Cars Americans Do Not Want to Buy
#16
Moderator
iTrader: (16)
There was a time that the Maxima used to compete with the Taurus SHO and grand prix GTP. It was the sleeper in family car guise. 3 generations of weight gain and CVTs have completely neutered it. Between the Altima 3.5, and the g37, the Maxima is being pushed in to obsolescence by it's own cousins.
#17
The list is based on data through August, and I assume that it means for the 2013 model year as the 2013 MDXs were sitting on lots as folks were waiting on the new 2014 MDX that started hitting dealers in June. I saw one stat that in June the 2014 MDX was the fastest seller sitting on the lot only 5 days on average. This makes sense as there were probably many pre-orders. From an Acura perspective, I would have thought the RDX would be on this list. I don't think they are selling very many.
I agree re the Maxima. They aren't worth the premium vs a comparably equipped Altima.
I agree re the Maxima. They aren't worth the premium vs a comparably equipped Altima.
#18
Lexus Champion
The list is based on data through August, and I assume that it means for the 2013 model year as the 2013 MDXs were sitting on lots as folks were waiting on the new 2014 MDX that started hitting dealers in June. I saw one stat that in June the 2014 MDX was the fastest seller sitting on the lot only 5 days on average. This makes sense as there were probably many pre-orders. From an Acura perspective, I would have thought the RDX would be on this list. I don't think they are selling very many.
I agree re the Maxima. They aren't worth the premium vs a comparably equipped Altima.
I agree re the Maxima. They aren't worth the premium vs a comparably equipped Altima.
#21
Lexus Fanatic
iTrader: (20)
dayum, if a new maxima really ends up looking like that...
as for the list, another 'stetch' on correlation, although some are obviously duds like really old models or 'content and fun free' vehicles like the ilx.
it doesn't make sense because if a manufacturer is building to actual demand, then sales might still be very low, but they just don't build many. i guess that's the case with the other new 'flagship' acura, the rlx - they ain't selling many, but i guess they ain't building many either.
as for the list, another 'stetch' on correlation, although some are obviously duds like really old models or 'content and fun free' vehicles like the ilx.
it doesn't make sense because if a manufacturer is building to actual demand, then sales might still be very low, but they just don't build many. i guess that's the case with the other new 'flagship' acura, the rlx - they ain't selling many, but i guess they ain't building many either.
#22
Lexus Fanatic
1. Acura TSX Sport Wagon
#23
Lexus Fanatic
The ILX doesn't compete directly against the Focus and Golf, both of which are (generally) in a lower price and status class. Its true competitor is the Buick Verano.......which, for several reasons, as you say, is simply hammering it. (I bought a Verano myself).
Last edited by mmarshall; 09-26-13 at 06:25 PM.
#24
Lexus Fanatic
Originally Posted by Hoovey2411
9. No point of the LR2 when the Evoque is here now to fill in the small luxury chic SUV position for LR.
8. Nissan needs to continue offering this car as their flagship, but they need to step it up, the Avalon, Cadenza, Azera, Impala, Taurus are all solid.
7. The Nissan Murano really pioneered the midsize CUV class in the early 2000s, but with more players than ever it has quickly fallen out of the limelight to new players like Sorento, Edge, Santa Fe etc..
5. The Infiniti EX... Where do I begin.. Well to sum up, ax the darn thing.
4. Well the ILX is assembled well, that's about it's only strong suit. Honestly it's what the Civic should be and the ILX needs to do more and be more.
2. The C30 is a fun little hatch, and has always been competent. It needs a little more sex appeal, AWD and turbo power trains, maybe a R version. Sounds hot!
#25
Lexus Test Driver
The biggest flaw with this article is including the MDX. The new model is selling very well. Of course the old model was going to linger a little, it was on it's way out. They should have omitted the model from this list.
And did I read the ILX section right? "...not offered with an automatic transmission?" Huh?
And did I read the ILX section right? "...not offered with an automatic transmission?" Huh?
#27
Pole Position
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Montreal, QC
Posts: 392
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Interestingly, the CSX and El 1.7 did very well in Canada, because they were not much more expensive than a fully loaded Civic.
#28
Lexus Champion
I disagree. Fully loaded mass market cars like the Focus compete very well with the ILX feature wise, at a lower price point. Similarly priced cars like teh Verano have better powertrain options. We won't mention the issues with Honda's own Civic Si competing against it.
Interestingly, the CSX and El 1.7 did very well in Canada, because they were not much more expensive than a fully loaded Civic.
Interestingly, the CSX and El 1.7 did very well in Canada, because they were not much more expensive than a fully loaded Civic.
The Acura EL and CSX, the ILX's predecessors that were only available in Canada, did sell very well but I am not sure why (granted, I never drove one). They seemed to be merely leathered-up Civics to me.
When there is only $2000 or $3000 difference in price between a loaded Civic or Corolla and a base Accord or Camry, and the base Accord / Camry is a larger, better car with more features (even at the base level), it gets difficult selecting the smaller car (in North America). IMO, that argument is just impossible to make when the leathered-up smaller car (which is still obviously a Civic) is the same or higher price than the larger, better car.
$2000 or $3000 may be a fair amount of change if you are paying cash for the car, but if you are financing or leasing, the difference in monthly payment becomes almost negligible. Why lease the smaller Civic / ILX if you can lease the Accord for only a few $ more per month?
#29
Lexus Champion
Thread Starter
#30
Moderator
iTrader: (8)
No kidding!
Regarding the maxima, looks like the altima is cannabalizing it. Size wise, power wise, option wise, and design wise, looks like there's hardly a reason to get the maxima (as also previously mentioned by mrraider).
Regarding the maxima, looks like the altima is cannabalizing it. Size wise, power wise, option wise, and design wise, looks like there's hardly a reason to get the maxima (as also previously mentioned by mrraider).
Last edited by GS3Tek; 09-27-13 at 09:33 AM. Reason: quote