6th Gen vs 5th Gen: soft/comfortable ride?
#16
2016 ES has been coming on Bridgestone or Michelin Primacy MXV4 (Not to be confused with Pilot, or MXM4). Bad news though...after years of the Primacy MXV4, Michelin is discontinuing them. They were the only consumer reports excellent tire for both comfort and noise, the new tire from them is called "Premiere". Its reviews online have been less than stellar. More grip as it wears is their sales pitch, but louder and not as soft. Assuming you can't get the MXV4s that are remaining in few sizes, most popular tire for this arena is Pirelli Cinturato P7 plus, or Toyo Versado Noir. Michelin disappointedly no longer has a quiet/soft tire, as the trend has gone to more sporty (a topic on it's own considering most drivers never drive on a track, and USA roads are rough and deteriorating rapidly). Check reviews online, several good sites.
#17
#18
Advanced
Thread Starter
For those of us wanting this, Lexus seems to only have the LS as the target car....sigh.....
#19
Lexus Fanatic
I had a 4ES like yours and a 5ES, and when I traded the 5ES I heavily considered the then new 2013 6ES, but upgraded to the GS almost entirely because of the interior.
In terms of ride, I personally never saw a ton of difference between the way my 5ES rode and the way the 6ES rode, even on back to back test drives. I was only considering cars on 17s so I can't speak to the UL and the 18s.
My 5th gen ES350 handled a good bit sharper and felt more dynamic than my 4th generation ES300, while still retaining the excellent ride.
I would not discount the GS. I actually felt my 4GS rode better than the ES when at speed, around town at low speeds it felt a good bit firmer but not uncomfortable. Its a much more substantial car.
As Mike said the Pirelli Cinturato P7 Plus are not runflats. Pirelli makes a P7 runflat but those aren't them. I put a set on my LS460 a few months ago and they ride great.
In terms of ride, I personally never saw a ton of difference between the way my 5ES rode and the way the 6ES rode, even on back to back test drives. I was only considering cars on 17s so I can't speak to the UL and the 18s.
My 5th gen ES350 handled a good bit sharper and felt more dynamic than my 4th generation ES300, while still retaining the excellent ride.
I would not discount the GS. I actually felt my 4GS rode better than the ES when at speed, around town at low speeds it felt a good bit firmer but not uncomfortable. Its a much more substantial car.
As Mike said the Pirelli Cinturato P7 Plus are not runflats. Pirelli makes a P7 runflat but those aren't them. I put a set on my LS460 a few months ago and they ride great.
#20
Advanced
Thread Starter
hmmm. good point. I should not discount the GS. I have never driven one - I should at least give it a try. ONe nice aspect for comfort about the GS is that you can get the 4 way adjustable lumbar support in the GS.
#21
Lexus Fanatic
Leases are great on the GS too, you can lease one for just a little bit more than an ES. Or if used is okay with you, you can buy a 2013 for ~ $30k which is an automotive steal IMHO.
#22
I don't understand your question. The Pirelli Cinturato P7's I pulled up seems to be listed as run-flats?
As Mike said the Pirelli Cinturato P7 Plus are not runflats. Pirelli makes a P7 runflat but those aren't them. I put a set on my LS460 a few months ago and they ride great.
Thanks, I'll take another look at them, thought I saw them listed as run-flats.
Originally Posted by SW15LS;9384241QUOTE
As Mike said the Pirelli Cinturato P7 Plus are not runflats. Pirelli makes a P7 runflat but those aren't them. I put a set on my LS460 a few months ago and they ride great.
Last edited by renegad44; 02-27-16 at 07:44 AM.
#23
Lexus Fanatic
Here they are, not run flats:
http://www.tirerack.com/tires/tires....0&autoModClar=
#24
You pulled up the wrong tires.
Here they are, not run flats:
http://www.tirerack.com/tires/tires....0&autoModClar=
Here they are, not run flats:
http://www.tirerack.com/tires/tires....0&autoModClar=
http://www.tirerack.com/tires/tires....SPXL&tab=Sizes
#25
Its about time for me to upgrade my 4th Gen (2005) ES 330. I'm going to go with another ES, I think (the other possibility would be going to a GS)
Most important to me in a car is comfort and the traditional, time honored soft/plush lexus ride. I've been reading multiple reviews indicating that the 6th Generation has a firmer ride than prior generations. So I'm almost tempted to get a pre-owned 5th generation 2012 model just to get the soft ride, although it seems silly to get a 4 year old car just for that reason. Is the ride really that different with the 6th generation? It is hard to tell on short test drives but the 6th Generation does seem firmer. Haven't encountered any major bumpy roads on test drives so far though, to really test it out.
-Boston Snowboarder
Most important to me in a car is comfort and the traditional, time honored soft/plush lexus ride. I've been reading multiple reviews indicating that the 6th Generation has a firmer ride than prior generations. So I'm almost tempted to get a pre-owned 5th generation 2012 model just to get the soft ride, although it seems silly to get a 4 year old car just for that reason. Is the ride really that different with the 6th generation? It is hard to tell on short test drives but the 6th Generation does seem firmer. Haven't encountered any major bumpy roads on test drives so far though, to really test it out.
-Boston Snowboarder
I put about 60000 miles on my 2011 ES (10000 of those miles where on OEM wheels and tires).
I've put about 100000 miles on my 2013 ES300H (6000 of those miles were on OEM wheels and tires).
The 2011 ES had a floaty ride and very comfortable. This took some getting used to after coming from an Audi. The Audi had tighter suspension. But definitely preferred the Lexus better. I actually considered keeping my 2011 ES after putting OEM wheels and tires back on before selling it. My 2013 ES300H had a firmer ride compared to my 2011 (comparing stock vs stock).
#27
I agree with Steve that the 5th and 6th generations felt very similar - almost identical to me. But I have heard that the 2016 has a softer ride.
I wish the ES would reproduce the soft ride that my 00 had. People always commented on how great it was when they hitched a ride.
I wish the ES would reproduce the soft ride that my 00 had. People always commented on how great it was when they hitched a ride.
#28
Lexus Fanatic
I would choose the Pirelli Cinturato P7 Plus. The MXV4s are hard to find, if you needed one or two to replace them it would be hard. The MXM4 is a sportier tire, and not that quiet (had them on my GS), and there have been some folks who have found the Premiers are louder than what they want.
#29
Advanced
Thread Starter
Make sure you drive a GS with the luxury package. That gets you the AVS suspension, and the additional and better wood/leather inside. That GS has incredible seats, the lumbar is just part of it. They're 18 way adjustable with an articulating backrest, power adjustable side bolsters, etc. Easily the best seats in any Lexus. In a lot of ways the GS was just as nice as my LS inside, in some ways even better.
Leases are great on the GS too, you can lease one for just a little bit more than an ES. Or if used is okay with you, you can buy a 2013 for ~ $30k which is an automotive steal IMHO.
Leases are great on the GS too, you can lease one for just a little bit more than an ES. Or if used is okay with you, you can buy a 2013 for ~ $30k which is an automotive steal IMHO.
I wish the ES350 and ES300h had an option of the 16 or 18-way seat. That really is now a inadequate lacking factor for Lexus compared to some of the competition - eg Audi A4, Hyundai Genesis have similar 12-16 way type seat options.....
If the ES300h had 16 way seats, I would probably have bought one already!
#30
Lexus Fanatic
Even the LS doesn't have the 18 way power seats you can get on the GS. The A4 and Genesis don't have seats with that level of adjustability.