Can't decide on which SUV? any suggestions
02-15-14, 03:12 PM
#1
Rookie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2011
Posts: 82
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Can't decide on which SUV? any suggestions
Hi all,
Trying to decide on a SUV, have a 2009 RAV4 V6. but can't decide on which to get. Like one for one feature and dislike the other for other reasons.
First thought would get the RX350, really like the interior but not sure of the ride and handling, felt heavy. Also, a refresh may be coming out soon
Test drove Q5, it nice looks good, but small cargo and back seat, my RAV4 feels more bigger.
Really liked the X3, in terms of how it drives like a car, but interior does not feel as luxurious as a lexus, cargo and back seat is smaller than the RX. comparable feature to the rx gets expensive very soon.
The NX is coming out but first year model, don't want to get into that, plus so many unknown factors.
maybe once its officially announced, will be in a better position, also would need to test drive.
Really that's it i guess, what else? infinity qx60 is too big? cvt has problems?
don't like rex at all, mdx is still something to be considered, but don't know much about it.
I would be leasing, so it shouldn't be difficult, but still want to get a car that i would like for at least 3years.
I also read forums and take comments too seriously i guess so I easily change my mind if i read a few negative comments.
Can someone put some sense and give some guidance.
Trying to decide on a SUV, have a 2009 RAV4 V6. but can't decide on which to get. Like one for one feature and dislike the other for other reasons.
First thought would get the RX350, really like the interior but not sure of the ride and handling, felt heavy. Also, a refresh may be coming out soon
Test drove Q5, it nice looks good, but small cargo and back seat, my RAV4 feels more bigger.
Really liked the X3, in terms of how it drives like a car, but interior does not feel as luxurious as a lexus, cargo and back seat is smaller than the RX. comparable feature to the rx gets expensive very soon.
The NX is coming out but first year model, don't want to get into that, plus so many unknown factors.
maybe once its officially announced, will be in a better position, also would need to test drive.
Really that's it i guess, what else? infinity qx60 is too big? cvt has problems?
don't like rex at all, mdx is still something to be considered, but don't know much about it.
I would be leasing, so it shouldn't be difficult, but still want to get a car that i would like for at least 3years.
I also read forums and take comments too seriously i guess so I easily change my mind if i read a few negative comments.
Can someone put some sense and give some guidance.
02-15-14, 05:14 PM
#4
The pursuit of F
Was also going to suggest the RDX for the same reasons LexBob2 mentioned, but I believe you stated you "don't like rex at all" (You mean RDX?). What bothers me about the RDX and why I would not even consider it is for the premium price, you cannot get any of these tech features as they're not available: power tilt-telescoping steering, memory seats, BSM, rear-cross traffic alert, lane departure warning, pre-collision system, dynamic radar cruise control, HUD, ventilated seats, to name the main ones.
So RDX out. MDX and QX60 are great vehicles, but I get the impression you want something a little smaller than those, between 180-190 inches max in length.
Others to consider:
1. Volvo XC60 has most all of those tech goodies, reliability is pretty good, has a nicely finished interior, and fuel economy comparable in this class. Would be about $5K less than the RX similarly equipped. This would be my personal preference next in line to the RX, NX, X3, Highlander, and MDX.
2. Santa Fe: Can get a fully loaded with many luxury tech features including rear heated seats, with a nicely finished interior and good fuel economy, for 35K. Reliability decent.
3. Highlander 2014: It's borderline on the large side at 191 in long, but for $43K you get the Limited "Platinum" which gives practically all the tech in the RX for $10K less. It also has a really nice interior, could almost be an RX in fit and finish, and is very roomy and decent on gas.
4. Porsche Macan: I love this vehicle, but it has less interior cargo room than an X3 and is pricey at $50K + starting
Domestics:
2. Caddy SRX: Decent in reliability, finish, price, and tech features.
3. Lincoln MKC: it's a polished Ford Escape with a 2L or 2.3L Ecoboost and looks like a Q5, though to watch out for potential engine problems if past 2L Ecoboost has been any indication.
4. Jeep Grand Cherokee: It's a polished vehicle inside and out. Smooth quiet ride. Decent fuel economy. Reliability questionable. $45K gets you plenty of the bells and whistles.
Don't even bother with the MB GLK unless you really love the car. It will be redesigned soon and it's pricey, small, and outdated.
Personally, I'm waiting for the NX which we should see in Production form in about three weeks at the Geneva Auto Show. If the looks satisfy me and interior space appears to be close to the RAV4, I'll be trading in my RX for it come November!
Good luck and keep us posted.
So RDX out. MDX and QX60 are great vehicles, but I get the impression you want something a little smaller than those, between 180-190 inches max in length.
Others to consider:
1. Volvo XC60 has most all of those tech goodies, reliability is pretty good, has a nicely finished interior, and fuel economy comparable in this class. Would be about $5K less than the RX similarly equipped. This would be my personal preference next in line to the RX, NX, X3, Highlander, and MDX.
2. Santa Fe: Can get a fully loaded with many luxury tech features including rear heated seats, with a nicely finished interior and good fuel economy, for 35K. Reliability decent.
3. Highlander 2014: It's borderline on the large side at 191 in long, but for $43K you get the Limited "Platinum" which gives practically all the tech in the RX for $10K less. It also has a really nice interior, could almost be an RX in fit and finish, and is very roomy and decent on gas.
4. Porsche Macan: I love this vehicle, but it has less interior cargo room than an X3 and is pricey at $50K + starting
Domestics:
2. Caddy SRX: Decent in reliability, finish, price, and tech features.
3. Lincoln MKC: it's a polished Ford Escape with a 2L or 2.3L Ecoboost and looks like a Q5, though to watch out for potential engine problems if past 2L Ecoboost has been any indication.
4. Jeep Grand Cherokee: It's a polished vehicle inside and out. Smooth quiet ride. Decent fuel economy. Reliability questionable. $45K gets you plenty of the bells and whistles.
Don't even bother with the MB GLK unless you really love the car. It will be redesigned soon and it's pricey, small, and outdated.
Personally, I'm waiting for the NX which we should see in Production form in about three weeks at the Geneva Auto Show. If the looks satisfy me and interior space appears to be close to the RAV4, I'll be trading in my RX for it come November!
Good luck and keep us posted.
Last edited by corradoMR2; 02-15-14 at 05:22 PM.
02-15-14, 05:37 PM
#6
Lexus Test Driver
Wait for the Refreshed BMW X3 which is coming shortly - interior is improved.
To me it has the perfect combo of utility and sporty driving.
Its a great suv especially if u are leasing - u should be able to get a nice deal.
To me it has the perfect combo of utility and sporty driving.
Its a great suv especially if u are leasing - u should be able to get a nice deal.
02-15-14, 05:52 PM
#7
Guest
Posts: n/a
Hi all,
Trying to decide on a SUV, have a 2009 RAV4 V6. but can't decide on which to get. Like one for one feature and dislike the other for other reasons.
First thought would get the RX350, really like the interior but not sure of the ride and handling, felt heavy. Also, a refresh may be coming out soon
Test drove Q5, it nice looks good, but small cargo and back seat, my RAV4 feels more bigger.
Really liked the X3, in terms of how it drives like a car, but interior does not feel as luxurious as a lexus, cargo and back seat is smaller than the RX. comparable feature to the rx gets expensive very soon.
The NX is coming out but first year model, don't want to get into that, plus so many unknown factors.
maybe once its officially announced, will be in a better position, also would need to test drive.
Really that's it i guess, what else? infinity qx60 is too big? cvt has problems?
don't like rex at all, mdx is still something to be considered, but don't know much about it.
I would be leasing, so it shouldn't be difficult, but still want to get a car that i would like for at least 3years.
I also read forums and take comments too seriously i guess so I easily change my mind if i read a few negative comments.
Can someone put some sense and give some guidance.
Trying to decide on a SUV, have a 2009 RAV4 V6. but can't decide on which to get. Like one for one feature and dislike the other for other reasons.
First thought would get the RX350, really like the interior but not sure of the ride and handling, felt heavy. Also, a refresh may be coming out soon
Test drove Q5, it nice looks good, but small cargo and back seat, my RAV4 feels more bigger.
Really liked the X3, in terms of how it drives like a car, but interior does not feel as luxurious as a lexus, cargo and back seat is smaller than the RX. comparable feature to the rx gets expensive very soon.
The NX is coming out but first year model, don't want to get into that, plus so many unknown factors.
maybe once its officially announced, will be in a better position, also would need to test drive.
Really that's it i guess, what else? infinity qx60 is too big? cvt has problems?
don't like rex at all, mdx is still something to be considered, but don't know much about it.
I would be leasing, so it shouldn't be difficult, but still want to get a car that i would like for at least 3years.
I also read forums and take comments too seriously i guess so I easily change my mind if i read a few negative comments.
Can someone put some sense and give some guidance.
The RX just got refreshed, try a F-sport. Even a non-F-sport is considered to be one of the best all around SUVs and they lease very well.
New X3 was recently updated, just don't think it drives sporty cause its a BMW.
The Q5 is smallish, the SQ5 is pricey and hard to find but 330hp is a blast.
I would ignore the RDX suggestion as it seems to be something designed for 2001 and not 2014. Its missing many basic features and there is nothing luxurious about it.
Trending Topics
02-15-14, 06:05 PM
#8
While I agree about the GS being a solid first year effort, the IS has had teething problems - namely the technology. The latest infotainment system (IS, CT, GX) is nowhere near as polished as what you'll find on the rest of the line-up though the system has better features forsure like traffic/weather (when it works), cache radio, 3D maps, One-Shot address entry etc..
02-15-14, 06:08 PM
#9
Guest
Posts: n/a
While I agree about the GS being a solid first year effort, the IS has had teething problems - namely the technology. The latest infotainment system (IS, CT, GX) is nowhere near as polished as what you'll find on the rest of the line-up though the system has better features forsure like traffic/weather (when it works), cache radio, 3D maps, One-Shot address entry etc..
02-15-14, 06:47 PM
#10
The pursuit of F
^^^ agreed, apart from some technological niggles i.e. with the 3IS as Hoovey2411 is right to point out, mechanically Lexus vehicles are flawless 1st or many years in. In my case, with the 3IS, I have no NAV, and not a single issue.
02-15-14, 06:53 PM
#11
Lexus do not have first year problems like most brands
02-15-14, 07:28 PM
#12
Guest
Posts: n/a
It wouldn't push me away either. My comment was geared towards your 'absolute' sentence
Latest JD Power shows that Lexus really is the brand to get for reliability, but a Lexus is still a car no matter what. Some folks expectations are inconcievable but that's because of stereotypes and what they come to expect. But things happen, and I like to say just because you buy a Honda doesn't mean it won't be a lemon, and just because you buy a BMW doesn't mean it will have problems
Latest JD Power shows that Lexus really is the brand to get for reliability, but a Lexus is still a car no matter what. Some folks expectations are inconcievable but that's because of stereotypes and what they come to expect. But things happen, and I like to say just because you buy a Honda doesn't mean it won't be a lemon, and just because you buy a BMW doesn't mean it will have problems
….
02-16-14, 06:36 AM
#14
Lexus Fanatic
My favorite small luxury SUV is undoubtedly the Audi Q5. It is quite small though.
The Jeep is a good suggestion, $45k gets you an Overland which is a ton of vehicle and quality for the money. Reliability isn't great (I have one) but with a lease it should be okay. If you think the RX feels heavy though, the Jeep is a very heavy vehicle.
RX is a solid choice, but uninspiring IMHO.
I think the Acuras are drab...
Its out now.
The Jeep is a good suggestion, $45k gets you an Overland which is a ton of vehicle and quality for the money. Reliability isn't great (I have one) but with a lease it should be okay. If you think the RX feels heavy though, the Jeep is a very heavy vehicle.
RX is a solid choice, but uninspiring IMHO.
I think the Acuras are drab...
Its out now.
02-16-14, 10:09 AM
#15
Lexus Test Driver
to the OP. If you only plan to keep the car 3 years, you should not even worry about reliablily much, most cars carry 4 years of warranty so it's really about your preference and liking. No doubt Japanese cars are the most reliable but that's something you should care if you plan keeping the car more than 5 years.
You will hear all the options possible here. people bashing acura, lexus, bmw.. they're really all good cars for the first 4 years. All manufactures have lemons and more or less problems. I think it'll get you more confuse
Last edited by keyframe13; 02-16-14 at 10:15 AM.