Clunking from rear end (98 ES)
#1
Pole Position
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: TX
Posts: 273
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Clunking from rear end (98 ES)
For the past couple of days my car has had an annoying clunking sound coming from the rear end. It sounds like it's coming from the left rear (but I could be wrong) and isn't really associated with any particular event. I was thinking strut mount even though i just replaced it a year ago and it's only got like 15k miles on it.
The clunking does NOT get worse when i drive over bumps. It actually gets worse when i turn from side to side or when the body flexes (like turning into a parking lot that is at an incline).
I have no idea what kind of sound you get when the sway bar end links are toast, but I read some people get some weird noises.
I got under my car and tugged, tapped, wiggled, everything I could find and nothing was loose or broken that I could tell
Do the ES masters have any ideas?
The crazy thing about this is this is the first vehicle I've owned that didn't have a rear diff and the first time I've had clunking from my rear end
The clunking does NOT get worse when i drive over bumps. It actually gets worse when i turn from side to side or when the body flexes (like turning into a parking lot that is at an incline).
I have no idea what kind of sound you get when the sway bar end links are toast, but I read some people get some weird noises.
I got under my car and tugged, tapped, wiggled, everything I could find and nothing was loose or broken that I could tell
Do the ES masters have any ideas?
The crazy thing about this is this is the first vehicle I've owned that didn't have a rear diff and the first time I've had clunking from my rear end
#3
Lead Lap
iTrader: (10)
Hey! This thread had a few responses about clunking
Furthermore:
&
I had this issue, it was weird, when there was 'no weight in the back' so nothing no groceries/people i would hear a clunking. I have baffled by this. Furthermore the suspension components were fine and my mechanic even checked them out.
It was the sway bar bushings. And apparently the ES300 has hard plastic ones that crack/deteriorate with time... My genius mechanic took the OEM ones [new] and modified them by filling them polyurethane. Ever since, "quiet" !
Hope that helps ya out!
-Mike
Furthermore:
you say theres clunking sounds in teh rear?
i have a strong feeling its your rear sway bar bushings.
CHECK: Go under the rear of your car and just try to move around the rear sway, if it moves left to right relatively easily. most likely when you go over bumps on one side of your car it will clunk, pretty loudly. almost sounding like the strut mount bolts are loose.
new sway bar bushings can be found online and are very easy to change.
i have a strong feeling its your rear sway bar bushings.
CHECK: Go under the rear of your car and just try to move around the rear sway, if it moves left to right relatively easily. most likely when you go over bumps on one side of your car it will clunk, pretty loudly. almost sounding like the strut mount bolts are loose.
new sway bar bushings can be found online and are very easy to change.
I had this issue, it was weird, when there was 'no weight in the back' so nothing no groceries/people i would hear a clunking. I have baffled by this. Furthermore the suspension components were fine and my mechanic even checked them out.
It was the sway bar bushings. And apparently the ES300 has hard plastic ones that crack/deteriorate with time... My genius mechanic took the OEM ones [new] and modified them by filling them polyurethane. Ever since, "quiet" !
-Mike
#4
Pole Position
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: TX
Posts: 273
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
does anyone know the part number, or can i just go to a Lexus dealership and ask for sway bar bushings? Thanks for all the help
side note: I'm going to a Texas Rangers game tonight and they offer free valet to Lexus owners! (too the clunking is gonna be kind of embarrasing considering they're probably valeting new LS's and whatnot)
side note: I'm going to a Texas Rangers game tonight and they offer free valet to Lexus owners! (too the clunking is gonna be kind of embarrasing considering they're probably valeting new LS's and whatnot)
#5
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Dec 2013
Location: Nj
Posts: 7
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I spent thousands on this clunking issue and after replacing the entire front end and rear suspension parts it turned out to be the trailing arm bushings. Even if they look good replace them. 40 a pair on ebay. 20 min job. Clunk free!!!!!! Feels like a 2013.
#6
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: nj
Posts: 3
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Noises in ES300 2000 Suspension. Front and Rear
Have had similar problems over the last two years.
Have 115K miles, runs great.
Made the mistake of using front strut assemblies from Moog, Monroe and FCS, that's right, bought all of them on Amazon, and returned two sets. Now using the FCS strut assembly ($150/pair).
But- All of them started to rattle after two weeks.
This is a critical part, and the after market mounts have a spacer washer between the bearing and the mount and that's what I believe starts to rattle as the upper mount and washer have to take about 1000lbs of impact over every bump. Even on smooth blacktop, the after market mounts rattled on slight ripples in the blacktop. Even after re-torqueing the top nut, the struts rattled! The Lexus parts have no spacer.
Ended up replacing the front upper strut mounts and bearing with Lexus parts. Now rides like new. Tight and rubbery. My mechanic told me this is the way they fix front struts, to use an after market strut, but Lexus mounts and bearings. I should have believed him. Being an engineer, I could not believe that brand name manufacturers could sell such junk, so I kept changing the strut assemblies, believing it could not be the mounts. I was wrong!!!
2 years go I replaced everything on the rear suspension, including the Knuckles from Lexus, because I could not find bushings. The others parts were after market parts, and still have rattling noises, which get worse as the temp drops from the 40s into the 20s. Its a fast rattle over manholes, and sounds like its from the upper mounts on the struts.
I used trailing arms from Dorman, and alignment arms and links from Mevotec and Beck-Arnley.
All the after market parts have rubber boots that are now cracked, and therefore will cause the joints to rust. I had my mechanic grease up all the joints to keep moisture out.
I will never again use after market parts for anything that requires precision, such as Ball joints, links that have swivel bushings, etc.
Do not use any front Ball joint except from Lexus. The studs will not line up properly in the 3 holes in the Lower Arm casting. Only use Lexus nuts for the front Ball joint, they have large sleeves that fit into the Arm holes.
Sway bar links are not critical, and I have used Delco and Moog.
I have had good success with AC Delco front lower arms, the Lexus Ball joint fits then perfectly, Front Rotors and Ceramic Pads, and Centric Rear Rotors, and Akebono Ceramic Pads.
I live in Bergen County New Jersey, but order my Lexus parts from Lexus of South Atlanta, that has a great parts web site. But it takes them a week to turn around orders. But the prices are substantially less than the local Lexus dealers.
Fortunately, I have a local mechanic, who will allow me to get the parts, and I pay them only for labor. Would appreciate your feedback on these issues.
Have 115K miles, runs great.
Made the mistake of using front strut assemblies from Moog, Monroe and FCS, that's right, bought all of them on Amazon, and returned two sets. Now using the FCS strut assembly ($150/pair).
But- All of them started to rattle after two weeks.
This is a critical part, and the after market mounts have a spacer washer between the bearing and the mount and that's what I believe starts to rattle as the upper mount and washer have to take about 1000lbs of impact over every bump. Even on smooth blacktop, the after market mounts rattled on slight ripples in the blacktop. Even after re-torqueing the top nut, the struts rattled! The Lexus parts have no spacer.
Ended up replacing the front upper strut mounts and bearing with Lexus parts. Now rides like new. Tight and rubbery. My mechanic told me this is the way they fix front struts, to use an after market strut, but Lexus mounts and bearings. I should have believed him. Being an engineer, I could not believe that brand name manufacturers could sell such junk, so I kept changing the strut assemblies, believing it could not be the mounts. I was wrong!!!
2 years go I replaced everything on the rear suspension, including the Knuckles from Lexus, because I could not find bushings. The others parts were after market parts, and still have rattling noises, which get worse as the temp drops from the 40s into the 20s. Its a fast rattle over manholes, and sounds like its from the upper mounts on the struts.
I used trailing arms from Dorman, and alignment arms and links from Mevotec and Beck-Arnley.
All the after market parts have rubber boots that are now cracked, and therefore will cause the joints to rust. I had my mechanic grease up all the joints to keep moisture out.
I will never again use after market parts for anything that requires precision, such as Ball joints, links that have swivel bushings, etc.
Do not use any front Ball joint except from Lexus. The studs will not line up properly in the 3 holes in the Lower Arm casting. Only use Lexus nuts for the front Ball joint, they have large sleeves that fit into the Arm holes.
Sway bar links are not critical, and I have used Delco and Moog.
I have had good success with AC Delco front lower arms, the Lexus Ball joint fits then perfectly, Front Rotors and Ceramic Pads, and Centric Rear Rotors, and Akebono Ceramic Pads.
I live in Bergen County New Jersey, but order my Lexus parts from Lexus of South Atlanta, that has a great parts web site. But it takes them a week to turn around orders. But the prices are substantially less than the local Lexus dealers.
Fortunately, I have a local mechanic, who will allow me to get the parts, and I pay them only for labor. Would appreciate your feedback on these issues.
Last edited by solr; 12-31-13 at 04:11 PM. Reason: spelling
#7
Lead Lap
iTrader: (10)
I rarely get anything OEM since it's far too much money, and once Toyota wasn't allowed [in my area] to get Lexus parts, it made no sense.
I agree with the struts, mine started creaking the winter after putting them on.
My ball joints are Moog, and they have a zerg fitting so it is serviceable which makes it better than oem as I can grease them at any time... a lot of other member swear by Moog, especially the 2GS guys.
Furthermore i have Beck Arnley BJ's on an RX - no issues whatsoever, bolted right up. Something is not right when the BJ's cannot bolt up - they have to be physically different that the OEM design [wrong vehicle model order]. Quite a bit of exaggeration there I'm afraid....
My ES has a gangbang of A/M parts on it, Dorman front control arms, 'ebay special' rear arms [2yrs so far, no issues, and Rockauto did not have brand names at the time]. Mevotech endlinks, Moog bushings, Monroe quick struts, etc.
I agree with the struts, mine started creaking the winter after putting them on.
My ball joints are Moog, and they have a zerg fitting so it is serviceable which makes it better than oem as I can grease them at any time... a lot of other member swear by Moog, especially the 2GS guys.
Furthermore i have Beck Arnley BJ's on an RX - no issues whatsoever, bolted right up. Something is not right when the BJ's cannot bolt up - they have to be physically different that the OEM design [wrong vehicle model order]. Quite a bit of exaggeration there I'm afraid....
My ES has a gangbang of A/M parts on it, Dorman front control arms, 'ebay special' rear arms [2yrs so far, no issues, and Rockauto did not have brand names at the time]. Mevotech endlinks, Moog bushings, Monroe quick struts, etc.
Trending Topics
#8
Driver School Candidate
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: wi
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hello all. Noob to this forum, I replaced the rear struts on my 97 ES with aftermarket complete assemblies and have the clunk also. So today I pulled rear seat and rode in back while my wife drove about and feel play in the upper mount of new strut . The strut nut is tight and strut to tower nuts are also tight, After searches found this thread and appears I can put new lexus mounts on the struts. Is that the best plan or is there a way to remodel these?
#10
Lead Lap
OEM parts cost more partly because they are higher quality, partly because OEMs build lots of profit into the price, and parts operations/dealers have to keep parts on the shelf for a long time. Do you want to pay the price to get those higher quality parts? Well that is up to you. Dealers like Sewell make it a little easier cutting out some of the big markup and giving a deal to CL members.
The aftermarket stuff costs less because quite frankly the end user, local mechanic or DIYer doesn't care, they shop by price. Do you want control arm bushings that last 150k? Probably don't need that, so buying the OEM part over the Dorman arm might not make sense unless you are going to go 300k and beyond.
Now sorry to burst your bubble but a Zerk fitting is not the mark of a quality part, that means you bought a ball joint that is not sealed well enough to not need greasing. Have fun going back to the 60s having to lube your chassis! I'm still on the original sealed BJs at 108k now, how long did yours last? Now maybe the aftermarket sealed BJs aren't high quality (likely!) enough to stay sealed so the zerk fitting stuff makes sense. The OEM ball joints probably outlast any aftermarket part though, but again how long do you need them to last...
Banjodave, yes get the OEM strut mounts...
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post