A-Hole mechanic removed my Check Engine Light
#1
Rookie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: tx
Posts: 39
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
A-Hole mechanic removed my Check Engine Light
Bought the car used, CEL was on, dealer sent me to Alan Automotive in Richardson, jackass mech runs obd and its the O2 banks. Long story short, he couldnt remove it so he pulled my check engine light out and told me everything was ok. Now a year later, i go to get inspected and they say im throwing the same codes, except no CEL....any legal issues here? They inspected the car before i got it with obd codes thrown too.
#2
Lexus Champion
iTrader: (12)
Ok there are so many questions to be asked here.. You got me kind of lost.
So you bought the car with the CEL.. They send you to a mechanic in Richardson to FIX the CEL, correct? As in run the code and tell you what the code is and what it is that needs to be replaced? So he runs the code, TELLS YOU that it's the O2 Sensors and then you said what to him...? Did you tell him to fix it or what? You lost me when you said 'he couldn't remove it'. Do you mean he couldn't remove the O2 sensor or he couldn't turn off the CEL? Of course the CEL won't go off, it's your O2 sensors that monitor your air/fuel ratio.
So anyway... You allowed him to remove your CEL bulb and actually believed that everything was ok?
Dude if you're throwing a CEL it means that something NEEDS to be replaced.. It's never good to just ignore it..
So you bought the car with the CEL.. They send you to a mechanic in Richardson to FIX the CEL, correct? As in run the code and tell you what the code is and what it is that needs to be replaced? So he runs the code, TELLS YOU that it's the O2 Sensors and then you said what to him...? Did you tell him to fix it or what? You lost me when you said 'he couldn't remove it'. Do you mean he couldn't remove the O2 sensor or he couldn't turn off the CEL? Of course the CEL won't go off, it's your O2 sensors that monitor your air/fuel ratio.
So anyway... You allowed him to remove your CEL bulb and actually believed that everything was ok?
Dude if you're throwing a CEL it means that something NEEDS to be replaced.. It's never good to just ignore it..
#3
Racer
iTrader: (8)
Ok there are so many questions to be asked here.. You got me kind of lost.
So you bought the car with the CEL.. They send you to a mechanic in Richardson to FIX the CEL, correct? As in run the code and tell you what the code is and what it is that needs to be replaced? So he runs the code, TELLS YOU that it's the O2 Sensors and then you said what to him...? Did you tell him to fix it or what? You lost me when you said 'he couldn't remove it'. Do you mean he couldn't remove the O2 sensor or he couldn't turn off the CEL? Of course the CEL won't go off, it's your O2 sensors that monitor your air/fuel ratio.
So anyway... You allowed him to remove your CEL bulb and actually believed that everything was ok?
Dude if you're throwing a CEL it means that something NEEDS to be replaced.. It's never good to just ignore it..
So you bought the car with the CEL.. They send you to a mechanic in Richardson to FIX the CEL, correct? As in run the code and tell you what the code is and what it is that needs to be replaced? So he runs the code, TELLS YOU that it's the O2 Sensors and then you said what to him...? Did you tell him to fix it or what? You lost me when you said 'he couldn't remove it'. Do you mean he couldn't remove the O2 sensor or he couldn't turn off the CEL? Of course the CEL won't go off, it's your O2 sensors that monitor your air/fuel ratio.
So anyway... You allowed him to remove your CEL bulb and actually believed that everything was ok?
Dude if you're throwing a CEL it means that something NEEDS to be replaced.. It's never good to just ignore it..
#4
Pole Position
iTrader: (9)
Thanks for contributing to global warming and climate change =p
I would just suggest you talk to a lawyer from your area and file a civil lawsuit for selling you (that you believe) to be a malfunctioning vehicle by falsifying the mechanics and law. However your car must've been able to pass the inspection before in order for you to get a registration sticker last year. You must also have actual evidence that the O2 sensor was malfunctioning at the time of purchase or you don't have a case. They can also argue that any vehicle's catalytic converter can go bad within a years time frame. Good luck and hope justice will be served.
I would just suggest you talk to a lawyer from your area and file a civil lawsuit for selling you (that you believe) to be a malfunctioning vehicle by falsifying the mechanics and law. However your car must've been able to pass the inspection before in order for you to get a registration sticker last year. You must also have actual evidence that the O2 sensor was malfunctioning at the time of purchase or you don't have a case. They can also argue that any vehicle's catalytic converter can go bad within a years time frame. Good luck and hope justice will be served.
Last edited by rogzballz; 11-06-12 at 06:50 AM.
#5
Rookie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: tx
Posts: 39
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Ok sorry about the early morning Tablet typing rant. Heres the story. Went to purchase my 2000 GS300 had 124k on the OD. I noticed the CEL at the time I test drive it, and it had no driving issues so I purchased the car with the agreement that they would fix whatever issue it had that was throwing the codes. So the GM of the lot gave me a work order and sent me to his affiliated shop to repair it. The tech at the shop ran the codes, and it was the O2 sensors, banks 1 AND 2. So he says they will have it repaired and that was that. So after I got a call saying that they couldn't get the sensor out of the manifold, they told me to bring it back the next day. So after I took it back, they called me and said that the repairs were finished and to come get my car. The tech even had the nerves to say "All fixed, and if that CEL comes on again, then you know you have a real problem. So I ride around all year, thinking that my car is fixed, wondering why I get such horrible gas mileage. So comes time for my inspection, I go to my personal service station and they say I am throwing 2 codes, the same ones from last year, but the CEL wasn't on.....So I went to Toyota of dallas and a tech pulled my gauge cluster to find a missing screw at the bottom and a MISSING CEL!!!!!!!! I went back to the station who screwed me and they sayed I'm a lier and they didn't do it. The car lot also says I"m a lier and my car is just old and I should expect problems. They never fixed the car, and they won't fix it now. It was inspected when I purchased it, so they did it illegally knowing that the codes where tripped. I am not a scam artist. Why would I want to NOT have my CEL? That could cost you an engine. Any case there? I don't have any paper work though...that part sucks.
#6
Rookie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: tx
Posts: 39
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks for contributing to global warming and climate change =p
I would just suggest you talk to a lawyer from your area and file a civil lawsuit for selling you (that you believe) to be a malfunctioning vehicle by falsifying the mechanics and law. However your car must've been able to pass the inspection before in order for you to get a registration sticker last year. You must also have actual evidence that the O2 sensor was malfunctioning at the time of purchase or you don't have a case. They can also argue that any vehicle's catalytic converter can go bad within a years time frame. Good luck and hope justice will be served.
I would just suggest you talk to a lawyer from your area and file a civil lawsuit for selling you (that you believe) to be a malfunctioning vehicle by falsifying the mechanics and law. However your car must've been able to pass the inspection before in order for you to get a registration sticker last year. You must also have actual evidence that the O2 sensor was malfunctioning at the time of purchase or you don't have a case. They can also argue that any vehicle's catalytic converter can go bad within a years time frame. Good luck and hope justice will be served.
#7
Rookie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: tx
Posts: 39
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Trending Topics
#8
Lead Lap
iTrader: (14)
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Yokohama, Japan
Posts: 426
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
you know you could have avoided all this headache by doing one simple thing. You should have checked that the CEL actually went away. That the CEL still illuminates and then extinguishes after engine start. Another thing that you could've done was to ask the repair technician if you can visually check that the OBD reader is no showing any codes after the repair was supposedly done. A reputable repair shop should never hide anything from the customer.
#9
Pole Position
iTrader: (1)
you know you could have avoided all this headache by doing one simple thing. You should have checked that the CEL actually went away. That the CEL still illuminates and then extinguishes after engine start. Another thing that you could've done was to ask the repair technician if you can visually check that the OBD reader is no showing any codes after the repair was supposedly done. A reputable repair shop should never hide anything from the customer.
#10
Pole Position
iTrader: (9)
Idk about TX, but In MA the new owner has to get the inspection done after buying the car. We also have laws that help the buyer if they cant get an inspection sticker after 30 days after purchase.
Anyways, I think you're SOL. Hope its just the O2 sensor and not the Catalytic converter. If the ladder, Straight pipe it, lol. I think all you can do now is write a bad Yelp review ...
Anyways, I think you're SOL. Hope its just the O2 sensor and not the Catalytic converter. If the ladder, Straight pipe it, lol. I think all you can do now is write a bad Yelp review ...
#12
Lexus Fanatic
iTrader: (182)
Ok sorry about the early morning Tablet typing rant. Heres the story. Went to purchase my 2000 GS300 had 124k on the OD. I noticed the CEL at the time I test drive it, and it had no driving issues so I purchased the car with the agreement that they would fix whatever issue it had that was throwing the codes. So the GM of the lot gave me a work order and sent me to his affiliated shop to repair it. The tech at the shop ran the codes, and it was the O2 sensors, banks 1 AND 2. So he says they will have it repaired and that was that. So after I got a call saying that they couldn't get the sensor out of the manifold, they told me to bring it back the next day. So after I took it back, they called me and said that the repairs were finished and to come get my car. The tech even had the nerves to say "All fixed, and if that CEL comes on again, then you know you have a real problem. So I ride around all year, thinking that my car is fixed, wondering why I get such horrible gas mileage. So comes time for my inspection, I go to my personal service station and they say I am throwing 2 codes, the same ones from last year, but the CEL wasn't on.....So I went to Toyota of dallas and a tech pulled my gauge cluster to find a missing screw at the bottom and a MISSING CEL!!!!!!!! I went back to the station who screwed me and they sayed I'm a lier and they didn't do it. The car lot also says I"m a lier and my car is just old and I should expect problems. They never fixed the car, and they won't fix it now. It was inspected when I purchased it, so they did it illegally knowing that the codes where tripped. I am not a scam artist. Why would I want to NOT have my CEL? That could cost you an engine. Any case there? I don't have any paper work though...that part sucks.
#14
Intermediate
iTrader: (1)
One year later, it's going to be tough to prove that a shady shop screwed you over. Easy solution, cut your losses, put the $1.00 bulb back in, spend the $250 for the two o2 sensors through one of the discount vendors on this site, spray those old sensors with PB bolt blaster for a few days, get an o2 sensor socket ans change them out. You should have improved fuel economy and a working CEL light when all said and done. Pick up a cheap obd2 scanner with live data for future inspections and purchases.