My turn with mysterious "clunk"
#1
Advanced
Thread Starter
My turn with mysterious "clunk"
My '01 430 has developed a clunk over the past few weeks that I cannot find for the life of me. Nor can the mechanic.
It only happens when I make a fairly sharp right turn while braking. No clunking if I am not braking.
I hear a "thump" or sometimes "thump thump" coming from the left front wheel, which is the one being loaded during the turn.
I checked every single bolt/nut I could see (control arms, sway bar, crossmember, balljoints, steering, brake caliper), all are tight.
So I gave up and went to a suspension place; good place, they build race Porsches there. They looked at it, said everything in suspension is fine, but had some concerns about the brake pads being a bit loose. They adjusted that somehow, but nothing changed.
What do I do next? I don't like clunking from my suspension, I have a vision of something falling off at 80 mph... Thoughts?
It only happens when I make a fairly sharp right turn while braking. No clunking if I am not braking.
I hear a "thump" or sometimes "thump thump" coming from the left front wheel, which is the one being loaded during the turn.
I checked every single bolt/nut I could see (control arms, sway bar, crossmember, balljoints, steering, brake caliper), all are tight.
So I gave up and went to a suspension place; good place, they build race Porsches there. They looked at it, said everything in suspension is fine, but had some concerns about the brake pads being a bit loose. They adjusted that somehow, but nothing changed.
What do I do next? I don't like clunking from my suspension, I have a vision of something falling off at 80 mph... Thoughts?
#6
Lead Lap
iTrader: (1)
I am working on fixing this problem myself. As I have mentioned in other threads I was hit a few months ago so Ive been working with the repair shop to find the cause of the noise. They have replaced the lower ball joint, sway bar, and still have not identified the noise. The shop even took it to a Lexus shop to see if they could trouble shoot it, but the Lexus shop was lazy and blamed it on my drilled rotors, haha. they probably didn't even take the wheel off. I had my brakes long before the accident anyway.
It has gotten a little worse in the last few days so they are putting an electronic ear in different areas to see where its coming from (again). I will definitely post the results if and when they find out what it is.
It has gotten a little worse in the last few days so they are putting an electronic ear in different areas to see where its coming from (again). I will definitely post the results if and when they find out what it is.
#7
Lead Lap
iTrader: (2)
I have the same problem with my rear driver side tire/wheel. Every time I make a sharp turn, it seems to either squeak, wiggle, or just be plain ol' annoying.
I took it to my uncle at his garage, he tore everything apart. Down to the nuts and bolts. He found that the rotor holes were filed down from something grinding against it. Changed the rotor, hardly any sound. But now it's back. He's guessing that I have to change the ENTIRE thing for it to fix.
IDK, that might help.
I took it to my uncle at his garage, he tore everything apart. Down to the nuts and bolts. He found that the rotor holes were filed down from something grinding against it. Changed the rotor, hardly any sound. But now it's back. He's guessing that I have to change the ENTIRE thing for it to fix.
IDK, that might help.
Trending Topics
#8
Advanced
Thread Starter
Well, at least I am not alone chasing this gremlin...
Mine sounds a lot like a "pop" or "pop pop", a sharp and short noise rather than a squeak or growl/groan. Like a lot of energy is being released in a very short time.
I ordered a set of new pads, and when I put them in I'll re-check everything in the pad/caliper; hopefully something will come up.
But if not, I am just not sure how to proceed. I would hate taking it somewhere where they'll just start replacing parts blindly, that can get real expensive real fast. And besides, the suspension place I consider pretty good already looked at it and found nothing. But obviously something is there, since it is clunking.. Ugh...
Mine sounds a lot like a "pop" or "pop pop", a sharp and short noise rather than a squeak or growl/groan. Like a lot of energy is being released in a very short time.
I ordered a set of new pads, and when I put them in I'll re-check everything in the pad/caliper; hopefully something will come up.
But if not, I am just not sure how to proceed. I would hate taking it somewhere where they'll just start replacing parts blindly, that can get real expensive real fast. And besides, the suspension place I consider pretty good already looked at it and found nothing. But obviously something is there, since it is clunking.. Ugh...
#11
Pole Position
I have the same problem with my rear driver side tire/wheel. Every time I make a sharp turn, it seems to either squeak, wiggle, or just be plain ol' annoying.
I took it to my uncle at his garage, he tore everything apart. Down to the nuts and bolts. He found that the rotor holes were filed down from something grinding against it. Changed the rotor, hardly any sound. But now it's back. He's guessing that I have to change the ENTIRE thing for it to fix.
IDK, that might help.
I took it to my uncle at his garage, he tore everything apart. Down to the nuts and bolts. He found that the rotor holes were filed down from something grinding against it. Changed the rotor, hardly any sound. But now it's back. He's guessing that I have to change the ENTIRE thing for it to fix.
IDK, that might help.
#12
Lead Lap
My first gen has a click when I back out of a parking space and then hit the brakes and another when I first apply the brakes after going forward. It's the front brake pads. I've had it checked out, too. Do you think this could be the same issue you have (to the OP)?
#13
Advanced
Thread Starter
I'm beginning to think more and more that it is the brakes, either the pads or the rotor. I noticed that after the suspension place had the car and worked on the brakes, the clunk got worse!. I now get it not just on the right turns, but also when using the brakes after backing out of a parking spot. Perhaps they did not tighten the lug nuts to the spec value, so the rotor slips around a bit more (?). Anyway, new brakes should be here any day, so I will look at everything brake related very carefully and see what I see.
#14
Lead Lap
iTrader: (2)
I checked out my suspension on the rear driver side, and surprisingly, there was some gunky build up BEHIND the calipers. Just turn the wheel, shine a flash light, and you should ( hopefully ) be able to find some gunk lined in circles going around the face of the rotor.
Don't know if this is the complete problem, or even close to it. Just giving some suggestions into this.
Don't know if this is the complete problem, or even close to it. Just giving some suggestions into this.