i have them on my 95+ brake setup and i dont regret them, affordable price also ($12X for a pair iirc)
slotted with EBC red pads also, and they stop REALLLY good..
slotted with EBC red pads also, and they stop REALLLY good..
#3
Lexus Test Driver
iTrader: (1)
Why can't you change the rotors yourself? If you get OEM rotors from Lexus of Pembroke Pines, you'll get them both for about $215 delivered and can put them on yourself in two hours time, taking your very sweet time. All you have to do to take the rotors off is to pop off the two 17mm caliper bolts, slide the calipers and pads out as one assembly, undo any phillips head screws on the rotor hat, and take the rotor off. Very easy job to do, and you'll save money AND get top notch stone-ground OEM rotors in the process.
#4
Instructor
Thread Starter
#5
#7
Driver
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Maryland/Florida
Posts: 155
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Agreed. I've used them plenty of times on numerous of my cars and they've lasted pretty long, but that also depends on how you drive. I'd worry more about what brake pads to get. Other good rotor brands are PBR, Centric, and Zimmerman, if they can be found. As far as I know, EBC is better known for brake pads than rotors.
Trending Topics
#8
Pole Position
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Johannesburg, South Africa
Posts: 225
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
I got myself a pair of EBC 3GD Sport Rotors, and must say extremely satisfied...
Didn't get the EBC brake pads yet, but at the moment running normal OEM brake pads from Lexus dealer...
I just noticed that there is a nice improvement from OEM rotors, doe I drive quite normally (I'm not exactly a "sport" driver) but here where I am, it was more affordable for me to import the rotors from you guys (USA) then to buy them at the local Lexus dealer
Didn't get the EBC brake pads yet, but at the moment running normal OEM brake pads from Lexus dealer...
I just noticed that there is a nice improvement from OEM rotors, doe I drive quite normally (I'm not exactly a "sport" driver) but here where I am, it was more affordable for me to import the rotors from you guys (USA) then to buy them at the local Lexus dealer
#9
i've always been partial to brembo, but recently tried r1 e-line slotted. the reason i decided to give them a shot is they are 1) cut off centric blanks and 2) affordable. from now on if my choice is between brembo blanks and r1 i'll probably go r1. the zinc coating is a real selling point for me (even if you get blanks) and the quality seems to be at least as good. i will continue to stay away from drilled blanks because i don't trust them, however i will be running brembo sport ($$$) cross drilled on my q45.
#10
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: NE
Posts: 18
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If you have the time....... replacing the rotors is a quite rewarding task. Here is a couple links from a 90 LS400 tutorial which may be similar to your 97'.
front pads:
http://www.lexls.com/tutorials/brake/fbpad.html
front rotors:
http://www.lexls.com/tutorials/brake/fbrotor.html
SSbrakelines:
http://www.lexls.com/tutorials/brake/SSbrakelines.html
Which ever rotor you choose, just make sure you use a high quality pad like HAWK HPS, bleed the brake fluid completely, and follow the pad manufactures break in procedures. I believe the tire rack has these on line you can print out. The break in is very very important to proper wear and performance! Good luck!
front pads:
http://www.lexls.com/tutorials/brake/fbpad.html
front rotors:
http://www.lexls.com/tutorials/brake/fbrotor.html
SSbrakelines:
http://www.lexls.com/tutorials/brake/SSbrakelines.html
Which ever rotor you choose, just make sure you use a high quality pad like HAWK HPS, bleed the brake fluid completely, and follow the pad manufactures break in procedures. I believe the tire rack has these on line you can print out. The break in is very very important to proper wear and performance! Good luck!
#11
Instructor
Thread Starter
Thanks for all the responses guys.
It seems it's between Brembo and R1 Concepts blanks. I may end up saving the money to have a shop install them and have one of my friends going to school for automotive tackle the project, probably at the same time we try messing with lowering my car a bit more. Considering doing some exhaust work too, but that'll be a bit further down the road probably.
It seems it's between Brembo and R1 Concepts blanks. I may end up saving the money to have a shop install them and have one of my friends going to school for automotive tackle the project, probably at the same time we try messing with lowering my car a bit more. Considering doing some exhaust work too, but that'll be a bit further down the road probably.
#13
#15
Instructor
Thread Starter
Well, after reading more reviews on the Brembo units, it looks like I'll probably be giving R1 Concepts a shot.
Now, I just have to figure out which ones - the Eline blanks for $81.20/pair or the Premium blanks for $169.20/pair.
They offer slotted rotors for $121/pair, but since all I've ever read about slotted is that they eat through pads/have short life expectancy/their benefits are a myth, I'm leaving them out of the equation (though they would contribute aesthetically).
Now, I just have to figure out which ones - the Eline blanks for $81.20/pair or the Premium blanks for $169.20/pair.
They offer slotted rotors for $121/pair, but since all I've ever read about slotted is that they eat through pads/have short life expectancy/their benefits are a myth, I'm leaving them out of the equation (though they would contribute aesthetically).