somnoboy

Just saw a Castrol Edge commercial making this claim. Any thoughts from the old timers?

I'm driving a first gen.

jrbump

Some people think cucumbers taste better pickled.

PureDrifter

iTrader: (10)

please search, and read up on forums like bobistheoilguy

RA40

iTrader: (6)

You can do the whole routine yourself. An oil analysis with your current oil and after the change. Report back.

The short version...doubtful you'll see any difference at this stage.

encore888

Guess this means different strokes for different folks...some prefer this oil or that...

jlattimore

Castrol publishes their industry standard test results on their website.
I have used Castrol for decades, they have always had good oil.

Jim

somnoboy

Thanks Jim. I guess my main question is whether the Castrol Edge is 8 times better than the M1 5W-30. Just wondering since I'm on the M1 right now, but certainly open to trying the Edge if it truly is 8 times better, as Castrol claims in it's current TV ad.

Banshee365

I bet the way this marketing ploy went down is Castrol deveopled a special test that their oil performed 8 times better in than Mobil 1 so they are then legally allowed to say it is 8 times better. The test may just be pointless and Mobil 1 would have no interested in ever bettering their oil in that specific test. But who knows. There is no way Edge is 8 times better overall than Mobil 1. I think saying that Edge is 8 times better overall than WD40 in your engine is a bit closer to the truth.

SChema

iTrader: (2)

Here's a good read, reason why many use Brad Penn for break in purposes.

http://store.forcedperformance.net/m...otor%20Oil.pdf

gemigniani

Castrol Edge claims are just a marketing gimmick just like Valvoline's "300,000 miles guaranteed if you use our synthetic" gimmick.

Neither Castrol or Valvoline will tell you what consequences will happen if you DON'T use their high priced synthetics because they know conventional $2.25 a quart oil lubricates a Toyota engine well enough to make it last 500,000+ miles (if changed on time and all other required engine preventive maintenance is performed on time).

iamviolet

Castro Edge is better oil. but 8x. thats kinda hard to believe.

somnoboy

I just checked out the Castrol Edge website. Looks interesting. I might just give the Edge a try next oil change...