SaintNexus

My sisters 22 years old. She's been married for a year now, and even have a baby (my niece is fkn adorable! But that's a different story), and she wants a new car.

Her husband (then boyfriend), got her her first car, which she currently drives: 2006 Range Rover. I think the car is a POS. He thinks it's a POS also. But my sister likes it.

She's wanting her car to be brand new. She's looking at either a Benz G Wagon or an Escalade. I personally don't like either one, and neither does my brother in law, but that's what she wants.

I'm trying to convince her to get something else, something more reliable and not that costly.

I showed her the Lexus NX; she thinks it's ugly. I showed her the Lexus GX; still feel's the same way.

I showed her the upcoming Audi Q7, but she'd rather have a G Wagon.

I suggested the BMW X5, but she still wants the G Wagon.

I don't know much about the Benz, other then it being very overpriced, and I don't think it's that reliable (can be wrong).

Anyway, what would you suggest for a spoiled girl who's been loving the Range Rover, G Wagon, and Escalade since HS? Personally, I think she just likes these cars cause it's popular among my nationality, and I think she's easily influenced; but that's just me.

pman6

Are you the same nationality as Kim Kardashian?

It sounds like sis is being heavily influenced by Kim and her family of misfits

SaintNexus

Lol. I wanted to mention Kim Kardashians, but she claims that she doesn't influence her (I think it did in the past). I mean seriously, there was a time where my sister almost looked like her. o.O

But to answer your question: yes, we're Armenian.

tex2670

Personally, I'd stay out of it and let her pick what she wants. If you steer her toward something she doesn't like, you are going to get blamed.

bitkahuna

iTrader: (20)

Since money does bot seem to be an issue, it doesn't have to be primarily about expected reliability.

Client just got a new loaded Escalade. It's awesome.

PhilipMSPT

iTrader: (5)

She wants a G Wagon.

She's gonna get a G Wagon.



It doesn't matter what you think about its cost or reliability. She's gonna get what she wants. Then she's going to deal with it.

Hoovey689

iTrader: (16)

Happy wife, happy life, or so I've been told

rominl

iTrader: (4)

but it's ok, she's not the wife, just sister

seriously, if money is no issue, just get what she wants. there are better battles to fight haha

Hoovey689

iTrader: (16)

For the OP yes. I was referring to his brother in law

Gojirra99

She's her husband's problem now, just let her gets what she wants

RNM GS3

Cant go wrong with a G-wagen or RR

Who cares about reliability? Haha

mmarshall

Well, as comfortable and competent as they are off-road (where few RR owners actually GO), reliability-wise, it probably IS a POS.

She's got a point. I'm not a big fan of the spindle-grilles myself. And neither one will have the RR's comfort-level. But both, admittedly, will likely be more reliable.

The G-Wagon is built like a tank. Shut the doors on one and the thunk is just unbelievable. It is essentially a 1980s-vintage Austrian/German military vehicle spruced in nice dress for civilian use.

Once you see how the G-Wagon is built, it's hard to pass it up if you actually have the money for one.

Again, like I said above, go check out the G-Wagon's construction/materials and you will see at least one reason for its price.

I don't know how this might (?) or might not affect either your own relationship with her as your sister or her own relationship with her husband, but, from a common-sense point of view, since she is a new mother, I'd strongly suggest her buying something maybe half of what a new RR/G-Wagon/Escalade would cost and, using the money saved to open up a fund or account for her daughter's future needs (such as medical needs or college tuition). There are PLENTY of nice SUVs on the market that can be had for 40 or 50K (even less) instead of 90-100K or more.

mmarshall

I have to at least partially disagree. It's not just a he-vs.-she marital tug-of-war. They've got a child now, with responsibilities. And they've got to plan for those responsibilities (see my last reply, just above).

For a good example, look at the way SW13GS, our CL colleague, is handling his own situation. He, IMO, is doing it correctly. His wife has twins on the way (due in February), and he is looking at something sensible and suitable for the newly-expanded family that probably won't cost half (maybe one-third) of what a RR does...and will be more reliable.

Money may not be an issue right now, but one cannot necessarily forecast the future. Either way, that child is going to grow up and have needs.

Vh_Supra26

iTrader: (1)

Just let her get whatever she wants.

/thread

cino

iTrader: (1)

My 20 years old sister just got a really loaded MB GLA250 for 52K OTD. I was convincing her to get the NX or Mazda CX-5, but nothing went through. About your case, I think she will get what she wants, no matter how much effort you spend convincing her. Let the time of ownership proves that she's wrong.