ClubLexus - Lexus Forum Discussion

ClubLexus - Lexus Forum Discussion (https://www.clublexus.com/forums/)
-   IS - 3rd Gen (2014-present) (https://www.clublexus.com/forums/is-3rd-gen-2014-present-249/)
-   -   IS300 vs IS350 (https://www.clublexus.com/forums/is-3rd-gen-2014-present/828952-is300-vs-is350.html)

cooperyau 07-18-16 07:12 AM

IS300 vs IS350
 
Looking into a 2016 IS300 & IS350. Is there a huge difference on engine performance and driveability between these V6s? 255 vs 305hp? The color combo that I want is hard to locate on the 350 so I am thinking to just go with the IS300. Thanks

Vivid101 07-18-16 07:42 AM

50 hp is definitely noticeable. I recommend you drive both before making a decision.

Olasek 07-18-16 11:37 AM


Originally Posted by cooperyau (Post 9556189)
Is there a huge difference on engine performance and driveability between these V6s?

It is a highly personal judgement. You need to try both of them.

evident 07-18-16 12:14 PM


Originally Posted by cooperyau (Post 9556189)
Is there a huge difference on engine performance and driveability between these V6s? 255 vs 305hp?

It's noticable. you need to test drive both.

ToDesi 07-18-16 12:48 PM

Very noticeable, if it wasn't for the 10k price difference in Canada I would be all over the 350. The 300 feels sluggish compared to the 350.

jmull3r 07-18-16 01:14 PM

What is the color combo you want? You can always special order the car

Sango 07-18-16 01:21 PM

Go with the 350.

Looking at the spec of the 300, it looks like it's basically a 350 detuned since it has the same engine. Interestingly, the MPG is the same for both AWD 300 and 350.

---


Originally Posted by ToDesi (Post 9556580)
Very noticeable, if it wasn't for the 10k price difference in Canada I would be all over the 350. The 300 feels sluggish compared to the 350.

Wait for 2017 and see if they bring back the 350 RWD for Lexus Canada. It was very disappointing that they dropped RWD model out.

EJ255t 07-18-16 02:04 PM

50hp difference! its a night and day difference!!!

if you dont care for power the IS300, but if you want the power, then 350!!

but test drive both to see which one you like, you have to test drive to see it for yourself. i know someone who just bought a is300 and they hate it!!!!

Olasek 07-18-16 04:17 PM


Originally Posted by EJ255t (Post 9556699)
i know someone who just bought a is300 and they hate it!!!!

But I also know a person that owns IS250 and is very happy. It works both ways. Many simply don't care for extra power, for them it is just another car, another utility vehicle, another A to B transportation, these people do not frequent this forum and simply are far detached from this 'enthusiast' factor.

EJ255t 07-18-16 06:11 PM


Originally Posted by Olasek (Post 9556860)
But I also know a person that owns IS250 and is very happy. It works both ways. Many simply don't care for extra power, for them it is just another car, another utility vehicle, another A to B transportation, these people do not frequent this forum and simply are far detached from this 'enthusiast' factor.


that is very true, the opinion does go both ways.

for those who loves cars will usually go for the more powerful car (ME LOL)

AWilson013 07-18-16 06:35 PM

We just picked up an IS300 F Sport for my wife and she absolutely loves it. Before settling on this car we drove a CT200h FSport(this is what we were planning on buying), a 2013 IS 350 (had some fancy package with funny looking tan and black leather seats), a 2016 IS350 F Sport, and lastly the 2016 IS300 F Sport. MY favorite of all the cars was the IS350 F Sport, but my wife said it felt like "too much car".

The IS300 is clearly not as powerful, but it's not slow. If you stomp the accelerator it'll get up and go pretty good. The 0-60 time is 1/2 second slower which, to me, doesn't matter.

One thing we've noticed (and we hope goes away after a few thousand miles) is that the fuel economy sucks. In eco mode, driving like a grandma, my wife is averaging high 17s to low 18s for mpg. With the cruise control at 60mph on the freeway (also in eco mode) it's getting high 23s to mid 24s for mpg.

There's only one IS300 on fuelly so far, but they're seeing similar results with an average of 17.3mpg over 10 fuel ups. IS350s (2014-2016) are seeing an average of 20-22mpg over a combined 986 fuel ups.


Originally Posted by EJ255t (Post 9556699)
i know someone who just bought a is300 and they hate it!!!!

Who would buy a car that they hate? That makes no sense. If they're dense enough to buy a new car they don't love, I wouldn't trust their opinion on much of anything.

Olasek 07-18-16 08:39 PM


Originally Posted by AWilson013 (Post 9557028)
Who would buy a car that they hate? That makes no sense.

And you are right - makes absolutely no sense to me either. Sounds to me a lot more like someone who is adjusting his story to fit the expectation of his audience. :sad:

AWilson013 07-18-16 11:55 PM


Originally Posted by Olasek (Post 9557148)
And you are right - makes absolutely no sense to me either. Sounds to me a lot more like someone who is adjusting his story to fit the expectation of his audience. :sad:

On the internet? Such a thing would NEVER happen! :rolleyes:

The IS300 and IS350 are both excellent vehicles, but if your only reason to go with the IS300 is the color, that's the wrong choice. To me, compromising on color is acceptable on a used car, but not a new car. When spending 40-55k you should get what you want, and absolutely nothing less.

Which color combo are you looking at, OP? I could only find one black F Sport in the country, and it was out in Tennessee or something.

EJ255t 07-19-16 11:54 AM


Originally Posted by AWilson013 (Post 9557028)
We just picked up an IS300 F Sport for my wife and she absolutely loves it. Before settling on this car we drove a CT200h FSport(this is what we were planning on buying), a 2013 IS 350 (had some fancy package with funny looking tan and black leather seats), a 2016 IS350 F Sport, and lastly the 2016 IS300 F Sport. MY favorite of all the cars was the IS350 F Sport, but my wife said it felt like "too much car".

The IS300 is clearly not as powerful, but it's not slow. If you stomp the accelerator it'll get up and go pretty good. The 0-60 time is 1/2 second slower which, to me, doesn't matter.

One thing we've noticed (and we hope goes away after a few thousand miles) is that the fuel economy sucks. In eco mode, driving like a grandma, my wife is averaging high 17s to low 18s for mpg. With the cruise control at 60mph on the freeway (also in eco mode) it's getting high 23s to mid 24s for mpg.

There's only one IS300 on fuelly so far, but they're seeing similar results with an average of 17.3mpg over 10 fuel ups. IS350s (2014-2016) are seeing an average of 20-22mpg over a combined 986 fuel ups.



Who would buy a car that they hate? That makes no sense. If they're dense enough to buy a new car they don't love, I wouldn't trust their opinion on much of anything.



well he test drove it and thought it was good, but i guess after a few months of owning it different story!! he doesnt like it like the day he got it!! he wants more out of the car!!!!

cooperyau 07-27-16 07:17 AM

Since both engines are V6 and 3.5 liter, wonder what the differences are? Cams? Ecu Tuning? Intake? etc


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 05:10 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands