07' - 09' Lexus IS/ES vs G35 vs TSX. Need help before buying a used car :D
#1
Driver School Candidate
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: ca
Posts: 4
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
07' - 09' Lexus IS/ES vs G35 vs TSX. Need help before buying a used car :D
I live in California and I'm gonna need to buy a car this summer.
These are the cars that I have my eyes on. (ranked from I like most to least)
1. '07, '08 Lexus IS250
2. '07, '08 Infiniti G35 Sedan
3. '07, '08 Lexus ES 350
4. '09 Acura TSX
5. '10, '11 Accord
6. Civic Si
My needs:
-Price Range : 13k-16k (maybe 17k if the car is nice)
-Maximum Mileage : 50-70k ? I don't know how reliable these cars are. But I heard the lexus are the most reliable ones. My friend bought a 130k miles is 250 and he said he hasn't had a problem since. So I think 80-90k for Lexus and Infiniti is alright too ?
-Features: Nav, Bluetooth, Keyless Entry (I really like this), Back Up Camera.
-Insurance: I live in Orange County, Cali. 20 yrs old, will be 21 soon and has had my License for 2 yrs. So I hope my insurance will be at most $150/month. That's the reason why I prefer the G35 Sedan so the Insurance would be cheaper. If there's any OC fellows please tell me your insurance cost for 6 months.
-Save Gas
I'm not really into modding cars and the horse power stuff aren't my thing because i live in Orange County, Cali so I cannot go really fast since there's always a traffic light every quarter of a mile. And I'm also having a 2000 Camry that's why anything above is good for me..
Please give me your thoughts about my consideration. Thank you fellows.
These are the cars that I have my eyes on. (ranked from I like most to least)
1. '07, '08 Lexus IS250
2. '07, '08 Infiniti G35 Sedan
3. '07, '08 Lexus ES 350
4. '09 Acura TSX
5. '10, '11 Accord
6. Civic Si
My needs:
-Price Range : 13k-16k (maybe 17k if the car is nice)
-Maximum Mileage : 50-70k ? I don't know how reliable these cars are. But I heard the lexus are the most reliable ones. My friend bought a 130k miles is 250 and he said he hasn't had a problem since. So I think 80-90k for Lexus and Infiniti is alright too ?
-Features: Nav, Bluetooth, Keyless Entry (I really like this), Back Up Camera.
-Insurance: I live in Orange County, Cali. 20 yrs old, will be 21 soon and has had my License for 2 yrs. So I hope my insurance will be at most $150/month. That's the reason why I prefer the G35 Sedan so the Insurance would be cheaper. If there's any OC fellows please tell me your insurance cost for 6 months.
-Save Gas
I'm not really into modding cars and the horse power stuff aren't my thing because i live in Orange County, Cali so I cannot go really fast since there's always a traffic light every quarter of a mile. And I'm also having a 2000 Camry that's why anything above is good for me..
Please give me your thoughts about my consideration. Thank you fellows.
#3
Rookie
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Oct 2013
Location: Colorado
Posts: 69
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It will be harder to find an IS with what you want at that price but you get what you pay for, a stock IS has much more options than and accord. All are good choices I would say infinity would be my last choice since reliability wont be as good.
#5
Driver School Candidate
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: ca
Posts: 4
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
There are some IS250 70k-80k @ $15-16k price range. Do you think Lexus are still good at that mileage ? I would prefer the lexus one because of its interior and exterior .
#6
Pole Position
iTrader: (4)
1. I would rule out the is250 because its probably the least reliable of the bunch. The IS350 has a much more reliable engine. Lexus as a whole is very reliable brand but certain models are underpar
2. I would rank this as probably your first or second choice base upon your criteria. You can also get some crazy deals on them
3. This is a solid engine but is quite boring IMO. It'll be very similar to your Camry just more upscale.
4. Unless your getting the tech package, this car is very behind in its amenities. Also the engine is reliable but unrefined (pretty rough and loud).
5. Nothing wrong with this car. I would put it up there with the g35 as your first or second choice.
6. At your age, insurance will kill you on this.
2. I would rank this as probably your first or second choice base upon your criteria. You can also get some crazy deals on them
3. This is a solid engine but is quite boring IMO. It'll be very similar to your Camry just more upscale.
4. Unless your getting the tech package, this car is very behind in its amenities. Also the engine is reliable but unrefined (pretty rough and loud).
5. Nothing wrong with this car. I would put it up there with the g35 as your first or second choice.
6. At your age, insurance will kill you on this.
Trending Topics
#8
Racer
iTrader: (12)
1. I would rule out the is250 because its probably the least reliable of the bunch. The IS350 has a much more reliable engine. Lexus as a whole is very reliable brand but certain models are underpar
2. I would rank this as probably your first or second choice base upon your criteria. You can also get some crazy deals on them
3. This is a solid engine but is quite boring IMO. It'll be very similar to your Camry just more upscale.
4. Unless your getting the tech package, this car is very behind in its amenities. Also the engine is reliable but unrefined (pretty rough and loud).
5. Nothing wrong with this car. I would put it up there with the g35 as your first or second choice.
6. At your age, insurance will kill you on this.
2. I would rank this as probably your first or second choice base upon your criteria. You can also get some crazy deals on them
3. This is a solid engine but is quite boring IMO. It'll be very similar to your Camry just more upscale.
4. Unless your getting the tech package, this car is very behind in its amenities. Also the engine is reliable but unrefined (pretty rough and loud).
5. Nothing wrong with this car. I would put it up there with the g35 as your first or second choice.
6. At your age, insurance will kill you on this.
#9
Driver School Candidate
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: ca
Posts: 4
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
1. I would rule out the is250 because its probably the least reliable of the bunch. The IS350 has a much more reliable engine. Lexus as a whole is very reliable brand but certain models are underpar
2. I would rank this as probably your first or second choice base upon your criteria. You can also get some crazy deals on them
3. This is a solid engine but is quite boring IMO. It'll be very similar to your Camry just more upscale.
4. Unless your getting the tech package, this car is very behind in its amenities. Also the engine is reliable but unrefined (pretty rough and loud).
5. Nothing wrong with this car. I would put it up there with the g35 as your first or second choice.
6. At your age, insurance will kill you on this.
2. I would rank this as probably your first or second choice base upon your criteria. You can also get some crazy deals on them
3. This is a solid engine but is quite boring IMO. It'll be very similar to your Camry just more upscale.
4. Unless your getting the tech package, this car is very behind in its amenities. Also the engine is reliable but unrefined (pretty rough and loud).
5. Nothing wrong with this car. I would put it up there with the g35 as your first or second choice.
6. At your age, insurance will kill you on this.
My sister and parents prefer the '08 G35 too. but at what mileage is acceptable to buy ? and is the insurance gonna be cheaper than the Lexus ? Because currently it's 1k-2k cheaper than the IS that's why it's my 2nd choice.
#10
Driver School Candidate
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: ca
Posts: 4
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
noiceeeeee car. which year is that accord ? and is the insurance gonna be a lot for me because it's a coupe
#11
Pole Position
iTrader: (7)
8th Generation Accord coupe. 2008 - 2012. From experience, you might actually get a better deal with coupes due to the probability of having less passengers in your vehicle. The insurance rate will increase with engine size (I4 vs V6), and the color (theft) - that blue will need to be looked into by a licensed agent.
#12
Pole Position
Join Date: Aug 2013
Location: Australia
Posts: 207
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I have both a 09 TSX and IS250. The TSX was my first car but the IS250 is ahead in materials + fit and finish... although the TSX had a firmer, maybe even better steering (I was like wtf because it's FWD and the IS is RWD.
I like the indicator stalks on the TSX too...when I first used the stalks in the IS250 it reminded me of the Camry we had previously had.
The TSX is $40k in Australia (marketed Accord Euro) while the IS250 is 80k.
I like the indicator stalks on the TSX too...when I first used the stalks in the IS250 it reminded me of the Camry we had previously had.
The TSX is $40k in Australia (marketed Accord Euro) while the IS250 is 80k.
#15
Lexus Test Driver
I would agree with the post above that the IS is probably the least reliable of the bunch. Its not that its not reliable but your pretty much comparing against honda which is notorious for being the most inexpensive engines to maintain that last the longest. I am also confused on why you have an ES350 in there among other sport sedans. I would expect a GS before an ES.
Honestly, if your looking for price and affordability, I would go with the Honda Accord. Peferably a coupe since the sedan doesn't look as good as the coupe. Two completely different front ends. Insurance for the coupe is actually cheaper than the IS (at least for me. Older, few tickets, no accidents). I was looking into both when I was looking at cars.
If your looking for styling and available tech, It would be a tossup between the IS250 and the TSX. Its annoying with the TSX to find a good leather interior when its pretty much standard on MOST IS sedans. But the TSX nav and tech packages are IMO much better than lexus. Both cars look pretty nice on the outside
If your looking for Power, G35 hands down. The accord V6 is pretty fast too with 280 HP but probably not as fun. I don't like the look of the g35 tho
If i had to rank them for me since i take everything into account, it would be
1. Accord Coupe
2. IS250 (tie)
2. TSX (tie)
4. G35
5. Civic.
6. Accord Sedan
7. Es350
Honestly, if your looking for price and affordability, I would go with the Honda Accord. Peferably a coupe since the sedan doesn't look as good as the coupe. Two completely different front ends. Insurance for the coupe is actually cheaper than the IS (at least for me. Older, few tickets, no accidents). I was looking into both when I was looking at cars.
If your looking for styling and available tech, It would be a tossup between the IS250 and the TSX. Its annoying with the TSX to find a good leather interior when its pretty much standard on MOST IS sedans. But the TSX nav and tech packages are IMO much better than lexus. Both cars look pretty nice on the outside
If your looking for Power, G35 hands down. The accord V6 is pretty fast too with 280 HP but probably not as fun. I don't like the look of the g35 tho
If i had to rank them for me since i take everything into account, it would be
1. Accord Coupe
2. IS250 (tie)
2. TSX (tie)
4. G35
5. Civic.
6. Accord Sedan
7. Es350
Last edited by NYKnick101; 01-29-14 at 11:32 AM.