Both cars are 1 owner, CPO warranty to 100k miles, both have about 48k miles, no nav, both have only the premium package. 08 listed at $22,500, 09 listed at $24,990. Both are black exterior, 09 has black interior, 08 has cashmere. I am partial to the black on black as my current BMW has. Any advice would be appreciated.

 

Try and negotiate the '09 down to $23,000. Plenty of $$ room on CPO cars to push down.

 

IMHO, black interiors are easier to keep clean than cashmere--we have both. Of course, dust will be moe obvious with black.

 

Too much money. They are $17k wholesale, you can get one for no more than $19k.